In the fall of 1999, Melissa Joan Hart was the face of wholesome teen television. She was Sabrina Spellman. She was the girl-next-door who talked to her cat and navigated high school with a literal magic wand. Then, a single magazine cover almost burned it all down. If you were around back then, you probably remember the Melissa Joan Hart Maxim cover. It was everywhere. But what most people don't realize is that the "scandal" wasn't just about a few photos—it was a legal and professional nightmare that happened on what Hart now calls the absolute worst day of her life.
Honestly, the timing couldn't have been weirder. Hart was in the middle of a massive PR push for her movie Drive Me Crazy. She was 23 years old, trying to prove she was more than just a "teenage witch." But the world wasn't quite ready for Clarissa to explain that much.
One Night, Two Firings, and a Breakup
Imagine you're at the premiere of your big-budget rom-com. You’re posing on the red carpet with Britney Spears. You look happy. But behind those eyes, things are falling apart. Hart recently opened up about this on the Pod Meets World podcast, and the details are kinda wild.
Before she even got to the party, she had broken up with her boyfriend. Then, while sitting in a limo on her way to the airport to film a cameo for Scary Movie, she got a phone call. She was fired. Apparently, the producers decided she wasn't "vivacious" enough—or, to put it bluntly, they wanted someone with a different body type for the opening scene.
She headed back to the Drive Me Crazy after-party at Planet Hollywood, probably just wanting a drink and a hug. Instead, her lawyer met her at the door.
"You did a photo shoot for Maxim?" he asked.
"Yeah," she said.
"Well, you’re being sued and fired from your show."
Basically, in the span of a few hours, she lost two jobs and a relationship. She ended up crying in her father's arms in the middle of the party while the world thought she was celebrating a movie launch.
The "Sabrina" Loophole That Almost Cost Everything
The problem wasn't just that she was in her underwear. This was the late '90s; everyone was doing Maxim. The issue was the branding. The October 1999 cover of Maxim didn't just feature Melissa Joan Hart. It featured a headline that screamed: "Sabrina, your favorite witch without a stitch!"
That was a massive legal red flag.
Hart’s contract with Archie Comics (who owned the rights to the Sabrina character) had a very specific clause. It stated she would never play the character naked or in a suggestive way. Because Maxim used the name "Sabrina" on the cover, the lawyers argued she was portraying the character in a way that violated the "wholesome" image requirements.
Here’s the thing: Hart didn't write the headline. She was there to promote Drive Me Crazy. She was posing as herself, Melissa. But in the eyes of the corporate suits, the line between the actress and the character had been blurred enough to justify a breach of contract lawsuit.
💡 You might also like: What Really Happened With Rachel Maddow Heart Surgery Rumors
Why she didn't actually get fired
- Lack of Control: Hart and her team argued she had zero say over what Maxim wrote on the cover.
- The Apology: She ended up writing a formal apology letter to smooth things over.
- Ratings: Let’s be real—Sabrina the Teenage Witch was a juggernaut. Firing the lead over a lingerie shoot that was actually driving more interest to the show wasn't a great business move.
Eventually, the "firing" threat evaporated, and she stayed on the show until it ended in 2003. But the stress of those weeks was real.
The Playboy Aftermath and No Regrets
You’d think after nearly losing her career, she’d stay far away from "men’s magazines." But the Maxim shoot actually led to an even bigger offer: Playboy. They offered her a massive payday to do a full spread.
She turned it down.
It wasn't because she was ashamed. Hart has been pretty vocal lately about the fact that she felt empowered during that era. She was 23, she had a great body, and she was tired of being treated like a kid. But she saw the toll the Maxim cover took on her family. Her younger brother was being teased at school, and her dad was getting comments at work. She decided that while Maxim was a "fun, risky" move for her career, Playboy was a step too far for her family's sanity.
✨ Don't miss: Lindsay Lohan Surgery Before and After: What Really Happened With Her Transformation
Plus, there’s the ecstasy factor. In a bit of a "truth is stranger than fiction" twist, Hart admitted years later that she had actually come straight to that Maxim shoot from a party at the Playboy Mansion. She hadn't slept, she was still feeling the effects of some party favors, and she was basically running on pure adrenaline.
What the Maxim Scandal Teaches Us Now
Looking back, the Melissa Joan Hart Maxim situation is a perfect time capsule of how the industry treated young women in the '90s and early 2000s. You were expected to be "sexy" enough to sell tickets and magazines, but "pure" enough to stay on a family-friendly network. It was a narrow tightrope to walk.
If you’re a creator or someone managing a public image today, there are a few takeaways from Hart’s experience:
- Read the fine print on "Character Rights": If you’re known for a specific role, your "private" shoots can still be legally linked to that role if the publication uses the character's name.
- The "Worst Day" isn't the End: Hart's career didn't die that night. In fact, Drive Me Crazy became a cult classic, and she went on to have another hit series with Melissa & Joey.
- Control the Narrative: Hart’s decision to finally tell the full story—ecstasy, breakups, and all—on her own terms shows the power of owning your history rather than letting old tabloid covers define you.
The controversy is now just a footnote in a long, successful career. It’s a reminder that even when it feels like the world is ending because of a PR blunder, usually, it’s just another Tuesday in Hollywood.
If you want to understand more about how '90s stars navigated these transitions, you can look into the contracts of other Archie Comics stars from that era or check out Hart's memoir, Melissa Explains It All.