Ever wonder why Garfield sounds so different depending on which decade you grew up in? If you’re a child of the 80s, Lorenzo Music is the undisputed king of the lasagna-loving feline. But for a whole new generation, the CGI era brought a different vibe. We're talking about The Garfield Show, that French-American production that ran from 2008 to 2016. It’s a weirdly polarizing show, honestly. Some fans love the high-energy slapstick, while others miss the dry, jazz-infused mood of the old Garfield and Friends.
But here’s the thing. The The Garfield Show cast had some big shoes to fill.
📖 Related: Where Is The Hills Have Eyes Streaming Right Now?
Voice acting isn't just about mimicry. It’s about soul. When Mark Evanier and the team at Paws, Inc. moved into the 3D world, they didn’t just want a copy of the past. They needed a cast that could handle the frantic pace of 214 episodes. That's a lot of Mondays.
Frank Welker: The Man Who Inherited the Lasagna
Frank Welker is a legend. You've heard his voice thousands of times without even realizing it. He's Megatron. He's Scooby-Doo. He’s basically every animal noise in every movie you’ve ever seen. But taking over the role of Garfield was a massive deal.
Lorenzo Music had passed away in 2001. After a brief stint with Bill Murray in the live-action films—which, let's be real, even Murray makes jokes about now—the franchise needed a "permanent" voice for the small screen. Welker wasn't just a random pick. He actually worked on the original Garfield and Friends as various supporting characters and incidental voices. He knew the rhythm.
Welker’s Garfield is a bit more energetic than Music’s. It’s less "I am too tired to move" and more "I am actively plotting your demise while thinking about pasta." He brings a certain snarky bounce to the character that fits the CGI animation style. In the CGI show, Garfield moves fast. He does physical comedy that the 2D version wouldn't dream of. Welker handles that transition by keeping the dry wit but adding a layer of theatricality.
Gregg Berger and the Art of Being Odie
Odie doesn't talk. Well, mostly. He pants, barks, and occasionally makes "humanoid" noises of frustration or joy. You might think that makes Gregg Berger’s job easy. It doesn’t.
Berger is one of the few cast members who stayed consistent from the old 1980s show. He is the bridge between the two eras. In The Garfield Show, Odie’s role shifted slightly. He became more of a companion and less of a punching bag—though Garfield still kicks him off the table plenty of times. Berger’s ability to emote through nothing but whimpers and barks is honestly a masterclass in non-verbal acting.
Interestingly, Berger also voices Squeak the mouse in this series. This was a change from the comics and the original show, where Garfield generally didn't have a "best friend" who was a mouse (because, you know, he’s a cat). Squeak provides a foil for Garfield’s laziness. Berger gives Squeak a high-pitched, fast-talking persona that contrasts perfectly with his own deep-voiced work in other franchises like Transformers (where he was Grimlock).
The Human Element: Wally Wingert as Jon Arbuckle
Jon Arbuckle is a tough character to play. He’s a loser, but he has to be a lovable loser. If he’s too pathetic, the show becomes depressing. If he’s too cool, the dynamic with Garfield breaks.
✨ Don't miss: Do You Know a Secret? Beatles Lyrics, Lennon's Childhood, and the Truth Behind the Track
Wally Wingert took over the role for the CGI series. Before him, Thom Huge had defined the character for decades. Wingert leans into the "awkward nerd" energy. His Jon is constantly trying his best—dating Liz, trying to manage the house, attempting to be a cartoonist—and constantly failing.
Wingert’s voice has a slightly higher pitch and a more frantic edge than previous versions. It matches the 3D Jon’s exaggerated facial expressions. Whether he’s screaming "GARFIELD!" or trying to impress Dr. Liz Wilson, Wingert keeps the character grounded in a weird kind of optimism. He also voices several side characters throughout the series, showing off a range that most casual viewers miss.
Supporting Players Who Defined the World
The world of The Garfield Show is surprisingly populated. It isn't just the trio in the house.
- Julie Payne as Dr. Liz Wilson: Payne brought a dry, professional, yet somehow affectionate tone to Liz. In this series, Jon and Liz actually start dating properly, which was a huge shift from the "perpetual rejection" of the comic strips.
- Jason Marsden as Nermal: Nermal is the "world's cutest kitten" and Garfield’s primary antagonist. Marsden plays Nermal with a deceptive sweetness that hides a deeply manipulative streak. It’s a great "love to hate" performance.
- Stan Freberg as Dr. Whipple: A legendary satirist and voice actor, Freberg’s involvement was a nod to old-school animation fans. His recurring role as the world-renowned (and often fraudulent) psychologist added a layer of meta-humor.
Why the Voice Direction Changed
Mark Evanier, who wrote most of the episodes, has been very open about the creative choices made for the The Garfield Show cast. The show was produced in France by Dargaud Media. This meant the animation had a different "squash and stretch" philosophy than American 2D animation.
The voices had to be bigger.
In the 80s show, the humor was often quiet. A long pause, a half-lidded stare, and a deadpan remark. CGI doesn't do "quiet" as well. The lighting is brighter, the colors are more saturated, and the characters move with a lot of kinetic energy. The cast had to match that. If Frank Welker had used the exact same low-energy monotone as Lorenzo Music, the character would have felt disconnected from his own body.
Misconceptions About the Cast and Production
A lot of people think The Garfield Show was a "cheap" reboot. While the early CGI definitely looks dated by today’s standards (it was 2008, after all), the voice talent was top-tier. These weren't "budget" actors. These were some of the most expensive and sought-after names in the industry.
Another common myth is that the cast recorded separately because it was an international production. Actually, for most of the run, the main cast recorded together in Los Angeles. This "ensemble" recording is why the timing of the jokes feels so sharp. You can hear the actors playing off each other’s energy, especially during the long-winded arguments between Jon and Garfield.
Complexity in the Sound Booth
It’s worth noting that the show dealt with some weird scripts. The Garfield Show took some bizarre sci-fi turns. There were aliens, parallel dimensions, and talking pizzas.
The cast had to play these absurd scenarios with a straight face. When Frank Welker has to act out a scene where Garfield is a superhero or fighting a giant robotic dog, he has to maintain the core of the character. That’s the trick. No matter how weird the plot gets, Garfield still has to sound like he’d rather be sleeping.
Welker has often mentioned in interviews that he tries to find the "itch" in the character. For Garfield, the itch is hunger and annoyance. Even when he’s saving the world, he sounds annoyed that he has to be the one to do it.
The Legacy of the CGI Era
When the show ended in 2016, it left behind a massive library of content. For kids born after 2000, this is the definitive Garfield. They don't hear Lorenzo Music when they read the Sunday funnies; they hear Frank Welker.
The The Garfield Show cast succeeded because they didn't try to be a cover band. They didn't just play the hits. They evolved the characters for a medium that required more noise, more speed, and more expressiveness.
Is it "better" than the original? That’s subjective. Honestly, the 80s show has a charm that CGI can’t touch. But the CGI show has a technical complexity in its voice acting that the old show didn't always require. Dealing with the "Lip Sync" was a nightmare for the actors, as the animation was sometimes timed to the French guide tracks first. The English cast had to fit their performance into pre-existing mouth movements, which is a specialized skill called "dubbing to lip flaps." It’s incredibly restrictive, yet Welker and the gang made it sound natural.
Actionable Takeaways for Fans and Creators
If you're a fan of voice acting or looking to understand why certain shows "feel" a certain way, look at the credits. You'll start to see patterns.
- Study the "Welker Method": If you're an aspiring voice actor, listen to how Frank Welker differentiates his "Garfield" from his other characters. It’s all in the placement of the voice—back of the throat, slightly nasal, very little chest resonance.
- Appreciate the Ensemble: Re-watch an episode like "Orange and Black" and pay attention to how Wally Wingert (Jon) and Frank Welker (Garfield) overlap. The "natural" feel comes from the actors being in the same room.
- Check out the Guest Stars: The show featured voices like June Foray and Marvin Kaplan. These are legends of the "Golden Age" of animation. Finding their episodes is like finding hidden treasure for animation nerds.
- Follow the Writers: Mark Evanier’s blog is a goldmine of information about the production of this show. If you want to know the "why" behind the "who," his archives are the place to go.
The cast of this show proved that Garfield is a character that can survive a change in technology. Whether it's ink and paper, hand-drawn cells, or pixels, the voice is what keeps the cat alive. And in the case of The Garfield Show, the voices were in very capable hands.