You probably remember the old days of the 3 p.m. to 7 p.m. slot. It was Michael, Don, and Peter. They had this specific, chaotic chemistry that felt like a family dinner where everyone was trying to talk over the person holding the mashed potatoes. But things have changed. A lot.
If you’re looking for the Michael Kay show live today, you aren't finding it in the drive-time evening slot anymore. Since early 2025, the show has shifted to a leaner, meaner midday window from 1 p.m. to 3 p.m. ET. It’s a solo venture now. Kay is flying without his long-time wingmen, Don La Greca and Peter Rosenberg, who moved to their own show, Don, Hahn & Rosenberg, right after him.
Honestly, the "solo" tag is a bit of a misnomer. Kay still has his regulars. He’s still the voice of the Yankees, which means he’s still the guy who has the most "insidery" info in the city. But the vibe is different. It’s tighter. Two hours instead of four. It’s a sprint, not a marathon.
Where to Find The Michael Kay Show Live Right Now
The biggest hurdle for fans has been the frequency flip. For years, 98.7 FM was the home. Not anymore. ESPN New York moved its primary operations to 880 AM (WHSQ). If you’re trying to catch the show live, you’ve basically got three main options:
👉 See also: Toronto Blue Jays Baseball World Series History: Why Those Back-to-Back Rings Still Hit Different
- The Radio: Tune your dial to 880 AM if you’re in the New York tristate area.
- The App: The ESPN New York app is pretty much the gold standard for stability here.
- Digital Stream: You can find it on the iHeartRadio app or TuneIn.
It’s important to note that the YES Network simulcast, which was a staple for a decade, ended in late 2024. You won't see Michael’s purple dress shirts on your TV screen during the 1 p.m. hour anymore. It’s back to the roots—pure radio.
The New Midday Schedule
The station did a massive reshuffle to combat the ratings juggernaut over at WFAN. Here is how the block looks for a typical weekday in early 2026:
- 10 a.m. – 1 p.m.: Bart & Carlin (Bart Scott and Chris Carlin reunited, finally).
- 1 p.m. – 3 p.m.: The Michael Kay Show.
- 3 p.m. – 7 p.m.: Don, Hahn & Rosenberg.
The Peter Rosenberg "Feud" and Why It Matters
New York sports radio lives for drama. Lately, the biggest story hasn't been about the Yankees' rotation or the Giants' coaching search; it’s been about Michael Kay telling Peter Rosenberg, "You’re dead to me."
This isn't some scripted bit for the cameras. It actually started over a wrestling podcast. Peter praised Joe Tessitore as the "best point guard" (the guy who sets everyone else up) he’s ever worked with. Michael, being famously sensitive about his standing as the lead dog, took it personally.
"Michael is the bride at every wedding and the corpse at every funeral," Peter joked recently. "Everything has to be Michael!"
This kind of friction is exactly why the Michael Kay show live still gets people talking even after two decades. Even when they aren't on the same show, the ecosystem of ESPN New York revolves around Kay’s personality. He’s the sun, and everyone else is just trying not to get burned by his take on Cody Bellinger's contract.
Who’s Still Coming on the Show?
Because Michael is now in the midday slot, the guest list has become more focused on "breaking the news" of the day rather than just recapping last night’s game. In the first few weeks of January 2026, we've seen a heavy rotation of heavy hitters:
- Dan Orlovsky: Usually shows up to break down the latest NFL disaster.
- Mike Lupica: Still the elder statesman providing the "back in my day" context for Yankees fans.
- Chris Simms: Always good for a controversial take on quarterback mechanics.
- Ian O'Connor: The guy you want when there’s a major coaching change in the works.
The show has become less about the "Would Ya" Wednesday antics (though fans still beg for them) and more about the immediate pulse of the city. When the Giants hired John Harbaugh recently, Kay’s show was the first place fans went to hear a measured, if slightly defensive, take on the New York front office.
Why the Ratings Battle Still Rages
Let’s be real. The "Middays" are a dogfight. For years, Kay trailed Craig Carton and Evan Roberts. Now that Carton is back at WFAN (after his own brief departure to FS1), the competition is even fiercer.
Michael has admitted that the ratings matter to him. He’s competitive. He wants to win. But the 1 p.m. to 3 p.m. slot is a different beast. It’s about being the bridge between the morning commute talk and the afternoon drive-time madness. By moving to a solo format, Kay has eliminated the "cross-talk" that sometimes bogged down the old show. It’s just him, his opinions, and your phone calls.
How to Get Involved (Live Calls)
If you want to get on the air, the number hasn't changed in forever: 1-800-919-3776.
🔗 Read more: Why the Football World Cup 2014 Schedule Still Haunts Brazil
Be warned, though. Michael has zero patience for "bad callers" these days. If you don't have a point within the first 10 seconds, he’s going to drop you faster than a pop fly in center field. He’s looking for people who actually watch the games, not just people who want to complain about the price of chicken buckets at the stadium.
Actionable Ways to Listen and Engage
If you’re a die-hard fan or a newcomer trying to figure out the new landscape, here is your playbook for staying updated:
- Subscribe to the Podcast: If you miss the 1 p.m. to 3 p.m. window, the "Hour 1" and "Hour 2" podcasts are usually up on Apple Podcasts and Spotify by 4 p.m. ET.
- Follow the Socials: The show's Twitter/X feed is the best place to see which guests are coming on ten minutes before they actually speak.
- Check the YES Network Schedule: While the live simulcast of the radio show is gone, Michael still does his CenterStage interviews and, of course, the Yankees play-by-play.
- Use the "Listen Back" Feature: The ESPN New York app allows you to rewind the live stream, which is a lifesaver if you tune in at 1:30 and missed the opening monologue.
The 2026 version of the Michael Kay show live is lean, focused, and undeniably Michael. It might feel weird not hearing Don La Greca’s rants immediately after a Kay rant, but that’s just the new reality of the New York airwaves. Turn to 880 AM, buckle up, and hope he’s in a good mood. Otherwise, you might just end up being "dead to him" too.