It happens every December. You walk into a living room and see it: a sprawling evergreen decked out in blue and white ribbons, maybe topped with a Star of David instead of an angel. Or perhaps there's a menorah sitting on a side table just inches away from a pine tree smelling of balsam and nostalgia. Some people call it a "Hanukkah bush." Others see it as a "Chrismukkah" hybrid. But for those living in interfaith households, the Hanukkah and Christmas tree conversation isn't just about decor. It's about identity. It's about trying to figure out how two very different stories—one about a miracle of oil and national liberation, the other about a divine birth and universal peace—can occupy the same four walls without one swallowing the other whole.
Honestly, it’s complicated.
For decades, the presence of a tree in a Jewish home was seen as the ultimate sign of assimilation. It was a "shanda"—a shame. But things have shifted. According to the Pew Research Center’s 2020 study on Jewish Americans, roughly 17% of Jews lived in households that had a Christmas tree. If you look specifically at intermarried couples, that number jumps significantly. We’re not talking about a fringe movement anymore; we’re talking about a lived reality for millions of people who are trying to respect their heritage while making room for their partner’s childhood memories.
The Friction Behind the Hanukkah and Christmas Tree
Let's be real: Hanukkah is a "minor" holiday in the Jewish calendar. It’s not Yom Kippur. It’s not Passover. Historically, it gained massive prominence in the United States primarily because it falls near Christmas. Jewish parents in the 20th century didn’t want their kids to feel left out of the "December Magic," so they leveled up. They added more gifts. They added blue and silver tinsel. And, eventually, some added the tree.
But there’s a theological rub here. Hanukkah, at its core, is a celebration of the Maccabees fighting against Hellenization—the blending of Jewish culture with outside Greek influences. There is a profound irony in celebrating a holiday about resisting cultural erasure by adopting the most iconic symbol of another religion. This is why many rabbis and community leaders still view the Hanukkah and Christmas tree combo with a bit of a side-eye. It feels like a contradiction.
Yet, for a kid growing up in a home with one Jewish parent and one Christian parent, that tree doesn't represent the Seleucid Empire. It represents Grandma's cookies. It represents the smell of the woods. It represents a family coming together. When you try to strip that away, you aren't necessarily "protecting" Judaism; you might just be creating resentment.
What a "Hanukkah Bush" Actually Is (And Isn't)
The term "Hanukkah bush" is kinda a joke that stayed past its welcome. It started as a way for secular Jewish families to participate in the greenery of the season without technically having a "Christmas" tree.
- Some people use a small, tabletop rosemary plant or a blue spruce.
- They decorate it with gelt (chocolate coins) and wooden dreidels.
- It’s meant to be a middle ground, but it often satisfies no one.
Strict traditionalists think it's a weak attempt to hide a Christmas tree, while secularists often find it a bit kitschy. But for some families, it’s the perfect compromise. It says, "We like the lights, but we’re sticking to our own narrative."
Navigating the Intermarried "December Dilemma"
Interfaith couples often hit a wall when December 1st rolls around. One person wants the 8-foot Douglas fir; the other feels a visceral, inherited guilt just looking at it. This isn't just about aesthetics. It's about "The December Dilemma," a term coined to describe the stress interfaith families face when navigating competing traditions.
If you're in this boat, you've probably realized that you can't just "split the difference" and end up with a holiday that feels right. You have to talk about the why. Does the tree represent Christ to you, or does it represent "Home"? Does the absence of a tree represent Jewish survival, or just a lack of fun?
Dr. Keren McGinity, an expert on interfaith marriage and a Research Associate at the Hadassah-Brandeis Institute, has noted that the "how" matters more than the "what." If a family decides to have a Hanukkah and Christmas tree setup, but they also light the menorah and teach the story of the Maccabees, the Jewish identity doesn't just evaporate. It becomes part of a broader, more complex tapestry.
🔗 Read more: Why 700 Tchoupitoulas Street New Orleans Still Anchors the Warehouse District
The Aesthetic Clash: Blue vs. Red
There's a funny thing that happens with the color palettes. Christmas is traditionally red and green (symbols of blood and eternal life in Christian iconography). Hanukkah is blue and white (the colors of the Israeli flag and the tallit). When you try to put blue lights on a green tree, it looks... okay, actually, it looks pretty cool.
But the "Hanukkah tree" isn't a thing in Israel. If you go to Tel Aviv in December, you’ll see menorahs everywhere. You might see some trees in the Christian quarters of Jerusalem or Jaffa, but the "blended" look is a uniquely American phenomenon. It's a byproduct of the melting pot.
How to Do Both Without Losing the Meaning
If you've committed to the Hanukkah and Christmas tree lifestyle, there are ways to make it feel intentional rather than accidental. You don't want your living room to look like a holiday aisle at a big-box store threw up.
- Keep the symbols separate but equal. Place the Hanukkah menorah (chanukiah) in a window as per tradition. It’s meant to "publicize the miracle." The tree can be in the corner for the family to enjoy. Mixing them too closely can lead to "symbol fatigue" where everything just blurs into a generic holiday mush.
- Tell the separate stories. On Christmas Eve, read about the Nativity or focus on the spirit of giving. On the nights of Hanukkah, focus on the bravery of the few against the many and the miracle of the oil.
- Own the hybridity. If you’re doing "Chrismukkah," lean into it. Make latkes and serve them with applesauce, then have ginger cookies for dessert.
Some people think this "watering down" of religion is dangerous. They worry that by trying to do everything, we end up teaching our kids nothing. But others argue that in a world that is increasingly polarized, a home that can hold space for both the Hanukkah and Christmas tree is a home that is teaching empathy and pluralism.
The Surprising History of Jews and Trees
Believe it or not, the idea of Jews having trees isn't entirely new or entirely about Christmas. In the late 19th and early 20th centuries, many highly assimilated German Jews had "Hanukkah trees." Even Theodor Herzl, the father of modern Zionism, reportedly had a Christmas tree in his home. To him, it wasn't a religious symbol but a German cultural one.
In America, the department store culture of the 1920s and 30s—largely driven by Jewish entrepreneurs like the Gimbels and Strauses—helped turn Christmas into a secular, commercial holiday. This made it "safer" for Jewish families to adopt certain customs. If Christmas was just about Santa and shopping, why couldn't a Jewish family participate?
This secularization is exactly what bothers religious leaders. If you strip the "Christ" out of Christmas and the "Maccabee" out of Hanukkah, you’re just left with a lot of plastic and calories.
Actionable Steps for a Stress-Free December
If you're struggling with how to handle the Hanukkah and Christmas tree situation this year, here’s how to actually move forward without a family feud:
👉 See also: How to Use Dip Powder Without Ruining Your Natural Nails
First, define your boundaries. Sit down with your partner before the decorations come out. Is the tree a non-negotiable? Does it have to be in the main room? Can we agree that there are no "Hanukkah ornaments" and instead keep the tree purely "Christmas" while the Hanukkah celebrations stay distinct?
Second, educate yourself (and the kids). Don't just put up decorations because they look pretty. Read the history. Know why the Maccabees fought. Know why the star is on the tree. When children understand the origins of the symbols, they are less likely to get confused by the overlap.
Third, create "New-Old" traditions. Maybe your family tradition is that on the Friday of Hanukkah, you have a massive Shabbat dinner under the lights of the tree. It’s weird. it’s modern. It’s you.
Fourth, respect the calendar. Some years, Hanukkah and Christmas overlap perfectly. Other years, Hanukkah is over before the tree even goes up. Use the calendar's natural spacing to give each holiday its own "breathing room." When Hanukkah is early, let it be the star of the show. When it’s late, let the tree provide the backdrop for the candle lighting.
At the end of the day, your home is not a museum. It’s a place where people live. If a Hanukkah and Christmas tree can coexist in a way that makes everyone feel seen and loved, then maybe that’s a small miracle in itself.
Don't let the "rules" of the past dictate the peace of your present. Decide what values you want to pass on—whether that's religious purity, cultural heritage, or simply the ability to love someone whose background is different from your own. Focus on the light. Whether it's coming from a wax candle or a pre-lit LED string, the world can always use more of it in the middle of winter.