You ever pick up a book thinking it’s just going to be a standard monster story and then realize, about fifty pages in, that you’re actually reading a autopsy of a culture’s soul? That’s basically the experience of cracking open The Only Good Indians by Stephen Graham Jones.
It’s a horror novel, yeah. There is blood. There is a vengeful spirit with an elk’s head. But honestly? The "monster" isn't even the scariest part. The scary part is the weight of the past and how it follows you, even when you try to outrun it in a beat-up truck or a New York City apartment.
The Thanksgiving Classic: A Mistake That Never Ends
Let’s talk about the event that starts it all. Ten years before the main story kicks off, four young Blackfeet men—Lewis, Ricky, Gabe, and Cass—decide to go hunting on a section of the reservation that’s strictly off-limits. They call it the "Thanksgiving Classic." It wasn't just a hunt. It was a slaughter.
They found a huge herd of elk and just started shooting. Adrenaline is a hell of a drug, and they didn't stop until the ground was red. But here’s the kicker: among the dead was a young cow elk who was pregnant. Lewis has to shoot her multiple times to put her down, and when he opens her up, he finds the calf.
They tried to hide it. They tried to use the meat. But the game warden caught them, and they were forced to leave the carcasses to rot. In Blackfeet tradition—and honestly, just in basic human decency—wasting a life like that is a massive taboo. You’re supposed to use every part of the animal. You’re supposed to show respect. They didn't. They just left it all behind in the snow.
Except you don't really leave things like that behind. Not for long.
Why Lewis is the Heart of the Tragedy
The first third of the book follows Lewis. He’s the one who "made it out." He moved off the reservation, got a job with the postal service, and married a white woman named Peta. He’s trying so hard to be "normal." But he’s haunted.
Stephen Graham Jones does this thing where he makes you feel Lewis’s slipping sanity. A flickering light in the living room. A shadow that looks a bit too much like an elk. Lewis starts to think the elk he killed is back, and she’s taking over the bodies of the women in his life.
🔗 Read more: Why Esther is Actually the Most Relatable Part of Nobody Wants This
It gets dark. Really dark.
Lewis ends up killing his coworker, Shaney, and eventually his wife, Peta, because he's convinced they are the "Elk Head Woman." He’s looking for ivory teeth as proof. It’s a brutal look at how generational trauma and guilt can make a person tear their own life apart before the monster even touches them.
The Slasher Meets the Rez
Once the story shifts back to the reservation with Gabe and Cass, the tone changes. It becomes more of a classic slasher, but with a Native American twist.
You’ve got this entity, Po’noka, who is the spirit of that pregnant elk. She’s growing, changing, becoming more human as she hunts down the men who killed her and her unborn calf. It’s a revenge story, but it’s fueled by the "Only Good Indian" trope—the idea that society only values Native people when they fit a certain mold or, darker yet, when they’re gone.
The Basketball Connection
A lot of people get tripped up by the basketball in this book. Why is there so much basketball?
Because on the rez, basketball is everything. It’s the "new tradition." For Denorah, Gabe’s daughter, it’s her ticket out. It’s her way of being "good" in a way the world understands.
The final showdown isn't a sword fight or a shootout. It’s a game of one-on-one. Denorah vs. the Elk Head Woman.
💡 You might also like: Lorde Tour 2025 Tickets: What Most People Get Wrong About the Ultrasound Era
It sounds weird on paper, I know. But in the context of the story, it’s brilliant. It’s a battle of skill, endurance, and identity. Denorah isn't just playing for her life; she’s playing to break the cycle that her father and his friends started.
Breaking the Cycle: The Ending Explained
The reason The Only Good Indians sticks with you is the ending.
In most horror movies, the "Final Girl" wins by being the most violent. She picks up the chainsaw and goes to town. But Denorah does something different. When she finally has the chance to end it, she chooses compassion.
She stops her stepfather from killing the elk and the new calf that is birthed from the ground. By refusing to continue the violence, she finally pays the debt that was opened ten years ago. The spirit retreats. The cycle breaks.
💡 You might also like: How Many Times Do We Have to Teach You This Lesson: Why This Spongebob Meme Refuses to Die
Actionable Insights for Readers
If you’re planning on diving into this book (or if you just finished it and your head is spinning), here are a few things to keep in mind:
- Watch the Motifs: Pay attention to the use of "ivory" and "teeth." It’s a recurring symbol of what was stolen and what is being reclaimed.
- Research the Blackfeet Nation: The book is deeply rooted in real Blackfeet culture. Understanding the history of the land and the significance of the elk hunt adds layers to the story that you might miss otherwise.
- Think About the Title: The phrase "the only good Indian is a dead Indian" is a piece of genocidal history. Jones flips it on its head to ask: what does it mean to be a "good" Indian in a world that’s designed to erase you?
- Listen to the Audio: If you can, grab the audiobook narrated by Shaun Taylor-Corbett. He’s Blackfeet himself, and he brings a level of authenticity to the voices that makes the horror feel way more personal.
The Only Good Indians isn't an easy read. It’s messy, it’s violent, and it’ll make you feel a little sick at times. But it’s one of the most important pieces of modern horror because it refuses to give you easy answers. It forces you to look at the carcasses we all leave in our wake and asks what we’re going to do when they eventually stand up and start walking toward us.