Alan Moore hates what Hollywood did to his books. That's not exactly a news flash—the guy is famous for disavowing basically every adaptation of his work, from Watchmen to V for Vendetta. But The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen is different. It wasn’t just a bad adaptation; it was the movie that literally drove Sean Connery into retirement and became a cautionary tale for how to ruin a perfectly good concept.
If you only know the 2003 film, you’re missing out on one of the most dense, literate, and frankly bizarre pieces of fiction ever printed. The original comic isn't some Victorian version of the Avengers. It’s a dark, often uncomfortable deconstruction of British imperialism, sexual politics, and the very idea of heroism.
The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen and the "Justice League" Trap
When 20th Century Fox got their hands on the property, they saw dollar signs in a "superhero team-up" before the MCU was even a glimmer in Kevin Feige’s eye. They wanted a blockbuster. They wanted gadgets. They wanted a younger American lead so the US audience wouldn't feel left out. Enter: Tom Sawyer as a secret agent.
Honestly, adding Tom Sawyer was the first sign of trouble.
In the original source material by Alan Moore and Kevin O'Neill, the roster is intentionally gritty. You have Mina Murray—the survivor of Dracula’s assault—acting as the actual leader. She’s not some "vampire queen" with superpowers like in the movie; she’s a traumatized but fiercely intelligent woman navigating a world of toxic men. Then you have Allan Quatermain, who isn't a suave Sean Connery type. He’s a pathetic, opium-addicted shell of a man when we first meet him.
The movie stripped that away. It turned a nuanced character study into a CG-heavy mess where Mr. Hyde looks like a bloated rubber balloon.
Why the 2003 Film Fell Apart
It’s hard to overstate how chaotic the production of The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen actually was. Filming in Prague was hit by catastrophic flooding that destroyed over $7 million in sets. But the real storm was the relationship between director Stephen Norrington and Sean Connery.
They hated each other.
🔗 Read more: AMC on 84th Broadway: What Most People Get Wrong
Connery, an old-school professional, couldn't stand Norrington’s more experimental and allegedly disorganized directing style. Reports from the set described shouting matches that halted production for days. By the time the film was released to scathing reviews, Connery was done. He famously said he was "fed up with the idiots" now making movies in Hollywood. He never made another live-action film.
The Hidden Depth of the Comics You Probably Missed
If you move past the film and look at the books, The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen is a massive literary scavenger hunt. Moore and O'Neill didn't just pick famous names; they built a cohesive universe where every single fictional character ever written exists in the same timeline.
It’s meta-fiction on steroids.
In the background of panels, you’ll see posters for the "Cavorite" from H.G. Wells' The First Men in the Moon. You’ll see references to Moll Flanders or characters from 18th-century penny dreadfuls. It’s a celebration of literature that rewards people for having a library card.
But it’s also incredibly bleak.
- Captain Nemo isn't a noble scientist; he’s a man who hates the British Empire with a burning passion and is arguably a terrorist.
- The Invisible Man (Hawley Griffin) is a literal psychopath and a rapist. He isn't a misunderstood hero; he's a monster who uses his invisibility for the most heinous crimes imaginable.
- Mr. Hyde is a hulking brute, yes, but his relationship with Jekyll is portrayed as a horrific, parasitic addiction.
The comics explore what happens when you take these "extraordinary" people and force them to work for a government that is just as corrupt as the villains they are fighting. It’s cynical. It’s brilliant. And it’s nothing like the popcorn flick people remember.
✨ Don't miss: Why Ludacris lyrics Stand Up Still Define the 2000s
The Copyright Nightmare That Almost Killed the Series
One of the reasons The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen is so unique—and so difficult to adapt—is the legal tightrope it walks. Most of the characters in the first two volumes (Quatermain, Nemo, Griffin, Jekyll) were in the public domain. This allowed Moore to do whatever he wanted with them.
However, as the series progressed into the 20th century, Moore started using characters that were still under copyright.
He had to get creative. He couldn't call a certain spy "James Bond," so he called him "Jimmy" and implied his identity through context clues. He used a version of Mary Poppins that was essentially a terrifying ancient deity. This "remix culture" approach is what makes the books rank so high in the hearts of comic fans, but it's a legal minefield for any movie studio.
How the League Influenced Modern Storytelling
Even though the movie was a flop, the DNA of The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen is everywhere now. You can see its influence in shows like Penny Dreadful, which took the "Victorian Avengers" concept and actually applied the horror elements that the movie ignored.
The idea of "Shared Universes" owes a massive debt to Moore’s work. Before the Avengers or the Justice League were household names for non-comic readers, Moore was proving that you could take disparate characters from different sources and weave them into a single, high-stakes narrative.
He just did it with more literary flair.
The Problem With Modern Reboots
Every few years, rumors surface that Disney (which now owns the rights via the Fox acquisition) wants to reboot The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen. Fans are torn. On one hand, a high-budget HBO-style miniseries could finally do justice to the darker themes of the books. On the other hand, there’s a fear that Disney will "sanitize" it again.
You can't really make a faithful League story without the grit. If you take away Nemo’s hatred of the West or Mina’s trauma, you just have a generic action team.
What You Should Do If You Want to Experience It Right
If you’re actually interested in this world, stop looking for the DVD in a bargain bin. You need to go to the source.
Start with Volume 1. It’s the most accessible. It introduces the team as they try to stop a gang war in London involving Fu Manchu (referred to as "The Doctor" for legal reasons) and Professor Moriarty. The art by Kevin O'Neill is scratchy, detailed, and perfectly captures the grime of Victorian England.
Once you finish that, move to Volume 2, which is basically a retelling of War of the Worlds but from the perspective of the League. It’s much more violent and features one of the most shocking "hero" deaths in comic history.
👉 See also: Where to Find the Florida Project Stream Without Getting Scammed
Avoid the "Black Dossier" unless you’re prepared for a massive headache. It’s a meta-textual experiment that includes 3D sections, fake postcards, and a ton of dense prose that even some hardcore fans find exhausting. It's brilliant, but it's not a light read.
Essential Reading Order:
- Volume I: The formation of the team and the Moriarty conflict.
- Volume II: The Martian invasion and the betrayal within the team.
- The Black Dossier: A bridge between the Victorian era and the 1950s (optional but recommended for lore junkies).
- Volume III: Century: A story told across 1910, 1969, and 2009. It tracks the decline of the world and the League itself.
- Nemo Trilogy: Spin-off graphic novels focusing on Nemo’s daughter, Janni Dakkar.
The real "extraordinary" thing about this series isn't the powers. It's how Alan Moore managed to take the dusty characters from your high school English syllabus and make them feel dangerous again. The movie treated them like superheroes; the books treat them like the flawed, broken, and sometimes evil people they were always meant to be.
If you want to understand the League, you have to embrace the weirdness. You have to be okay with the fact that your favorite literary heroes are probably terrible people. Once you accept that, the series opens up into one of the most rewarding reading experiences in the medium.
Actionable Next Steps for Fans:
- Track down the "Gallery Editions": If you want to see Kevin O'Neill's art in its full glory, these oversized editions show the original ink lines and corrections.
- Read the "New Traveler's Almanac": Located at the back of the first two volumes, these text pieces map out the entire fictional world. It’s a masterclass in world-building.
- Watch 'Penny Dreadful': If you want the "vibe" of the League but in a high-quality TV format, this is the closest you will ever get to a faithful spiritual adaptation.
- Skip the 2003 film: Unless you want to watch it as a "so bad it's good" experience with friends, it adds nothing to the legacy of the characters.