Tennessee football is a weird, beautiful, often frustrating beast. If you’ve spent any time at Nissan Stadium—or even back when it was Adelphia Coliseum—you know the feeling. It’s that constant, nagging search for "the guy." When people talk about titans qbs all time, the conversation usually starts and ends with Steve McNair, and honestly, that’s part of the problem. Every single person who has taken a snap under center since Air McNair left has been measured against a literal MVP. It’s an impossible bar.
Look at the history. It’s a wild mix of Heisman winners who fizzled out, gritty veterans who did just enough to get us to the playoffs, and a whole lot of "what ifs."
The franchise moved from Houston to Tennessee in 1997, and since then, the quarterback room has seen more turnover than a Nashville hot chicken joint on a Friday night. We've had the dual-threat dynamos, the statuesque pocket passers, and the guys who were clearly just there to hand the ball off to Derrick Henry or Eddie George. It hasn't always been pretty, but it has definitely been interesting.
The MVP Gold Standard: Steve McNair
You can't talk about this team without starting with Number 9. Steve McNair wasn't just a quarterback; he was the heartbeat of the city. He’s the only one in the history of titans qbs all time to win the NFL MVP award (sharing it with Peyton Manning in 2003, which still feels a little cheap, if we’re being real). McNair threw for 27,141 yards and 156 touchdowns in his career, but the stats don't tell the story.
The story was his ribs. His ankles. His thumb. The guy played through injuries that would put most people in the hospital for a month.
He led the team to Super Bowl XXXIV. One yard short. Everyone remembers Kevin Dyson reaching for the goal line, but nobody gets there without McNair escaping two Titans-sized Rams defenders on that final drive to keep the dream alive. He was the prototype for the modern mobile QB before the league even knew what to do with them. He was tough as nails.
The Boom or Bust Era: Vince Young and Jake Locker
After McNair left for Baltimore, the Titans went big. They drafted Vince Young 3rd overall in 2006. For a minute there, it looked like they’d struck gold twice. VY was electric. He won Offensive Rookie of the Year and had that incredible walk-off touchdown run against the Texans in his hometown. He went 30-17 as a starter in Tennessee. That’s a winning record! But the relationship with Jeff Fisher was... complicated. To put it mildly.
The mental side of the game and the locker room friction eventually derailed what could have been a legendary career. It's one of the biggest "what could have beens" in Nashville sports history.
Then came Jake Locker in 2011. The "Huskies" legend. Locker was a great guy, a hard worker, and had a literal cannon for an arm. But the guy was a magnet for hits. He just couldn't stay on the field. He retired at age 26, citing a loss of passion for the game, leaving the Titans back at square one. It was a sobering reminder that scouting a quarterback is basically an educated guess.
The Marcus Mariota Experiment
In 2015, the Titans drafted Marcus Mariota out of Oregon. He was the perfect "culture" fit. Polite, fast, and coming off a Heisman. His debut against Jameis Winston and the Bucs—where he threw for four touchdowns and had a perfect passer rating—is still legendary.
But things got weird.
🔗 Read more: Women’s Big 12 Basketball: Why the New 16-Team League is Absolute Chaos
Mariota suffered a nerve injury in his elbow that changed everything. He started losing feeling in his fingers. He became tentative. Despite that, he gave us one of the coolest moments in postseason history: throwing a touchdown pass to himself against the Chiefs in the 2017 playoffs. You can't make that up. Ultimately, the lack of consistency and a rotating door of offensive coordinators (Mularkey, Robiskie, LaFleur, Smith) stunted his growth. He was the nice guy who just couldn't quite become the killer the team needed.
The Tannehill Renaissance
Enter Ryan Tannehill. Nobody expected much when Jon Robinson traded a late-round pick for a guy the Dolphins had basically given up on. He was supposed to be the backup. Instead, he took the job in 2019 and went on an absolute tear.
Tannehill led the league in passer rating (117.5) and took the Titans to the AFC Championship game.
People love to credit Derrick Henry for those years—and rightfully so, the man is a cyborg—but Tannehill’s efficiency on play-action was elite. He was the first guy since McNair to provide genuine stability. He won 36 games over a three-year span. However, the 2021 divisional round loss to the Bengals, where he threw three interceptions, sort of signaled the beginning of the end. Fans are fickle, and that game left a scar that never really healed.
Ranking the Top 5 Titans QBs All Time (The Realistic List)
If we're looking at who actually delivered when the lights were brightest, the list is shorter than you'd think. We're excluding the Houston Oilers years here—so sorry, Warren Moon fans, he’s a legend, but he never played in Tennessee.
- Steve McNair: The undisputed king. MVP, Super Bowl appearance, and the soul of the franchise.
- Ryan Tannehill: Statistically the most efficient and led the most successful regular-season stretch since the early 2000s.
- Vince Young: Despite the drama, he won games. A lot of them. Two Pro Bowls don't happen by accident.
- Marcus Mariota: A playoff win and years of being a solid, if unspectacular, starter.
- Kerry Collins: The 2008 season where he went 13-3 after replacing VY was a masterclass in "game management."
Honestly, putting Kerry Collins on there feels a bit like rewarding a substitute teacher who didn't let the kids burn the classroom down, but he did his job. He was a pro.
The Guys Who Just Passed Through
We’ve had some random names take snaps. Remember Matt Hasselbeck? He was actually pretty decent for a year or two, providing a bridge between the VY era and the Locker era. Or how about Charlie Whitehurst? "Clipboard Jesus" himself. Then there was the Zach Mettenberger era, which was mostly just fans trying to convince themselves a sixth-round pick with a cool mustache was the next Tom Brady. Spoiler: he wasn't.
🔗 Read more: Mexico Brazil Sub 20: Why This Youth Rivalry Actually Matters More Than You Think
Why Scouting QBs in Tennessee is So Hard
There's a recurring theme here. The Titans have historically been a "run-first" team. Whether it’s Eddie George, Chris Johnson (CJ2K), or King Henry, the identity is built on physical dominance. This puts a unique pressure on the quarterback. You don't get to throw 50 times a game like Patrick Mahomes. You have to be perfect on the 20 throws you do get.
When you look at the titans qbs all time, the ones who succeeded were the ones who could handle the "boring" parts of the game—the handoffs, the checks at the line—and then make a massive play on 3rd and 8 when everyone knew a pass was coming.
It’s a tough gig. You’re playing in a division that was dominated by Peyton Manning for years, then Andrew Luck, and now C.J. Stroud. The margin for error is razor-thin.
The Future: Will Levis and the New Identity
As of right now, the keys have been handed to Will Levis. He’s got the arm strength that makes scouts drool and the kind of "reckless abandon" that makes coaches stay up at night. His four-touchdown debut against the Falcons was the most exciting thing to happen to the position in years.
But he’s a Titans QB, which means he’s already being compared to McNair. He’s already being scrutinized for every mistake. The franchise is shifting away from the Mike Vrabel "toughness first" mentality toward a more modern, pass-heavy approach under Brian Callahan. This might be the first time in history a Titans QB is actually expected to be the focal point of the offense from day one.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Analysts
- Contextualize Stats: When comparing Titans QBs, raw yardage is a lie. Look at "Expected Points Added" (EPA) or success rate on play-action. Tennessee’s system has historically suppressed passing volume.
- The "Win" Factor: In Nashville, QBs are judged on toughness and wins. It might not be fair, but a guy who throws for 300 yards in a loss is less respected than a guy who throws for 150 but converts a crucial 4th-down scramble.
- Coaching Stability: Notice that the most successful QBs (McNair, Tannehill) had consistent offensive leadership for at least a few years. The failures (Locker, Mariota) were plagued by coaching turnover.
- Draft Strategy: The Titans are currently in a "build around the rookie contract" phase. Watch how they prioritize the offensive line. A Titans QB is only as good as the protection he gets, as evidenced by the 2022-2023 seasons where the line was a sieve.
The history of the position in Tennessee is a rollercoaster. We’ve seen the highest of highs and some truly baffling lows. But through it all, the search for the next McNair continues. Maybe it’s Levis. Maybe it’s someone not even in the league yet. Regardless, the 2-tone blue faithful will be there, yelling "Titan Up" and hoping they finally found the one.
To truly understand the trajectory of this team, you have to look at the offensive line moves and the receiver depth chart. A quarterback in this system is an island unless the front office surrounds him with elite pass protection—something that failed both Mariota and Tannehill in their final years. Keeping an eye on the "Adjusted Sack Rate" is usually the best way to predict if a Titans QB is about to have a career year or a catastrophic one.