When you think about the first school shooting, your mind probably jumps to the 1990s. Maybe you think of Columbine. Or maybe you go back a little further to the University of Texas tower in 1966. Most people do. But history is actually much messier and goes back way further than the 24-hour news cycle would have you believe.
Honestly, the answer to what was the first school shooting depends entirely on how you define your terms. Are we talking about a mass casualty event? A targeted assassination? A colonial skirmish?
👉 See also: The Court Case on Gay Marriage Nobody Talks About (Anymore)
If we are looking for the absolute earliest recorded instance of a gunman entering a school with the intent to kill, we have to travel back to 1764. That is more than a decade before the United States even declared independence. It happened in what is now Greencastle, Pennsylvania. It’s known as the Enoch Brown school massacre.
It wasn’t a disgruntled student. It wasn't a "loner." It was a group of three Delaware (Lenni Lenape) warriors during Pontiac’s War. They entered a log schoolhouse and killed the schoolmaster, Enoch Brown, along with ten children. Only one student, a boy named Archie McCullough, survived by hiding under the bodies of his classmates.
This event is horrific. It’s also complicated by the context of colonial warfare. Most historians treat this more as an act of war or a frontier raid rather than what we modernly classify as a "school shooting." But technically? It’s the first time a classroom became a site of organized violence with a firearm.
What Was the First School Shooting by a Student?
If you're asking about the modern phenomenon—a student bringing a weapon to school to settle a grievance—the timeline shifts to the 19th century. This is where the records get grainy. Local newspapers in the 1800s didn’t always make national headlines, but the archives are full of "affrays" and "outrages."
In 1853, a student named Matthew Ward brought a pistol to the Louisville Male High School in Kentucky. He wasn't there to target a crowd. He was there for the principal, W.H.G. Butler. Ward’s brother had been disciplined the day before, and Matthew felt his family honor was at stake. He shot Butler in his office. Butler died.
The trial was a circus. It was a massive scandal. Ward was actually acquitted after a high-priced legal defense, which caused literal riots in the streets of Louisville. People burned effigies of the jury. It was a mess.
Why we ignore the 1800s
We tend to overlook these because they don't fit our current mental model. In the 19th century, violence was handled differently. Schools weren't "gun-free zones." In many rural areas, students brought rifles to school because they hunted on the way home. Violence was often seen as an individual dispute rather than a systemic failure.
But the frequency might surprise you. Between 1850 and 1900, there were dozens of recorded incidents.
- In 1867, a 13-year-old in Missouri shot his classmate for teasing him.
- In 1884, in Iowa, a student shot a teacher over a dispute about a desk.
- In 1891, an elderly man fired a shotgun at a playground full of children in New York.
It happened. We just didn't have the terminology to group them together.
✨ Don't miss: The Missouri Congressional District Map Nobody Talks About
The Shift to Mass Violence: The Bath School Disaster
You can't talk about what was the first school shooting without mentioning the one that wasn't actually a shooting—at least, not primarily. If we define "school shooting" by the scale of the tragedy and the targeting of a whole community, the 1927 Bath School Disaster is the dark milestone.
Andrew Kehoe was a school board treasurer in Bath Township, Michigan. He was angry about taxes. He was angry about losing an election. He spent months planting hundreds of pounds of dynamite under the school.
On May 18, 1927, he detonated the explosives.
As rescuers arrived, Kehoe drove his truck up to the school and blew it up too, killing himself and several others nearby. 44 people died, most of them children.
While Kehoe did use a rifle to detonate some of the explosives in his truck, this event is technically a bombing. Yet, it serves as the historical pivot point. It showed that schools could be targets for mass indiscriminate slaughter. It changed the psyche of the American education system forever, even if we buried the memory for a few decades.
The Sniper Era and the 1966 Texas Tower
For many Boomers and Gen Xers, the real answer to "what was the first" is Charles Whitman. On August 1, 1966, Whitman climbed to the top of the University of Texas Tower in Austin.
He was a former Marine. He was a sharpshooter.
For 96 minutes, he held the campus hostage. He killed 14 people and wounded over 30 others. This was the first time the entire nation watched a school shooting happen in almost real-time via news broadcasts.
📖 Related: Stephen Paddock: Why We Still Don’t Have a Motive for the Las Vegas Shooting Suspect
This event created the blueprint for the modern response. It led to the creation of SWAT teams across the country. Police realized they weren't equipped for a "sniper" scenario. Before this, the idea of a mass shooter on a campus was basically unthinkable in a civil defense context.
Debunking the "New Phenomenon" Myth
There's a common belief that school shootings didn't exist before the 1990s. That’s just factually wrong.
What changed wasn't the presence of violence, but the type of violence and the media's role in it. Early incidents were usually "one-on-one." A student mad at a teacher. A teacher mad at a student. A romantic rivalry gone wrong.
The 1979 Cleveland Elementary School shooting in San Diego is a chilling example of the shift. Brenda Spencer, 16 years old, fired at children from her window across the street. When asked why, she famously said, "I don't like Mondays."
This was one of the first times we saw a "random" motive. It wasn't about a grade or a specific fight. It was about a general nihilism. That’s the thread that eventually leads to Columbine in 1999.
Key Historical Milestones:
- 1764: Enoch Brown (First recorded school massacre, Pennsylvania)
- 1853: Louisville, KY (First high-profile student-on-teacher shooting)
- 1891: St. Mary's Parochial School, NY (A man fires at students with a shotgun; no fatalities, but huge news at the time)
- 1927: Bath School Disaster (The deadliest act of school violence in US history)
- 1966: UT Austin (The first "modern" televised mass shooting)
- 1979: Brenda Spencer (The "I Don't Like Mondays" shooting)
Why History Matters for Today
Looking back at what was the first school shooting isn't just a trivia exercise. It's about seeing patterns. We often hear that this is a "mental health crisis" or a "gun access crisis" or a "social media crisis."
While those things are true today, the 19th-century incidents tell us that schools have always been vulnerable points of friction in a community. The difference now is the lethality of the tools and the speed of the "copycat" effect.
Research by organizations like The Violence Project shows that shooters often study previous events. They look for the "first" or the "biggest." By understanding that this isn't a brand-new problem, we can stop looking for a "quick fix" and start looking at the long-term cultural issues that make schools targets.
Summary of Insights
Identifying the "first" depends on your criteria:
- Oldest Recorded: Enoch Brown (1764)
- First Individual Student Action: Louisville (1853)
- Deadliest Historical Event: Bath School (1927)
- First Modern/Televised Mass Shooting: UT Austin (1966)
If you are researching this for a project or for policy reasons, the most important thing is to look at the primary sources. Don't just rely on viral social media posts that claim school shootings didn't exist before 1990. They did. They were just reported differently.
Next Steps for Researchers:
- Visit the Library of Congress "Chronicling America" digital archives. Search for terms like "schoolhouse affray" or "pistol school" in the 1800s. You will find hundreds of local reports.
- Read "Ceremonial Violence: A Psychological Explanation of School Shootings" by Jonathan Fast. It provides deep context on how these events evolved from individual disputes to public "performances."
- Check the K-12 School Shooting Database. It is one of the most comprehensive sets of data available, tracking every time a gun is brandished or fired on school property.
Understanding the timeline helps strip away some of the political noise. It allows us to see these tragedies as a long-standing, complex part of the American story that requires more than just a surface-level solution.