You’re standing there, elbow-deep in cold, stringy orange guts. It’s October, it’s probably raining, and you’re wondering why on earth we do this every single year. The smell is… distinctive. We hack a goofy face into a giant gourd, stick a candle inside, and leave it on the porch to rot. It’s a strange tradition when you actually think about it. But the jack o lantern background isn’t just about making neighborhood kids happy or winning a local carving contest. It’s actually pretty dark.
Centuries ago, people weren't carving pumpkins. Pumpkins are a New World crop, native to North America. If you were a farmer in 18th-century Ireland or Scotland, you had never even seen a pumpkin. Instead, you had turnips. Massive, hard-as-rock, purple-topped turnips. And that is where this whole messy business actually started.
💡 You might also like: Why the Farmers Market Owatonna MN is Actually the Heart of Steele County
The Stingy Jack Legend
The story starts with a guy named Jack. He was a smith, a trickster, and by all accounts, a pretty terrible person. The Irish folktale says Jack was so silver-tongued he managed to trick the Devil himself not once, but several times. In one version, he convinced the Devil to turn into a coin to pay for drinks, then shoved the coin into his pocket next to a silver cross, trapping the prince of darkness. He eventually let the Devil go on the condition that he wouldn't claim Jack’s soul.
Bad move.
When Jack finally kicked the bucket, God didn't want him in heaven because of his life of trickery. But the Devil, keeping his promise, wouldn't let him into hell either. Jack was stuck. He was a wanderer in the "between" place—the eternal dark. The Devil, perhaps out of a weird sense of respect or just to get Jack to leave him alone, tossed him a single burning coal from the fires of hell. To keep the coal burning as he wandered, Jack hollowed out a turnip and put the coal inside. He became "Jack of the Lantern," or Jack O' Lantern.
Irish immigrants brought this story to America in the mid-19th century. They fled the Great Famine and brought their folklore with them. When they got here, they found that pumpkins were much bigger and way easier to carve than a turnip. Honestly, have you ever tried to carve a turnip? It’s like trying to hollow out a bowling ball with a spoon. Pumpkins were a massive upgrade.
Why the Face?
There’s a practical side to this too. In the old country, these lanterns weren't just for decoration. They were meant to be scary. People believed that during Samhain (the Gaelic festival marking the end of the harvest and the beginning of winter), the veil between our world and the spirit world got thin. Real thin.
Ghosts could walk. Spirits could cause trouble.
The jack o lantern background is rooted in the idea of "apotropaic magic." That’s just a fancy way of saying "something that wards off evil." If you put a terrifying face on your doorstep, the wandering spirits (and maybe even Stingy Jack himself) would see it and think twice about coming inside. It was basically a spiritual security system.
From Potatoes to Pumpkins
The shift from roots to gourds happened fast. By the 1860s, American magazines like Godey's Lady's Book were already mentioning carved pumpkins as a centerpiece of Thanksgiving and Halloween celebrations. It’s funny because we associate them so strictly with October 31st now, but back then, they were just "harvest symbols."
📖 Related: Why the Winter Time Change in France Still Happens (and Why It Might Never Stop)
- Turnips: Used in Ireland and Scotland. Small, white/purple, extremely hard.
- Beets: Used in parts of England. Deep red and messy.
- Potatoes: Occasionally used, but they shrivel up way too fast.
- Pumpkins: The American champion. Large, hollow, and soft-walled.
It’s worth noting that the earliest American Jack O' Lanterns weren't always faces. Sometimes they were just geometric patterns or holes poked through to let light out. The "scary face" became the standard because it leaned into the spooky vibe that Halloween eventually adopted.
The Science of the Glow
We’ve moved past burning coals from hell. Most people use tea lights or those flickering LED "candles" from the dollar store. But if you want to be authentic to the jack o lantern background, you need fire.
The physics are simple. A hollowed-out gourd acts as a chimney. The heat rises, drawing oxygen in through the mouth and eyes. If you don't cut enough "exhaust" holes in the top, the candle will suffocate and go out. That’s why people often cut a hole in the lid—it’s not just to get the guts out; it’s for airflow.
Nathaniel Hawthorne, the guy who wrote The Scarlet Letter, actually wrote about a "Jack-o'-lantern" in a short story back in 1835. He described it as a symbol of someone who looks bright on the outside but is totally empty and dark on the inside. Dark stuff, Nathaniel. But it shows how deeply embedded this image was in the American psyche even before the massive wave of Irish immigration in the 1840s.
Regional Variations You Probably Didn't Know
In Somerset, England, they have "Punkie Night." It happens on the last Thursday of October. Kids carry "punkies," which are hollowed-out mangel-wurzels (a type of large beet). They go door to door and sing songs. It’s almost exactly like our modern trick-or-treating, but with a much weirder name for the vegetable.
In some parts of Scotland, these lanterns were called "guizards." The kids would dress up in costumes—often made of straw—and carry their turnip lanterns to scare away the Aos Sí, the fairy folk. If you think a pumpkin is creepy, go look up a photo of a traditional Irish carved turnip. They look like actual shrunken heads. They are nightmare fuel.
The Modern Industrial Complex
Today, we grow over 1.5 billion pounds of pumpkins in the U.S. every year. Most of those are "Howden" pumpkins. This specific variety was developed by John Howden in the 1960s. He wanted a pumpkin that was thin-walled, had a sturdy handle, and stayed upright. Before the Howden, pumpkins were often lumpy, slanted, and hard to carve.
So, when you buy that "perfect" pumpkin at the grocery store, you’re buying a piece of 20th-century agricultural engineering designed specifically to honor an 18th-century Irish ghost story. Kind of wild.
How to Respect the Tradition (And Make It Last)
If you’re going to partake in this centuries-old tradition, you might as well do it right. The biggest enemy of a Jack O' Lantern isn't the Devil; it’s mold. Once you break the skin of the pumpkin, the clock starts ticking.
Keep It Fresh
First, don't carve too early. A week before Halloween is the sweet spot. If you do it on October 1st, you’ll have a pile of orange mush by the 10th.
Second, try the "bottom cut" trick. Instead of cutting a lid off the top, cut a hole in the bottom. You can set the pumpkin down over a candle or light. This keeps the structural integrity of the "shoulders" of the pumpkin intact, so it doesn't cave in as it dries out.
The Bleach Soak
Serious carvers (yes, they exist, look up the "Pumpkin Masters") swear by a bleach solution. After you carve, soak the whole thing in a bucket of water with a tablespoon of bleach. It kills the bacteria and mold spores. Smells like a pool, but your Jack stays crisp.
Smear Some Jelly
Put petroleum jelly on the cut edges. It seals in the moisture. Think of it like lip balm for your pumpkin. Without it, the "flesh" of the pumpkin dries out and curls, making your scary monster look like a wrinkled old man in about 48 hours.
💡 You might also like: Wrapping flowers with brown paper: Why this simple trick beats expensive florist foil
What Most People Get Wrong
People think the Jack O' Lantern was always a Halloween staple. It wasn't. In the early 1800s, it was more of a prank. Teenage boys would use them to jump out and scare people on dark roads. It was a tool for mischief before it was a decoration for the suburbs.
Also, it wasn't always about "scary." In the Victorian era, Jack O' Lanterns were often used as elegant decorations for high-society autumn parties. They would carve intricate floral patterns into them. It was very "cottagecore" before that was a thing. The pivot back to horror happened as the movie industry took over Halloween in the 20th century.
Making Your Own History
The jack o lantern background is a weird mix of Celtic paganism, Christian folklore, and American agricultural history. It’s about light in the dark. It’s about laughing at the things that scare us. Whether you’re carving a turnip to keep the Devil away or just making a "Howden" pumpkin look like a cat for your Instagram feed, you’re participating in a ritual that’s survived for hundreds of years.
Next time you’re scraping out those seeds, remember Jack. He’s still out there somewhere in the dark, according to the legend, waving his little turnip lantern and looking for a place to rest. Just make sure your porch light is on.
Your Halloween Action Plan
- Skip the grocery store bin: Go to a local patch. You want a pumpkin that feels heavy for its size—that means it’s hydrated and will last longer.
- Try a non-traditional vegetable: If you really want to honor the jack o lantern background, buy a large rutabaga or turnip. Try carving it. You’ll gain a whole new respect for 18th-century Irish peasants.
- Save the seeds: Don't throw them away. Toss them in olive oil and salt, roast them at 300 degrees for 45 minutes. It’s the best part of the whole process.
- Dispose of it properly: When November 1st hits, don't just throw the pumpkin in the trash. Smash it up and put it in a compost bin or find a local farm that takes them for pig feed. Pigs love old pumpkins.
The tradition doesn't have to end with a rotting gourd in a landfill. Keep the cycle going. Just don't make any deals with the Devil while you're at it.