Key West is basically a fever dream of salt air, pastel siding, and roosters that definitely don't own a clock. Honestly, finding a place to stay there is easy. Finding a place that doesn't feel like a corporate photocopy of a beach resort? That’s where things get tricky. Tucked away in the quieter neighborhood of Old Town, The Palms Hotel White Street Key West FL sits as a bit of a local landmark, mostly because it isn't trying to be the Hilton.
It’s a Victorian-era guesthouse. Think less "lobby with marble floors" and more "wraparound porch with a history that dates back to the late 1800s." Specifically, the main house was built around 1889. You’ve probably seen the paintings of it—local artist David Harrison Wright famously captured the property's three original homes, once owned by the prominent Williams family. John Sherman Williams, or "Pappa Jack" as he was known, was a saloon owner who essentially built these mansions as a flex of his success. Today, those buildings are mashed together into one of the most interesting stays on the island.
What it’s like staying at The Palms Hotel White Street Key West FL
Most people head to Key West and make a beeline for Duval Street. That's fine if you want to be within earshot of a drag show and a frozen daiquiri machine at 2:00 AM. But The Palms is about a 15-minute walk—or a five-minute bike ride—away from that chaos. It’s located at 820 White Street. This puts you in the "real" Key West, where people actually live and where the streets are shaded by massive mahogany trees.
The vibe is very much "island casual." Don't expect a white-glove concierge. Instead, you get a staff that actually knows where the best Cuban coffee is (hint: it's Sandy’s Cafe, just a couple of blocks away).
👉 See also: Why What Time Is It Anchorage Matters Way More Than You Think
The property itself is a maze of 32 rooms. Because it’s a collection of historic homes, no two rooms are really the same. You might end up in a petite queen room that feels a bit snug, or you might snag the Bi-Level Attic Suite, which is basically an apartment with a full kitchen.
The pool and the "Saltwater Factor"
Let's talk about the pool. It’s heated seasonally and, more importantly, it’s a saltwater pool. If you’ve spent your life swimming in chlorine that makes your eyes sting for three days, this is a game changer. It’s surrounded by a tropical garden that feels significantly more private than the pool decks at the big hotels on the water.
They serve a continental breakfast poolside every morning. It's nothing fancy—pastries, fruit, cereal, and juice. But eating a bagel while a lizard watches you from a palm frond is a quintessential Key West experience. There’s also a poolside bar that usually opens up for a happy hour from 2:00 PM to 6:00 PM. It’s the kind of place where you end up talking to a retired sea captain or someone who moved to the Keys in the 70s and never left.
💡 You might also like: The Map of Europe with Oceans: Why We Keep Getting the Borders Wrong
Practical details you actually need to know
Key West has some quirks. Parking is the biggest one. The Palms has limited on-site parking, which is rare for Old Town, but it's first-come, first-served. If you don't get a spot, you're hunting for street parking, which can be a nightmare during Fantasy Fest or busy weekends.
Room Variety:
- Standard Rooms: Usually one king or queen bed. Good for a solo traveler or a couple who plans on being out all day.
- Cottage Suites: These often include kitchenettes or small kitchens. Great if you’re tired of paying $30 for a salad on Duval.
- The Attic Suite: This is the one with the full kitchen. It’s funky because of the sloped ceilings, but it’s huge.
- Pet-Friendly Options: They do allow dogs (usually under 35 pounds), but only on the first floor. You have to request these specifically because there aren't many of them.
Bicycles are mandatory. Okay, not legally, but basically. The hotel rents them right on-site. The island is only about four miles long. Driving a car in Key West is a mistake you only make once. On a bike, everything is 10 minutes away.
A bit of "Real Talk" on the history
This place has lived a dozen lives. Before it was The Palms Hotel (a name it took in 1993), it was a boarding house. In the 70s and 80s, it went by names like the Terrell Apartments and the Vandegroaff Apartments. It was the kind of place where "Key West admirers"—which is a polite way of saying bohemian drifters and artists—would hunker down for months at a time.
There’s a lot of talk about the "authentic" Keys. This is it. It’s the Queen Anne architecture, the gingerbread trim, and the fact that the floorboards might creak a little because they've been there for 140 years. It’s not a sterile environment. If you want a hotel that feels like a hospital room with a view of the ocean, go to the Marriott. If you want a place where the walls have stories, this is the spot.
Nearby spots that don't suck
Since you're on White Street, you're perfectly positioned to see the parts of the island tourists usually miss.
✨ Don't miss: Coleman's Authentic Irish Pub: Why It’s More Than Just a Bar
- Key West Cemetery: It’s a five-minute walk. Sounds weird, but it's one of the most beautiful and hilarious places on the island (look for the "I told you I was sick" gravestone).
- Fausto’s Food Palace: The local grocery store. Get your supplies here if you have a room with a kitchen.
- Higgs Beach: Much closer than the big beaches on the other side of the island. It’s home to the White Street Pier, which is the best place to watch the sunrise if you can drag yourself out of bed.
Final verdict: Is it right for you?
The Palms Hotel White Street Key West FL is for a specific type of traveler. If you need 24-hour room service and a gym with 50 treadmills, you’ll hate it here. But if you want to wake up in a house built by a 19th-century saloon owner, grab a bike, and spend your day exploring hidden alleys, it’s perfect.
Actionable Next Steps:
- Check the Room Type: If you’re traveling with a group, look specifically for the Bi-Level suites or the "Ashe Cottage" style units; they provide significantly more breathing room than the standard historic rooms.
- Book Your Bike Early: Don't wait until the morning you want to ride. Rental stock can get low during peak season (January to April).
- Check the Pet Policy: If you're bringing a dog, call the front desk directly. Website filters aren't always great at showing the specific first-floor rooms that allow pets.
- Manage Parking Expectations: If you’re driving down the Keys, try to arrive as close to the 3:00 PM check-in as possible to snag one of the few on-site spots. Otherwise, be prepared to walk a block or two from your car.