You probably think they're just beans. Tiny, creamy little legumes with a dark spot that look pretty unassuming on a plate. But if you grew up in certain parts of the South, or if your family has roots stretching back through the African Diaspora, you know that a plate of cowpeas is never just a side dish. It’s a heavy weight of history, superstition, and occasionally, a very real black eyed peas taboo that dictates exactly when and how you’re allowed to eat them.
Most people recognize them as the "New Year's Lucky Charm." Eat them on January 1st, and you'll have money. Skip them, and you're asking for twelve months of financial ruin. That’s the mainstream version. But there is a flip side to this coin—a darker, more restrictive set of rules that most folks don't talk about until they're standing in a kitchen with their grandmother.
Why would a bean be forbidden?
It sounds ridiculous. It’s a legume. Yet, the cultural baggage attached to this specific plant is so dense that some people won’t touch them outside of a twenty-four-hour window once a year. For others, eating them signifies a period of mourning or a reminder of a poverty they’ve spent a lifetime trying to outrun.
The Hunger Games of the Civil War
To understand the black eyed peas taboo, you have to look at the 1860s. During the American Civil War, specifically during General William Tecumseh Sherman’s "March to the Sea," Union soldiers were instructed to burn crops and seize livestock to starve the Confederate Army into submission. They torched the corn. They took the pigs. They left the fields in ruins.
But they left the black eyed peas.
The Northern soldiers viewed cowpeas as "cow fodder." To them, it wasn't human food. It was something you fed to the pigs or the cattle. They didn't even bother to burn the stores of dried peas because they couldn't imagine a civilized person actually eating them. This arrogance saved thousands of lives. Enslaved people and poor Southerners survived the winter because they had access to the one thing the Union army deemed too "low-class" to destroy.
This is where the luck comes from. Survival. But it’s also where the stigma was born.
For a long time after the war, eating black eyed peas was a sign of desperation. If you were eating them, it meant you didn't have meat. It meant you were at the bottom of the social ladder. In some families, this created a massive psychological block. To eat them was to admit you were struggling. My own great-aunt wouldn't serve them if company was over because she didn't want anyone thinking the family was "back in the fields."
The Cultural Superstitions and Spiritual No-Gos
In some Gullah-Geechee communities and West African traditions, the black eyed peas taboo gets even more specific. There is a deep-seated belief that certain foods carry spiritual "weight."
🔗 Read more: Why the Nike Air Max 90 Bacon Still Matters Two Decades Later
Take the "Hoppin' John" tradition. The dish—a mix of peas, rice, and pork—is strictly ritualistic. In some households, if you eat the peas before midnight on New Year's Eve, you're "eating your luck away." You're literally consuming the prosperity before it has a chance to manifest in the new year. It’s a taboo of timing.
Then there's the "leftover" rule.
Some folks believe that if you don't finish every single pea on your plate on New Year's Day, the "luck" turns into a debt. You owe the universe. It’s a heavy burden for a legume.
Wait. It gets weirder.
There are specific practitioners of Hoodoo and Traditional African Religions (ATR) who view the black eyed pea as a tool for protection rather than just food. In these contexts, you don't just eat them; you might carry them in a red flannel bag (a mojo bag) for luck. However, if that bag breaks or you lose a pea, it’s considered an omen of impending loss. The taboo here is treating the food with disrespect. You don't toss them in the trash. You don't waste them. If you do, you're disrespecting the ancestors who relied on them for literal survival.
Why the Taboo Still Lingers in 2026
You might think we’d be over this by now. We aren't.
I’ve spoken to chefs in Atlanta and Charleston who struggle to keep black eyed peas on the menu year-round. People will order them in January, sure. But come July? The sales drop off a cliff. There’s a subconscious collective memory that says these belong to a specific, sacred time—or a time of suffering.
Part of the black eyed peas taboo is also rooted in the "Struggle Plate" phenomenon.
✨ Don't miss: Weather Forecast Tysons Corner VA: Why the Wind Matters More Than the Snow
On social media, you’ll see people posting elaborate meals. But mention black eyed peas and ham hocks, and the comments section often splits. Half the people feel a rush of nostalgia. The other half see it as "slave food" that they’ve worked hard to move past. This internal conflict—the desire to honor heritage while simultaneously wanting to distance oneself from the trauma of the past—is exactly why the taboo persists. It’s a complicated relationship with a bean.
The Health Counter-Narrative
If you look at the nutritional profile, the taboo makes zero sense. They are a powerhouse.
- High in folate (great for cell repair).
- Loaded with fiber.
- Zinc and iron in spades.
Yet, there’s a persistent myth in some communities that "soul food" is inherently unhealthy. While some preparation methods (looking at you, salt pork and excessive lard) can be heavy on the sodium, the pea itself is a superfood. The taboo against eating them "too much" is actually doing a disservice to public health.
Dr. Jessica B. Harris, a preeminent culinary historian, has often noted that the transition from a plant-based diet in the African Diaspora to a heavy meat-based diet is a relatively recent Western shift. The black eyed pea was a staple protein. Reclaiming it means breaking the taboo that associates it only with "the hard times."
How to Navigate the Tradition Without the Baggage
If you’re worried about the "luck" or the "stigma," honestly, you’re overthinking it. But culture isn't always logical. If you want to honor the roots of the black eyed peas taboo while still enjoying your dinner, here is how the experts suggest you handle it.
First, acknowledge the history. When you cook them, remember that you're eating a plant that survived a war. It’s a plant that traveled from West Africa to the Caribbean and then to the Americas in the pockets of people who had nothing else.
✨ Don't miss: Bath and Body Works Blue Perfume: Why Everyone Is Still Obsessed With Gingham
Second, mix up the preparation. The taboo is largely tied to the "mushy" stewed version served with pork. Try a "Texas Caviar"—cold, pickled black eyed peas with bell peppers, onions, and vinaigrette. It breaks the psychological link to the "New Year’s pot" and allows the ingredient to stand on its own as a modern, healthy legume.
Lastly, stop treating it like a once-a-year guest.
The best way to kill a taboo is to normalize the behavior. If we only eat these peas when we’re desperate for a financial miracle on January 1st, we reinforce the idea that they are a "poverty food" or a "emergency luck" food.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Meal
If you want to move past the black eyed peas taboo and actually enjoy the benefits of this historical powerhouse, do this:
- De-link the Pork: If your avoidance is based on health concerns or the "heavy" feel of the dish, use smoked paprika and liquid smoke to get the flavor without the saturated fat. This changes the "vibe" of the meal from a heavy ritual to a light lunch.
- Research Your Seed: Buy heirloom varieties. Sea Island Red Peas are a cousin to the black eyed pea and carry a massive amount of historical weight without the same "cheap fodder" stigma.
- Eat Them on a Tuesday: Seriously. Break the cycle. Cook a batch in the middle of a random month. Observe the internal resistance you might feel—that’s the cultural taboo talking. Eat them anyway.
- Teach the History: If you have kids, don't just tell them "eat this for money." Tell them "eat this because your ancestors were smart enough to grow something the enemy didn't understand."
The taboo is only as strong as the silence around it. Once you realize the "forbidden" nature of the pea is just a mix of wartime propaganda and survival-based superstition, you can finally just enjoy the damn beans.