Look at the water long enough and your mind starts playing tricks. It’s dark. It’s cold. Loch Ness is deeper than the North Sea, and honestly, it feels like it when you’re standing on the banks of Urquhart Castle. People have been obsessed with what’s lurking down there for nearly a century, ever since a certain "surgeon" snapped a photo that turned out to be a toy submarine. But even with the hoaxes, the theories of the Loch Ness monster keep evolving because we just can't quit the idea of a prehistoric survivor.
Most people think of Nessie as a dinosaur. They picture a Plesiosaur—that long-necked marine reptile that supposedly missed the memo on extinction 66 million years ago. It’s a cool image. It sells keychains. But if you talk to a biologist, they’ll tell you it’s basically impossible. Plesiosaurs were cold-blooded. The Loch is an average of 42 degrees Fahrenheit. You do the math.
The Giant Eel Hypothesis: What the DNA Actually Says
In 2019, a guy named Professor Neil Gemmell from the University of Otago led a massive "eDNA" expedition. They took water samples from all over the Loch. The idea is simple: everything that lives in water leaves behind skin cells, scales, or waste. If there was a giant reptile, or even a shark, they’d find its genetic signature.
They didn't find any monster DNA. No sturgeon. No catfish. No plesiosaur.
What they did find, however, was a massive amount of eel DNA. Like, a lot. Gemmell suggested that the theories of the Loch Ness monster might just boil down to overgrown European eels (Anguilla anguilla). If an eel stayed in the Loch and didn't migrate to the Sargasso Sea to breed, could it grow to be ten or fifteen feet long? It's a stretch. Most eels top out at a few feet. But in the murky water of the Highlands, a thick, dark shape undulating near the surface looks a whole lot like a "monster" to a panicked or excited tourist.
It’s less glamorous than a dinosaur. I get it. Nobody wants to buy a "Loch Ness Eel" plushie. But scientifically? It’s one of the few theories that actually has data backing it up.
Why We Keep Seeing Things: The Optical Illusion Factor
The Loch is a weird place geographically. It’s long, narrow, and straight. This creates something called a "seiche"—a standing wave in an enclosed body of water. When the wind blows a certain way, or a boat passes miles away, the wake can travel and bounce off the steep underwater walls. By the time it reaches you, the boat is gone, but the wave remains, often appearing as a series of dark humps moving against the current.
Then there’s the logs.
📖 Related: Forest Lawn Memorial Park Glendale CA: Why It’s Way More Than a Cemetery
Scots pine logs are heavy. When they fall into the water and become waterlogged, they sink. But as they decay, gases build up inside the wood. Eventually, the log becomes buoyant enough to shoot to the surface like a torpedo, bob for a second, and then sink back down as the gas escapes. If you’re looking at the water at the exact moment a 10-foot log breaches, you’re going to tell everyone you saw Nessie.
The Elephant in the Water
This is my favorite "debunking" story. In the 1930s, when the Nessie craze really took off, there were several traveling circuses in the area. Bertram Mills, a famous circus owner, actually offered a reward for the monster. But some researchers, like paleontologist Neil Clark, pointed out that circuses would often stop by the Loch to let their animals bathe and drink.
An elephant swimming is mostly submerged. All you see is the top of the head, the hump of the back, and the trunk sticking up.
Think about that shape for a second.
Long neck? Check.
Bulky body? Check.
If you didn't know a circus was in town, you'd swear you were looking at a creature from the Jurassic period. It’s a perfect example of how the theories of the Loch Ness monster are often just a cocktail of timing, lighting, and cultural expectation.
Greenland Sharks and Other Misplaced Travelers
Some people think the monster is a "lost" visitor. The Loch is connected to the sea via the River Ness. It's rare, but large marine animals have been known to wander into freshwater.
- Greenland Sharks: These things are ancient. They can live for 400 years. They’re slow, dark, and look like living rocks.
- Atlantic Sturgeon: These can grow to 12 feet long and have bony plates that look like armor. They’re "living fossils."
- Wels Catfish: They aren't native to Scotland, but they were introduced to the UK for sport. They’re massive, flat-headed predators that can gulp down a bird.
The problem with all of these? None of them have long necks. Most Nessie sightings describe a "periscope" neck. Fish and sharks just don't do that. So, we're back to the drawing board, or we have to admit that maybe the sightings are a mix of different things happening at different times.
The Power of Folklore and the "Kelpie"
Before the "Surgeon’s Photo" in 1934, the locals didn't really talk about a "monster." They talked about Water Horses or Kelpies. These were shape-shifting spirits that lured children into the water to drown them. It was a dark, cautionary folklore designed to keep kids away from the dangerous, freezing depths of the Loch.
🔗 Read more: Where is Halifax Nova Scotia Canada? What Most People Get Wrong
When the road was built along the northern shore in 1933, the Loch became accessible to the public. Suddenly, the "Spirit of the Water" became a "Biological Mystery." We traded magic for science, but the core human need stayed the same: we want there to be something big and scary in the deep.
Facts to Consider Before Your Next Visit
If you're heading to Drumnadrochit to do some monster hunting, keep these realities in your back pocket. The Loch is 23 miles long. It contains more freshwater than all the lakes in England and Wales combined.
- Visibility: It’s nearly zero. The water is packed with peat particles. Even with high-tech sonar, you’re basically looking through a thick fog.
- Temperature: It stays a constant, bone-chilling cold year-round. This isn't a tropical lagoon where life thrives in abundance.
- Food Source: This is the big one. To support a breeding population of 15-foot predators, there would need to be tons of fish. Like, literally tons. The Loch’s biomass just doesn't support a family of monsters.
Actionable Insights for the Curious
If you want to dive deeper into the theories of the Loch Ness monster without falling for the clickbait, here is how you should actually look at the evidence.
First, visit the Loch Ness Centre in Drumnadrochit. They’ve moved away from the "it's definitely a dinosaur" vibe and now focus on the actual scientific surveys, including the 1987 "Operation Deepscan." It’s much more grounded in reality and honestly more fascinating.
Second, look into the "Atmospheric Refraction" studies. In certain weather conditions, light bends over the water’s surface, making small objects like ducks or floating bottles look like towering, distorted necks.
👉 See also: Why Newark Penn Station is Actually the Best Way into Manhattan
Finally, accept the nuance. It's likely that Nessie isn't one thing. It's probably a combination of 10% rare animal sightings (like wandering seals or large eels), 40% misidentified logs and waves, and 50% the human brain's desperate desire to see a monster.
To get the most out of your research, focus on the 1933-1934 newspaper archives. Seeing how the "legend" was manufactured in real-time by journalists looking to sell papers is a masterclass in media history. You'll find that the "monster" as we know it today was largely a creation of the early 20th-century press, built on the bones of ancient Highland myths.
Plan your visit during the "shoulder" seasons of May or September. The light is lower, the crowds are thinner, and the "mirage" effects on the water are much more common. Whether you see a monster or just a very convincing piece of driftwood, you'll understand why this place still haunts our imagination.