Ask most fans and they'll give you a year. 1917. But if you're looking for the specific moment when was NHL formed, you have to look at a messy, ego-driven corporate breakup in Montreal. It wasn't some grand vision for the future of winter sports. Honestly? It was a spite move. A group of team owners basically got tired of one guy—Eddie Livingstone—and decided to start a whole new club just so they didn't have to invite him to the meetings anymore.
It happened at the Windsor Hotel. November 26, 1917.
History likes to polish these things up, but the birth of the NHL was chaotic. The National Hockey Association (NHA) had been the top dog since 1909. However, the owners of the Montreal Canadiens, Montreal Wanderers, Ottawa Senators, and Quebec Bulldogs were fed up. Livingstone, who owned the Toronto Blueshirts, was notoriously difficult to work with. He sued everyone. He argued over everything. So, the other owners met in a hotel room and essentially said, "Fine, we’re dissolving the NHA and starting the National Hockey League." They didn't even invite him. Imagine being the guy who owned the biggest team in Toronto and finding out via a newspaper or a telegram that your league just stopped existing without you.
The November Coup at the Windsor Hotel
The meeting wasn't just a quick handshake. It lasted two days. Frank Calder, who had been the secretary of the old NHA, was named the first president. People often forget that the NHL was originally intended to be a temporary solution. They figured they'd get through the war years—World War I was absolutely gutting team rosters at the time—and then figure out a permanent structure later.
Quebec had a team but couldn't afford to play that first season. That left a big hole in the schedule. To fix it, the newly formed NHL "loaned" players to a new Toronto franchise, which eventually became the St. Patricks and then the Maple Leafs. If you’re a Leafs fan, your team basically started as a placeholder to keep the schedule balanced while the league tried to freeze out Eddie Livingstone.
The first games didn't even happen until December 19. On that night, the Montreal Wanderers beat the Toronto Arenas 10-9. Defense? Not a priority back then. Meanwhile, the Canadiens beat Ottawa 7-4. Joe Malone, a name every hockey nerd should worship, scored five goals in that first game for Montreal. He ended the season with 44 goals in 20 games. Just think about that for a second. That's a pace that would make Connor McDavid’s head spin.
Why the 1917 Date is a Bit Complicated
Even though we point to 1917 as the year the NHL was formed, it didn't look anything like the league we know. There were no divisions. No Original Six. In fact, the "Original Six" era didn't even start until 1942. For the first few years, the NHL was a tiny, regional operation focused mostly on Ontario and Quebec.
The league almost died several times in its first decade. The Montreal Wanderers' home arena burned down in January 1918, just six games into the first season. The team just... stopped existing. They folded immediately. The league was down to three teams. It stayed that way for a while. It’s a miracle the whole thing didn't go belly up before the 1920s even started.
✨ Don't miss: John Morton and the Lions: What Really Happened in Detroit
By 1924, the league finally started looking south. The Boston Bruins became the first American team. This was a massive shift. Before the Bruins joined, the NHL was a purely Canadian affair. Adding Boston opened the floodgates for the New York Americans (who are now a trivia answer) and the Pittsburgh Pirates.
The Stanley Cup Wasn't Always Ours
One of the biggest misconceptions about when was NHL formed is that the league owned the Stanley Cup from day one. That is total nonsense. The Stanley Cup was a "challenge trophy." It was controlled by trustees, not a league office.
In the early years, the NHL champion had to play the champion of other leagues, like the Pacific Coast Hockey Association (PCHA), to actually win the Cup. It wasn't until 1926 that the NHL became the only league left standing, effectively taking over the trophy by default. Before that, you could be the NHL champion and still lose the Stanley Cup to a team from Vancouver or Seattle. In 1917, the Seattle Metropolitans actually held the Cup when the NHL was being born.
Money, War, and Survival
You have to realize how much the world was changing during this era. The Spanish Flu pandemic hit in 1919, famously canceling the Stanley Cup Finals mid-series between Montreal and Seattle. Joe Hall, a Canadiens defenseman, actually died from the flu during the series. It was a brutal time to try and run a business.
The owners weren't billionaires. They were local businessmen, often with ties to the arenas or the transport industry. They survived by being cutthroat. The jump from the NHA to the NHL was purely a legal maneuver to escape contracts and litigation. It worked, but it left a lot of bad blood in its wake. Eddie Livingstone spent years in court trying to prove the whole thing was an illegal conspiracy. He never really won, but he certainly made their lives miserable.
Why It Still Matters Today
The DNA of those 1917 meetings is still in the league today. The power of the owners, the emphasis on regional rivalries, and even the way the schedule is weighted—it all tracks back to that hotel room in Montreal.
If you want to understand the modern NHL, you have to appreciate its gritty, somewhat shady origins. It wasn't a product of consensus; it was a product of conflict. The league didn't grow because everyone loved hockey; it grew because it was the most organized survivor of a chaotic era in sports history.
💡 You might also like: Iowa State Arizona Game: Why This Rivalry Just Hits Different Now
Fact-Checking the Timeline
- November 26, 1917: The official meeting at the Windsor Hotel where the NHL was created.
- December 19, 1917: The first official games were played.
- 1924: The Boston Bruins join, marking the first U.S. expansion.
- 1926: The NHL gains de facto control of the Stanley Cup.
- 1942: The start of the "Original Six" era, which lasted until the 1967 expansion.
Actionable Takeaways for the Modern Fan
If you're looking to dive deeper into the history of how the game was built, there are a few things you should do to get the full picture.
First, check out the Digital Archives of the Hockey Hall of Fame. They have scanned documents from the early NHA and NHL meetings that show just how close the league came to collapsing. Seeing the actual handwritten notes from those early days puts the "business" of hockey into perspective.
Second, if you ever find yourself in Montreal, visit the site of the old Windsor Hotel (now part of Le Windsor). There's a plaque, but standing in the space where four guys decided to change sports history just to spite a business rival is a trip.
Finally, read up on the PCHA and the WCHL. Understanding the leagues that the NHL killed is just as important as knowing when the NHL itself was born. It gives you a much better grasp of why the league is structured the way it is today, particularly regarding player contracts and territorial rights.
The NHL wasn't born out of a love for the game alone—it was born out of a need for a fresh start. Knowing that history makes every Original Six matchup feel a little bit more meaningful. It wasn't just about hockey; it was about who survived.