It happened in a flash. One minute, people were just commuting, scrolling through their phones or staring blankly at the ads above the windows. The next, a woman was lit on fire on a subway train, and the collective sense of safety in our urban centers took another massive hit. This wasn't a movie scene. It was a brutal, physical reality that unfolded in front of horrified witnesses.
Public transit is the lifeblood of cities like New York, Toronto, and Chicago. When something this visceral happens—someone literally being set ablaze while just trying to get from point A to point B—it taps into a deep-seated primal fear. It's the "it could have been me" factor. Honestly, it’s the kind of story that makes you want to never touch a turnstile again.
What Actually Happened During the Woman Lit on Fire on Subway Incident?
To understand the weight of this, we have to look at the specifics of the most prominent case that shocked the public: the 2022 attack in Toronto. A woman was at Kipling Station. Without any apparent provocation, a man poured a flammable substance on her and ignited it. She didn't survive. She was 28 years old, a caregiver named Nyima Dolma. She died after weeks in the hospital. It was senseless.
There have been other incidents, too. In New York City, a man was recently arrested for dousing passengers with a flammable liquid. Thankfully, in that case, no one was ignited. But the terror? That stayed. It lingers in the air long after the smell of lighter fluid dissipates. When we talk about a woman lit on fire on subway cars or platforms, we are talking about a breakdown in the social contract.
Public spaces require a level of trust. You trust that the person sitting across from you isn't carrying a bottle of accelerant. When that trust breaks, the city feels different. It feels colder.
The Mental Health and Security Crisis We Aren't Solving
We can't talk about these attacks without talking about the state of our streets. Most of these incidents aren't "targeted" in the traditional sense. They are often the result of severe, untreated mental illness or random acts of desperation and malice. It’s a messy, complicated intersection of policy failure.
Experts like Dr. Liza Gold, a clinical professor of psychiatry, have often noted that while most people with mental illness aren't violent, the lack of a robust support system leads to "systemic failures" where individuals in crisis end up in the subway system because it’s the only place they have to go.
Then there's the security aspect.
Transit authorities are in a bind. You can’t put a metal detector at every single subway entrance. It’s physically impossible. New York City tried "gun detection" technology, and the results were... mixed, to put it lightly. So, we are left with more police on platforms. Is that the answer? Some say yes, it’s a deterrent. Others argue it’s a band-aid on a gunshot wound.
Breaking Down the Security Response
- Increased Surveillance: Most modern subway cars now have cameras, but they are reactive. They help catch the person after the woman is lit on fire, but they don't stop the match from being struck.
- Mental Health Outreach: Programs like New York's SCOUT teams attempt to move people out of the system and into care. It's slow work. Very slow.
- Platform Barriers: In places like Tokyo or Paris, glass walls prevent people from being pushed onto tracks. But they don't stop an attack happening inside the car.
The Psychology of Transit Fear
Why does this specific type of crime haunt us more than, say, a car accident? It’s because of the confinement. You are in a moving metal tube. There is nowhere to run.
When you hear about a woman lit on fire on subway tracks or trains, your brain immediately begins a "what if" loop. What if the doors didn't open? What if the emergency brake was pulled? This is known as "availability heuristic." Because the event is so graphic and memorable, we perceive it as being more likely to happen than it actually is, statistically speaking.
But tell that to the person who saw it happen. Statistics don't mean much when you're smelling smoke.
How to Actually Stay Safer on Public Transit
Look, I'm not going to give you some "10 tips to be a ninja" nonsense. If someone pours gasoline on you and lights a match, you are in a life-and-death situation that no amount of "situational awareness" can fully prevent. But there are things that change the odds.
First, the "conductor car" is a real thing. In NYC, the conductor is usually in the middle of the train. Being near them means there is a human with a radio who can call for help instantly.
Second, don't be a hero, but don't be a zombie. We all stare at our phones. It’s how we survive the boredom of a commute. But taking one earbud out—just one—changes your reaction time. You hear the argument starting three seats away. You hear the liquid hitting the floor. You get those extra three seconds to move.
Third, know where the fire extinguishers are. Most modern trains have them at the end of the cars. It sounds extreme, but in the case of a fire attack, that's the only tool that matters.
💡 You might also like: United States Nuclear Targets: What Most People Get Wrong About Modern Maps
The Policy Failure Nobody Wants to Admit
We are failing at the basics.
Cities have become increasingly expensive, pushing the most vulnerable people into the margins—and the margins are often the subway. We've closed beds in psychiatric hospitals and replaced them with... nothing. So, the subway becomes a de facto shelter, a de facto hospital, and occasionally, a de facto crime scene.
When we see a headline about a woman lit on fire on subway, we shouldn't just be angry at the perpetrator. We should be angry at the 50 different points in the system where that person was allowed to fall through the cracks until they ended up on a platform with a bottle of flammable liquid.
It's easy to call for more "law and order." It's harder to fund the boring stuff: supportive housing, assertive community treatment, and transit infrastructure that doesn't look like it's from the 1970s.
Real-World Steps for the Daily Commuter
If you are feeling anxious about your commute after hearing about these incidents, you aren't alone. It’s a rational response to an irrational event. Here is how to navigate the system today:
- Trust your gut over your manners. If someone on the train is making you feel "weird" or unsafe, move. Don't worry about being rude. Switch cars at the next station.
- Download the transit safety app. Most major cities (like the MTA’s "See Say" app) have a way to report issues silently. Use it.
- Locate the Emergency Intercom. Every car has one. It’s usually near the doors. Know what it looks like so you don't have to hunt for it during a panic.
- Distance is your friend. In any situation involving a potential weapon or accelerant, space is the only thing that saves you. If the car is crowded, try to stay near the doors.
Public transit remains, statistically, one of the safest ways to travel. It is significantly safer than driving a car. But the psychological impact of a subway attack is unique. It’s a violation of our shared space.
The goal isn't to live in fear, but to live with an eyes-open approach to the realities of urban life. We demand better from our city leaders not just because we want to be "safe," but because we want to be able to exist in our own cities without the haunting image of a woman lit on fire on a subway train becoming a recurring nightmare.
Demand more funding for mental health crisis centers in your local budget meetings. Support transit initiatives that prioritize both staff presence and passenger safety. Stay aware of your surroundings, keep your head up, and look out for your fellow passengers. Transit works because we all agree to ride together; keeping it safe is a job for the city, the state, and the community at large.