Honestly, the copper-plated zinc disc in your pocket is a fiscal disaster. You’ve probably heard people joking about the US penny going away for decades, yet here we are, still lugging around jars of metal that most vending machines won't even acknowledge. It’s a weird situation. Every single year, the United States Mint churns out billions of these tiny coins, and every single year, the Department of the Treasury loses a staggering amount of money doing it.
We are currently in a cycle where it costs roughly 3 cents to manufacture a 1-cent piece. If that sounds like a terrible business model, that’s because it is. According to the 2024 Annual Report from the United States Mint, the unit cost for a penny was 3.07 cents. Think about that for a second. We are literally burning money to create money.
But it isn't just about the production cost. It’s about utility. Or the complete lack of it. When was the last time you actually bought something for a penny? You can’t even find a "penny candy" store that sells things for a cent anymore. Most of us just toss them in a bowl or leave them in those "take a penny, leave a penny" trays at gas stations. They are, for all intents and purposes, dead weight in the American economy.
The Massive Logistics of a Tiny Coin
The scale of this "loss-leader" is hard to wrap your head around. In 2023, the Mint produced about 4.5 billion pennies. When you multiply that by the loss per coin, you’re looking at nearly $90 million in losses in a single year just to keep the penny in circulation. This isn't a new problem, either. The cost of production first crossed the one-cent threshold back in 2006. Since then, we've essentially been subsidizing a piece of currency that has lost 95% of its purchasing power since it was first introduced.
Why haven't we stopped? It isn't just a lack of political will, though that is a huge part of it. There are massive lobbying efforts involved. Take the zinc industry, for example. Since 1982, the penny has been composed of 97.5% zinc with a thin copper coating. Companies like Jarden Zinc Products (now part of One Rock Capital Partners) have a vested interest in keeping the penny alive. They have historically spent significant money lobbying Congress through groups like "Americans for Common Cents" to ensure that the US penny going away remains a conversation rather than a reality.
Then you have the sentimental side. People love the penny. It’s got Abraham Lincoln on it. It’s "lucky." There’s a deep-seated psychological attachment to the currency that makes politicians terrified of being the one to "kill" it. They don't want to be accused of causing inflation or "rounding up" prices on the poor.
💡 You might also like: Dollar Tree Gary Indiana: Why Local Shoppers Still Flock to These Stores
The "Rounding" Myth and Price Gouging
The biggest argument against the US penny going away is that it will hurt low-income consumers. The logic goes like this: if we stop using pennies, businesses will round every price up to the nearest nickel. If your total is $1.02, it becomes $1.05. You lose three cents. Over a year, that adds up.
Except, it really doesn't.
Robert Whaples, an economics professor at Wake Forest University, has studied this extensively. His research suggests that rounding would actually be a wash. Sometimes the price rounds down ($1.02 to $1.00), and sometimes it rounds up. On average, the impact on the consumer is zero. More importantly, we already have a blueprint for this. The US military abolished the penny at overseas bases over 40 years ago. They use a simple rounding system for cash transactions, and the world hasn't ended. Canada did it in 2013. Australia did it in 1992. In all these cases, the transition was seamless, and the "inflationary spike" people feared never actually materialized.
What Happens if We Actually Pull the Trigger?
If the US penny going away actually happened tomorrow, your life wouldn't change as much as you think. Most of our transactions are digital anyway. Whether you use Apple Pay, a credit card, or a bank transfer, the price remains $19.99. Rounding only applies to physical cash.
Here is how the transition usually looks in countries that have ditched their lowest denomination:
- Cash Transactions: If your total is $10.01 or $10.02, you pay $10.00. If it’s $10.03 or $10.04, you pay $10.05.
- Digital Transactions: Absolutely no change. The exact cent is still charged to your card.
- Existing Pennies: They don't become worthless overnight. You can still take them to the bank or use them until they eventually filter out of the system.
The biggest winner in this scenario is the taxpayer. We’d save tens of millions of dollars annually in production costs alone. Beyond that, there's the "time tax." Think about the seconds spent fumbling for change at a register. Multiply those seconds by every cash transaction in the country. It adds up to millions of hours of wasted productivity. We are literally paying to waste our own time.
The Environmental Toll
We rarely talk about the environmental cost of the penny. Mining zinc and copper is an intensive process. Then you have to transport the raw materials to the Mints in Philadelphia and Denver. Then you have to ship billions of finished coins in heavy armored trucks to banks across the country.
Because pennies have so little value, they don't circulate well. People keep them in jars. This means the Mint has to keep making "new" ones because the "old" ones are sitting in your dresser drawer. It’s a one-way trip for most pennies, from the Mint to a jar, where they sit for decades. That is a massive amount of metal being pulled from the earth for no functional purpose.
Why 2026 Could Be the Tipping Point
We are seeing a convergence of factors that might finally make the US penny going away a reality. First, inflation. The more prices rise, the less a penny is worth. We are approaching a point where the penny is so worthless that it's practically a nuisance to everyone involved in the supply chain.
Second, the "coin shortage" during the COVID-19 pandemic highlighted how fragile our physical currency circulation is. It forced many businesses to go "cashless" or ask for exact change, proving that we can survive without a constant flow of small coins.
Third, the budget. With the national debt being a constant talking point in Washington, cutting a program that literally loses $90 million a year is an easy win for any fiscal hawk. It’s "low-hanging fruit." There is no logical reason to keep it, other than nostalgia and specialized lobbying.
📖 Related: How to Invest in Carbon Credits: What Most People Get Wrong
Actionable Insights for the Change-Heavy
Regardless of when the government decides to pull the plug, you probably have a hoard of these things. Don't wait for a federal mandate to deal with them.
- Use the Coinstar trick: Most people hate the 11-12% fee Coinstar charges. However, if you choose the "eGift Card" option (like Amazon or Starbucks), they usually waive the fee entirely. You get 100% of your penny value.
- Dump them at the bank: If you have a brick-and-mortar bank account, they will often give you free coin wrappers. It’s a mindless task to do while watching TV, and most banks will take the rolls without a fee if you’re a customer.
- Check for "Key Dates": Before you dump them, look for 1943 copper pennies (extremely rare) or pennies from the early 1900s. While most are worth exactly one cent, some "wheat pennies" can fetch a few dollars. It’s a small hobby that might pay for your lunch.
- Charity jars: Many non-profits still rely on "spare change" drives. Your 400 pennies are annoying to you, but to a local food bank, that’s $4.00 they didn’t have before.
The reality is that the penny has already "gone away" in the minds of most Americans. We don't value it, we don't use it, and we certainly don't want to carry it. The only thing left is for the law to catch up with our pockets. When it finally happens, the transition will be so quiet you'll probably wonder why we waited so long to stop paying 3 cents for a piece of zinc.