It was supposed to be the greatest spectacle Broadway had ever seen. Instead, it became a punchline, a cautionary tale, and a literal deathtrap for some of the most talented performers in the industry. Spider-Man: Turn Off the Dark didn't just break records for the most expensive musical in history; it broke bones, reputations, and the traditional model of how a stage show is actually built.
Honestly, if you were around New York City in 2010 or 2011, you couldn't escape it. The headlines were relentless. You had Bono and The Edge from U2 doing the music. You had Julie Taymor—the visionary behind The Lion King—at the helm. It had a budget that ballooned past $75 million. For context, most massive Broadway musicals cost around $10 to $15 million. This was something else entirely. It was a high-wire act with no net, both figuratively and, at times, literally.
Why the Web Tangled So Badly
The ambition was the problem. Julie Taymor didn't want a "musical." She wanted a "circus-rock-opera-myth." She brought in a deep, dark, and frankly confusing storyline involving a new villain named Arachne. This wasn't the Spidey we knew from the Saturday morning cartoons. This was a weaving, metaphysical journey that left early audiences scratching their heads and checking their watches.
The technical requirements were staggering. We're talking about dozens of "fliers" soaring over the audience at high speeds. This wasn't Peter Pan gently floating toward the nursery window. These were high-speed maneuvers powered by massive, complex winch systems that required military-grade software to coordinate.
Then the injuries started.
📖 Related: Isaac Brock: Why the Modest Mouse Lead Singer Is Still Indispensable
Kevin Aubin and Nelson Beato were hurt during early rehearsals. Then came the one that stopped everyone in their tracks: Christopher Tierney. During a performance in December 2010, he fell 30 feet into the orchestra pit because a safety tether wasn't properly secured. He suffered a fractured skull, broken ribs, and a bruised lung. It was terrifying. The show became known as a "bloodbath," and the New York Department of Labor had to step in.
The Massive Creative Overhaul
Eventually, the producers had seen enough. They realized the "mythological" version of the show was a disaster. They fired Julie Taymor. Think about that for a second. Firing the woman who revolutionized Broadway with The Lion King from her own passion project. It was a huge scandal.
They brought in Philip William McKinley to "fix" it. He basically gutted the weird Arachne subplot and tried to make it more like a comic book. They hired Roberto Aguirre-Sacasa to rewrite the book. You might know him now as the guy behind Riverdale. He brought a more traditional, "geek-friendly" sensibility to the script.
The show went on hiatus for weeks. They retooled everything. They simplified the stunts. They added more humor. When it finally officially opened in June 2011—after a record-breaking 182 preview performances—it was a much more "standard" superhero story.
Critics mostly hated both versions. But the public? They were fascinated.
Was it Actually a Failure?
This is where it gets complicated. If you look at the raw numbers, the show was a financial catastrophe. It ran for about three years and closed in January 2014. Despite grossing over $200 million, it never made back that $75 million-plus investment. The weekly running costs were just too high. You had to pay for the massive crew, the specialized technicians, and the astronomical insurance premiums.
But it sold tickets. Lots of them.
For a long time, it was one of the top-grossing shows on Broadway every single week. Families loved the spectacle. Seeing Spidey fight the Green Goblin right above your head was genuinely cool, regardless of what the New York Times thought of the lyrics. It proved there was a massive appetite for "event" theater.
✨ Don't miss: Watch Drake and Josh Go Hollywood: Why This Weird Movie Still Rules
The legacy of Spider-Man: Turn Off the Dark is visible in every big-budget production we see today. It taught the industry exactly where the limit is. It showed that you can't just throw money at a technical problem and hope it resolves itself. It also served as a grim reminder of the physical toll that "spectacle" takes on the actors.
The Real Cost: Human and Financial
- The Budget: It started at $25 million and ended north of $75 million.
- The Casualties: At least five major injuries occurred during the production's run.
- The Music: Bono and The Edge’s score was widely panned as being "un-theatrical," though "Rise Above 1" got some radio play.
- The Length: It holds the record for the longest preview period in Broadway history.
People still talk about it because it was a "perfect storm" of ego, money, and technology. It was the "Titanic" of Broadway, but unlike the ship, it actually managed to sail for a few years before sinking under its own weight.
Practical Takeaways for Theater Fans and Creators
If you’re a fan of theater history or a creator looking to push boundaries, there are some pretty clear lessons to be learned from the Spidey saga.
- Technology should serve the story, not the other way around. The stunts in the original version were so complex they actually hindered the pacing of the narrative.
- Safety is non-negotiable. The production’s reputation never truly recovered from the early injuries. If you’re doing something dangerous, the margin for error must be zero.
- Know your audience. Taymor wanted a Greek tragedy; the people buying tickets wanted to see Peter Parker throw a punch.
- Check the insurance. The insurance costs for this show were reportedly among the highest in theatrical history, which is a massive drain on weekly profits.
Next time you’re in Midtown Manhattan, look up at the Foxwoods Theatre (now the Lyric). It’s been renovated since Spidey left, but the echoes of those high-flying stunts are still there. It remains the most ambitious failure in the history of the Great White Way.
To really understand the scale of what happened, you should track down the documentary Glen Hansard and Markéta Irglová didn't make—no, wait, I’m thinking of the wrong U2-adjacent project. Actually, look for the book Song of Spider-Man by Glen Berger. He was the original co-writer and he lays out the entire messy, heartbreaking, and hilarious process of how it all fell apart from the inside. It’s a masterclass in how creative dreams can turn into logistical nightmares.