The Messenger Story of Joan of Arc: What Most People Get Wrong About the Maid of Orleans

The Messenger Story of Joan of Arc: What Most People Get Wrong About the Maid of Orleans

She was an illiterate teenager from a tiny village who changed the map of Europe. It sounds like a movie script. Honestly, if you didn't know the history, you'd think it was total fiction. But the messenger story of Joan of Arc isn't just about a girl who heard voices; it’s about a girl who convinced the most powerful men in France to listen to her.

How did she do it?

📖 Related: 30 Divided by 7: The Math Most People Get Wrong

Most people think she just showed up at the palace and everyone bowed down. That’s not how it happened. Not even close. It was a long, gritty, and often humiliating process of proving she was a legitimate divine messenger rather than a crazy peasant girl or, worse, a tool of the devil.

The First "Message" at Domrémy

Joan’s journey didn't start with a sword. It started in a garden. Around 1424, when she was roughly 12 or 13, she claimed to hear the voice of God for the first time. She later identified these voices as St. Michael, St. Catherine, and St. Margaret.

Initially, the messages were simple. Be good. Go to church. But as the Hundred Years' War dragged on and the English pushed further into French territory, the messages got specific. Very specific. They told her she had to leave her home, lift the siege of Orléans, and lead the Dauphin (the uncrowned King Charles VII) to Reims to be crowned.

Imagine being a teenager today and telling your parents you need to lead the army because a saint told you so. Her father, Jacques d'Arc, wasn't exactly thrilled. In fact, he had dreams of her running off with soldiers and basically told her brothers that if she tried anything, they should drown her. He wasn't being a monster; he was a medieval peasant trying to protect his daughter’s reputation in a world where "unaccompanied woman" usually meant something very different.

Vaucouleurs: The Persistence of a Messenger

To get to the King, Joan had to go through Robert de Baudricourt, the garrison commander at Vaucouleurs. This is where the messenger story of Joan of Arc really gains its legs. She didn't just walk in and get an escort.

The first time she asked him for help in 1428, he literally told her cousin to take her home and beat her.

She didn't quit.

She came back in early 1429. This time, something was different. The city of Orléans was on the brink of falling. The French were desperate. Joan made a specific prediction about a military defeat near Orléans (the Battle of the Herrings) before news could have possibly reached the town. When the news arrived days later, matching her claim, Baudricourt finally gave her an escort.

She cropped her hair. She put on men’s clothes—not for "fashion" or identity politics, but for sheer survival and modesty while traveling hundreds of miles with a pack of rough soldiers. This choice would later be used to kill her, but at the time, it was a practical necessity for a girl on a mission.

The "Sign" and the Secret at Chinon

When Joan finally reached the royal court at Chinon, Charles VII was skeptical. Who wouldn't be? He famously hid in the crowd of courtiers while someone else sat on the throne to test her. Joan, despite never having seen him, walked straight to the real Charles.

But even that wasn't enough.

They talked privately. History doesn't have a transcript of what was said, but whatever it was, it changed Charles’s mind. Historians like Kelly DeVries suggest she may have given him a "sign" regarding his own legitimacy. At the time, there were rumors Charles was a bastard and not the rightful heir. If Joan—a random peasant—confirmed his secret prayers or his lineage, it would have been the ultimate proof of her messenger status.

Why the Church Had to "Verify" the Message

You've got to understand the medieval mind. They didn't just worry about "crazy." They worried about "demonic." If Charles followed a girl sent by the devil, his soul was forfeit and his kingdom was cursed.

So, they sent her to Poitiers.

📖 Related: Why Easy Homemade Spaghetti Sauce With Fresh Tomatoes Beats the Canned Stuff Every Single Time

For weeks, a panel of high-level theologians grilled her. They looked for "signs" of her being a messenger. One of the most famous exchanges happened here. A monk asked her why, if God wanted to save France, He needed soldiers. Joan’s reply was legendary: "The soldiers will fight, and God will give the victory."

Basically, she was saying God doesn't do the laundry for you; He gives you the strength to scrub the clothes. The priests found nothing but "goodness, humility, virginity, devotion, and honesty." They cleared her to go to Orléans.

The Messenger Becomes the Leader

In April 1429, Joan arrived at Orléans. She wasn't a general in the modern sense. She was more of a "warrior-prophet" or a "mascot-commander." She carried a white banner featuring Christ and the words "Jhesus Maria."

She sent letters to the English. These letters are some of the best evidence of her "messenger" persona. She didn't say, "I think you should leave." She said, "Yield to the Maid sent by God, the King of Heaven." She spoke with an authority that infuriated the English commanders, who called her a "cow-girl" and a "slut."

They stopped laughing when she broke the siege in just a few days.

The messenger story of Joan of Arc reached its peak when she stood beside Charles VII as he was crowned in Reims Cathedral. She had fulfilled the impossible prophecy. She had delivered the message.

The Capture and the Trial of the Voices

History is rarely kind to its heroes. In 1430, Joan was captured by the Burgundians and sold to the English. The subsequent trial wasn't about war crimes; it was a religious trial. The English needed to prove she wasn't a messenger of God. If she was a saint, then the English were the ones fighting against God.

👉 See also: Gents Wedding Reception Dress: What Most Guys Get Wrong About Post-Ceremony Style

They focused on her voices. They tried to trip her up with "trap" questions.

One of the most famous moments in legal history happened when they asked her if she was in a state of grace. This was a catch-22. If she said "yes," she was being arrogant (since no one can know God’s mind). If she said "no," she was admitting she was a fraud.

Her answer? "If I am not, may God put me there; and if I am, may God so keep me."

The judges were stunned. It was the answer of a theological genius, coming from a girl who couldn't read or write.

The Tragic End and the Legacy

Ultimately, the court used her "men's clothing" as the legal technicality to burn her at the stake in 1431. They called her a "relapsed heretic." As the flames rose, she didn't curse them. She asked for a cross to be held up. She cried out the name of Jesus until she died.

It took 25 years for the Church to admit they'd made a mistake. A "nullification trial" was held, and she was declared innocent. In 1920, she was officially canonized as a saint.

The messenger story of Joan of Arc is complicated. It’s a mix of military history, religious mysticism, and a 19-year-old girl’s sheer willpower. Whether you believe she actually talked to angels or was just a brilliant, charismatic leader who used the language of the time to get things done, you can't deny the impact. She took a fragmented, dying nation and gave it a reason to exist.

Actionable Steps for History Lovers

If you want to dive deeper into the actual documents—not just the legends—here is how you should proceed:

  • Read the Trial Transcripts: The most reliable source for Joan’s own words is the record of her 1431 trial and the later 1456 nullification trial. Look for the translation by W.P. Barrett; it’s widely considered the standard.
  • Study the Siege of Orléans: To understand the military side, look into the specific tactics used. Joan wasn't just a figurehead; she pushed for aggressive frontal assaults that the French generals were too afraid to try.
  • Visit the Primary Sites: If you ever travel to France, skip the tourist traps and go to Domrémy-la-Pucelle. Seeing the humble house she was born in puts the scale of her journey into a haunting perspective.
  • Check Out "The Maid and the Queen": Nancy Goldstone’s book offers a fantastic look at the political maneuvering behind Joan’s rise, specifically the role of Yolanda of Aragon. It adds a layer of "realpolitik" to the spiritual narrative.

Joan wasn't a victim of her times. She was the architect of them. She took a message that no one wanted to hear and shouted it until the world had no choice but to listen.