Let's be real for a second. If you’ve spent more than five minutes on TikTok or scrolled through "Stan Twitter" in the last few years, you’ve seen the videos. They’re usually set to eerie slowed-down music. They claim to show "proof" of Hailey Bieber's dangerous decade long obsession with her now-husband Justin Bieber and, by extension, his ex-girlfriend Selena Gomez.
It’s a rabbit hole. A deep, messy, often mean-spirited rabbit hole.
But what’s actually true? People love a villain arc. They love the idea of a "fan girl" who schemed her way into a marriage. However, when you actually look at the timeline—the real one, not the one edited by a 14-year-old with a grudge—the "obsession" narrative starts to look less like a psychological thriller and more like the chaotic reality of growing up in the Hollywood fishbowl.
✨ Don't miss: Winston Churchill: What Most People Get Wrong About His Final Years
The "Stalker Fan" Label That Won't Quit
The internet has a long memory. It’s also very good at taking things out of context to fit a specific vibe. The core of the Hailey Bieber's dangerous decade long obsession theory rests on tweets from 2011 and 2012.
Back then, Hailey Baldwin was just another teen on Twitter. She tweeted about "Jelena." She said she was "100% team Jelena." To some, this is proof of a tactical "Keep your friends close and your enemies closer" strategy. To everyone else? It looks like a teenager being a fan of the biggest pop star on the planet.
Honestly, who wasn't?
The narrative shifted from "Hailey is a fan" to "Hailey is a predator" almost overnight when she and Justin actually got serious. Critics point to photos of her waiting outside hotels or posing with Justin at fan meet-and-greets. They call it "stalking." But here’s the thing: Hailey’s father is Stephen Baldwin. She wasn’t some random kid from the suburbs; she was a Baldwin. She moved in the same social circles as the Jenners and the Hadid sisters. The idea that she was "hunting" him down ignores the fact that they were introduced by her father in 2009 at the Today show.
It was an industry introduction, not a sidewalk ambush.
Why the "Mean Girl" Tropes Are So Sticky
We need to talk about the 2023 "Eyebrow Gate." You remember it. Selena Gomez posted about laminating her eyebrows too much; hours later, Kylie Jenner and Hailey Bieber posted a FaceTime screenshot of their eyebrows.
The internet exploded.
This moment fueled the Hailey Bieber's dangerous decade long obsession fire more than almost anything else. It wasn't just about Justin anymore. It was about an alleged decade-long campaign to bully the "rightful" queen of the fandom.
But if we look at the facts, both women have repeatedly asked for the narrative to stop. Selena Gomez eventually had to step in on Instagram, asking fans to stop the death threats against Hailey. "Hailey Bieber reached out to me and let me know that she has been receiving death threats and such hateful negativity," Selena wrote.
That’s the part the "obsession" videos usually leave out.
If this were a truly dangerous obsession, would the "victim" of that obsession be the one shielding the "obsessor" from public vitriol? Probably not. It’s more likely a case of two women being pitted against each other by a public that refuses to let the 2010s die.
The Mental Health Toll Nobody Discusses
Social media is a vacuum. It sucks out the humanity and leaves only the "content."
Hailey has been vocal about how this narrative affects her. In her "Call Her Daddy" interview with Alex Cooper—which was basically a masterclass in PR damage control—she addressed the "stole him" rumors head-on. She clarified that she was never with Justin while he was in a relationship with Selena.
"I can say, period, point blank, I was never with him when he was in a relationship with anybody — that’s the end of it," she said.
People didn't believe her. Why? Because the "dangerous obsession" story is more fun. It’s a movie plot. The reality—that a guy and a girl drifted in and out of each other's lives for years before finally deciding to grow up and get married—is boring.
Examining the Proof: Fact vs. Fan Fiction
Let's break down the "evidence" often cited for Hailey Bieber's dangerous decade long obsession and see how it holds up under actual scrutiny.
- The Tweets: Yes, she tweeted support for Justin and Selena. Most of it was typical fan girl behavior from 15 years ago.
- The Style Mimicry: TikTok users often post "side-by-sides" of Hailey wearing an outfit similar to something Selena wore weeks prior. Is it obsession? Or is it two wealthy women following the exact same Pinterest trends and hiring the same three celebrity stylists?
- The Tattoos: Both women have a "g" tattoo behind their ear. The obsession theorists say Hailey copied Selena. The reality? They both got the tattoo for a young girl named Georgia who had a rare brain disorder. It was a tribute, not a copycat move.
When you peel back the layers, the "danger" seems to exist almost entirely in the comments section.
🔗 Read more: Caitlyn Jenner 2025 Explained: What Really Happened with the Return to TV and That Israel Trip
The Timeline of a Very Public Marriage
Justin and Hailey’s relationship didn't happen in a vacuum. It happened during Justin’s very public struggle with mental health, Lyme disease, and the pressures of child stardom.
In his documentary, Our World, and his YouTube series, Seasons, we see a different side of the dynamic. We see a man who was deeply struggling and a woman who became his "anchor." This doesn't look like an obsession-driven power grab. It looks like a partnership.
Does she look at him with intensity? Sure. Is she protective of her marriage? Clearly. But labeling that as a Hailey Bieber's dangerous decade long obsession ignores the agency of the man involved. It treats Justin like a prize to be won rather than a person who made a choice.
Moving Past the Parasocial Grudge
It’s 2026. The Bieber marriage has outlasted many of its critics' own relationships. They have a child now. They have a life.
The obsession narrative is a relic of a parasocial culture that refuses to let celebrities evolve. It relies on "confirmation bias"—where people look for evidence to support what they already believe while ignoring everything that contradicts it.
👉 See also: Josh Duhamel Ex-Wife: What Really Happened With Fergie and Where They Are in 2026
If you want to understand the Hailey/Justin/Selena dynamic, you have to accept that it’s probably much more mundane than the internet wants it to be. It’s a story of young people, bad timing, social media pressure, and eventual maturity.
Actionable Insights for Navigating Celebrity Culture
If you find yourself getting sucked into the "obsession" rabbit holes, here are a few ways to keep your perspective grounded in reality:
- Check the Source: Most "evidence" for these theories comes from edited fan accounts. Always look for the original, unedited video or interview to see the full context.
- Acknowledge the Baldwin Factor: Remember that Hailey grew up in the industry. Her proximity to Justin was a result of her social circle, not just her being a "fan."
- Recognize the "Mean Girl" Archetype: Media often relies on the "Good Girl vs. Bad Girl" trope to drive clicks. Don't fall for a narrative just because it feels like a movie plot.
- Respect the Boundaries: Both Selena Gomez and Hailey Bieber have asked for these comparisons to stop. The most respectful thing a fan or observer can do is take them at their word.
The real story isn't about a dangerous obsession; it’s about the danger of a public that refuses to let people change.