You've probably got one. It’s sitting in your closet right now, likely slightly wrinkled on a plastic hanger, or maybe it’s your "old reliable" for weddings and job interviews. I’m talking about the white men's button up. It seems like the simplest garment in human history, right? It’s a white sheet with buttons. Yet, somehow, most guys are still getting it wrong. They’re wearing shirts that look like sails in the wind or, worse, shirts so thin you can see their undershirt seams from a block away.
It's weird. We’ve been wearing these things since the 19th century, back when a detachable collar was the height of technology, and we still struggle with the basics. Honestly, the white shirt is the ultimate test of a man's style because there’s nowhere to hide. You can't distract people with a loud pattern or a trendy color. It’s just fit, fabric, and you.
The Great Fabric Debate: Broadcloth vs. Oxford vs. Twill
Most guys just walk into a store and grab "a white shirt." Big mistake. Huge. If you buy a crisp broadcloth shirt to wear with jeans, you’re going to look like you’re headed to a board meeting but forgot your trousers. Broadcloth is that classic, smooth, slightly shiny fabric. It’s formal. It’s thin. It’s what you wear with a suit. If you want something for the weekend, you’re looking for an Oxford.
💡 You might also like: Study Guide for SAT Math: Why Your Current Strategy is Probably Failing
The Oxford shirt—specifically the Oxford Cloth Button Down or OCBD—is the workhorse. It’s got that pebbly texture. It’s thicker. It actually looks better when it’s a little rumpled. Legend has it that polo players in the late 1800s started pinning their collars down so they wouldn't flap in their faces while they were riding, which is where we get the button-down collar. Brooks Brothers eventually commercialized it, and it hasn't changed much since.
Then there’s Twill. You can spot twill by the diagonal ribs in the weave. It’s got a bit of a sheen and it’s surprisingly durable. If you hate ironing—and let’s be real, who doesn't?—a heavy twill is your best friend because it resists wrinkles way better than a standard poplin.
Stop Buying Shirts That Don't Fit Your Neck
I’ve seen it a million times. A guy buys a white men's button up based on his "Large" or "Extra Large" t-shirt size. Don't do that. Dress shirts are sold by neck size and sleeve length for a reason. If you can fit more than two fingers between your collar and your neck when it’s buttoned, it’s too big. You’ll look like a kid wearing his dad’s clothes. Conversely, if you’re turning red and can’t swallow, maybe size up.
The shoulder seam is the most important part of the fit. It should sit right where your arm meets your torso. If that seam is drooping down your bicep, the whole shirt is going to look sloppy, no matter how much you paid for it.
Let's Talk About the "Muffin Top"
The most common complaint I hear is about the extra fabric around the waist. You tuck it in, and five minutes later, it’s ballooning out over your belt. This is usually a "Classic Fit" problem. Unless you actually have a very large midsection, you should probably be looking at "Slim Fit" or "Athletic Fit." Brands like Charles Tyrwhitt or Proper Cloth have made a killing just by offering different levels of taper.
If you already own a shirt that fits in the shoulders but is huge in the waist, take it to a tailor. For about 20 bucks, they can "dart" the back, which basically means they sew two small folds into the back to pull the fabric tight. It’s the cheapest way to make a $50 shirt look like a $200 custom piece.
Why Quality Actually Matters Here
You can find a white shirt at a big-box retailer for $15. It’ll probably be 60% polyester. You will sweat. You will itch. And after three washes, the collar will look like a wilted piece of lettuce.
When you’re shopping, look for "Two-Ply" cotton. This means two yarns were twisted together to make a single thread before weaving. It makes the shirt stronger and much less opaque. Nobody wants to see your nipples through your shirt. It’s a vibe, sure, but usually not the one you’re going for at a 10:00 AM presentation.
- Mother of Pearl Buttons: These are the gold standard. They’re carved from actual shells. They have a depth and a shine that plastic just can’t mimic. Plus, they don’t melt if your iron is a little too hot.
- Stitch Density: Look at the seams. High-end shirts have more stitches per inch. It’s a sign of slow, careful manufacturing.
- Removable Collar Stays: If the shirt has little plastic or metal tabs you can slide out of the collar, buy it. It means you can keep that collar crisp, and you won't ruin the shirt in the wash when the stays eventually warp.
The Undershirt Trap
Listen closely: if you are wearing a white undershirt under your white button-up, you can see the lines of the undershirt. It creates a visible box around your torso. It looks amateur.
If you need an undershirt for sweat protection, wear heather grey. Grey absorbs less light and blends in with your skin tone under a white shirt much better than bright white does. It sounds counterintuitive, but it works. Or, better yet, look into "flesh-toned" undershirts. They’re a game changer.
Caring For the White Shirt Without Losing Your Mind
White shirts die a slow death by yellowing. Those yellow pits? That’s not just sweat. It’s a chemical reaction between your sweat and the aluminum in your deodorant. Switching to an aluminum-free deodorant can actually save your wardrobe.
Don't bleach them. I know, it sounds like the right move. But bleach can actually turn the synthetic fibers in the stitching yellow over time. Use an oxygen-based whitener like OxiClean instead. And for the love of everything, wash your white shirts separately. One stray red sock and you’ve got a pink shirt you never wanted.
The Ironing Reality Check
If you’re going to wear a white men's button up, you have to own an iron or a steamer. A wrinkled white shirt doesn't look "relaxed"—it looks like you slept in your car. If you absolutely hate ironing, look for "Non-Iron" shirts, but be aware they are treated with formaldehyde to keep them crisp. Some people find them a bit stiff or less breathable.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Purchase
Stop guessing. Spend ten minutes doing this before you buy your next shirt:
💡 You might also like: Leaves Nail Art Designs: Why Your Manicurist Probably Thinks You’re Basic (And How to Fix It)
- Get Measured: Go to a department store or a local tailor and ask for your neck and sleeve measurements. Write them down in your phone.
- Check the Transparency: Hold the shirt up to the light in the store. If you can see the outline of your hand through both layers of fabric, it’s too thin. Move on.
- Audit Your Deodorant: Check the back of your stick. If "Aluminum" is the first ingredient and your shirts are yellowing, it's time to switch brands.
- The Sit Test: When you try a shirt on, sit down in the fitting room. If the buttons are straining or "gapping" to show your skin when you sit, you need a different cut or a larger size.
A great white shirt is the most versatile tool in your arsenal. It works with a tuxedo, it works with chinos, and it even works with a pair of well-worn jeans. Just make sure the shoulders hit where they should, the fabric doesn't show your skin, and the collar isn't choking you. Simple, but not easy.