You’ve probably heard the name Shyamalan and immediately thought of a guy in a hoodie staring at a twist ending. But The Watchers movie 2024 isn't actually an M. Night joint, at least not in the director's chair. It’s the debut of his daughter, Ishana Night Shyamalan. Honestly, the baggage that comes with that name is probably the heaviest thing about the whole movie. People went in expecting The Sixth Sense in a forest and ended up with a strange, folkloric mood piece that feels more like a dark Irish fairytale than a standard Hollywood jumpscare-fest.
The movie stars Dakota Fanning as Mina. She’s an American living in Galway, working at a pet shop and basically hiding from her own life. She’s got a lot of trauma—the kind that movies love to show in grainy flashbacks—and she spends her nights wearing wigs and pretending to be other people. When she’s tasked with driving a golden conure parrot (aptly named Darwin) to a zoo near Belfast, her car predictably dies in a forest that doesn't appear on any maps.
Standard horror stuff, right?
Well, kinda. But it gets weirder.
The Coop and the Rules of the Woods
Mina finds herself trapped in a structure called "The Coop." It’s basically a giant concrete box with one wall made of a massive one-way mirror. Inside, she meets three other strangers: Madeline (the "leader" of the group), Ciara, and Daniel. They’ve been stuck there for months. Or years. Time gets fuzzy when you’re being hunted by things you can’t see.
The premise of The Watchers movie 2024 relies on these very specific, almost ritualistic rules.
- You must be inside the Coop before the sun goes down.
- You must stand in front of the mirror every night so the "Watchers" can see you.
- You never, ever turn your back to the glass.
- You don't enter the "Burrows" (the holes in the ground where the creatures hide during the day).
It’s essentially Big Brother but with ancient Irish monsters instead of D-list celebrities. The creatures want to watch humans. They want to learn how to mimic us. It’s a literal stage.
Why the Irish Folklore Matters
A lot of critics complained that the lore felt "clunky" or "exposition-heavy," but if you look at the source material—the 2021 novel by A.M. Shine—the Irish roots are everything. Shine has a degree in history from the University of Galway, and he didn't just make these things up. The Watchers are based on the Aos Sí or the Sidhe. In American pop culture, we think of "fairies" as Tinkerbell. In Irish lore, they are ancient, terrifying, and very much not your friends.
The movie explains that these beings used to be worshipped like gods until humans got the upper hand and trapped them underground. They lost their wings. They became photosensitive. Now, they’re just bitter, shapeshifting mimics trying to claw their way back into the world by "becoming" the people they watch.
👉 See also: Paul Blart Mall Cop Actors: What Most People Get Wrong About the Cast
Ishana Shyamalan shot the film in actual Irish forests—specifically in Wicklow and Galway. You can feel that. The moss is real. The dampness is real. It’s not a soundstage in Atlanta, and that gives it a texture that most modern horror lacks.
The Twist That Divided Everyone
You can’t have a Shyamalan-adjacent movie without a twist. Except The Watchers movie 2024 doesn't just have one; it has a double-layered reveal that left some people rolling their eyes and others (myself included) thinking it was actually pretty bold for a debut.
Spoiler territory here.
We find out that Madeline, the older woman who has been teaching Mina the rules, isn't human. She’s a Watcher. But she’s a special kind—a hybrid. Ages ago, humans and these "fairies" crossbred, and Madeline is the result of that ancient mingling. That’s why she can stand in the sun. That’s why she’s so "human."
The final act takes us out of the woods and into the city, where Mina realizes that the Madeline she escaped with isn't the real wife of the professor who built the Coop. The real wife died years ago. Madeline is a mimic who did such a good job of "watching" that she literally stole a life.
It's a lot.
Some people hated the 102-minute runtime because it spends so much time explaining its own internal logic. It’s not a movie that trusts the audience to "get it" through vibes alone. It wants to tell you exactly why the parrot says "Don't die now" and exactly how the professor died in the bunker.
How it Performed (The Cold Hard Numbers)
The movie had a production budget of around $30 million, which M. Night Shyamalan actually self-financed before selling it to Warner Bros. It didn't light the box office on fire, pulling in about $33 million worldwide. That’s basically a "wash" in Hollywood terms. Critics were pretty harsh, too—it’s sitting at a 33% on Rotten Tomatoes.
But here’s the thing: horror fans usually like it more than critics do. CinemaScore gave it a C-, which sounds bad, but for a weird, experimental folklore horror, that’s almost a badge of honor.
Is It Worth a Watch?
Honestly, it depends on what you want. If you want a movie where a monster jumps out from behind a tree every five minutes, you’re going to be bored. The monsters are mostly CGI and, frankly, they aren't that scary once they are fully revealed. They look like lanky, unpolished versions of something out of The Hobbit.
But if you like "folk horror"—the kind of stuff like The Ritual or The Vitch—there is a lot to appreciate here. The cinematography by Eli Arenson is genuinely gorgeous. He uses these weird, predatory overhead shots that make the forest feel like a living character.
📖 Related: Sarah Atwood on Yellowstone: Why the "New Villain" Looks So Familiar
Actionable Insights for Your Next Movie Night
If you're planning to check out The Watchers movie 2024, here is how to get the most out of it:
- Watch it with the lights off: The movie relies heavily on the "reflection" motif. If your room is bright, you won't see the subtle things happening in the mirror scenes.
- Don't skip the intro: The first five minutes set up the "Burrow" mechanics that become vital in the finale.
- Read the book if you're confused: A.M. Shine's novel handles the "hybrid" explanation a bit more gracefully than the movie does.
- Look for the "Trap" connection: While Ishana has denied a shared "cinematic universe," there are tiny Easter eggs in the background that nod to her father's 2024 film, Trap.
Ultimately, this isn't a perfect movie. The dialogue is sometimes a bit repetitive, and Dakota Fanning (who is usually great) feels a little trapped by the script's insistence on her being "moody." But for a first-time director, it's a confident swing. It’s weird, it’s specifically Irish, and it’s a lot more interesting than the fifth installment of a generic slasher franchise.
If you're looking for more folklore-based horror, you might want to check out The Hallow (2015) or The Banshee Chapter. They pair perfectly with the vibes here. Just make sure you're home before the sun sets.
The woods in Wicklow are beautiful, but according to the locals, you really shouldn't go in there after dark. Now you know why.