You remember the hype. Back in 2016, when word got out that PlatinumGames—the absolute legends behind Bayonetta and Metal Gear Rising—were taking a crack at the Ninja Turtles, the internet basically lost its collective mind. It seemed like a match made in heaven. Fast, stylish combat meets the Heroes in a Half Shell? It was a slam dunk. Or so we thought.
Honestly, TMNT Mutants in Manhattan is one of the weirdest footnotes in gaming history. It arrived with a bang and vanished like a smoke bomb. If you try to find it on Steam, the PlayStation Store, or Xbox Marketplace today, you’re out of luck. It’s gone. Delisted. A ghost in the machine.
What Really Happened With TMNT Mutants in Manhattan?
The game launched in May 2016, and by January 2017, it was scrubbed from digital shelves. That is a blink-and-you-miss-it lifespan for a major licensed title. Most people assume it was just a "bad game," but the truth is way more corporate than that. Activision’s licensing deal with Nickelodeon simply expired. Because the contract ended, they couldn't legally sell the game anymore.
This happened to their Spider-Man games and Transformers: Devastation too. It’s a bummer. If you didn't buy it digitally back then, your only hope now is tracking down a physical disc on eBay, and let's just say the prices aren't getting any cheaper.
The Platinum DNA (And Where It Faltered)
When you boot it up, you can feel that signature Platinum flair. The turtles move with this snappy, athletic grace. You’re rail-grinding, double-jumping, and wall-running across Manhattan rooftops. It looks like a comic book come to life, thanks to a cel-shaded art style heavily inspired by Mateus Santolouco’s work on the IDW comics.
But here’s where things get kinda messy.
Platinum is known for deep, intricate combat systems. In TMNT Mutants in Manhattan, they went for something different: a four-player co-op brawler. You always have all four turtles on screen. If you're playing solo, the AI takes over the other three. This makes the screen look like a neon-colored explosion. It’s chaotic. Sometimes it’s too chaotic to actually tell what you’re doing.
- Leonardo: The tactical lead with slowing-down-time abilities.
- Donatello: Long-range bo staff and health-regen gadgets.
- Michelangelo: High-speed combos and some pretty goofy "cheerleader" buffs.
- Raphael: The heavy hitter with high-damage single-target strikes.
You’ve got Ninjutsu cooldowns, team combos, and items like pizzas and turrets. On paper? Amazing. In practice? It feels a bit like button-mashing through a kaleidoscope.
The Boss Battles: A Love Letter to Fans
Despite the repetitive level design (yeah, the sewers and subways get old fast), the bosses are where the game actually shines. Tom Waltz, who wrote the IDW comics, handled the story, and it shows. The character interactions are spot on.
Fighting Bebop and Rocksteady feels exactly how it should. They’re big, dumb, and hit like freight trains. The game even has secret boss encounters. If you play well enough, Bebop might crash a Rocksteady fight halfway through, turning a standard scrap into a total war zone. You go up against Slash, Karai, Armaggon, and eventually a massive, multi-stage fight against Krang and Shredder.
✨ Don't miss: Why Five Nights at Freddy's Susie is Actually the Franchise's Most Heartbreaking Character
These encounters are the meat of the experience. They require actual dodging and parrying, unlike the trash mobs in the streets that you can basically sneeze on to defeat.
The Missing Piece: Couch Co-op
If there is one thing that killed the vibe for a lot of people, it was the lack of local split-screen. How do you make a Ninja Turtles game—a franchise built on four brothers fighting together—and make it online only for multiplayer?
It felt like a massive oversight. We wanted to sit on the couch with three friends and a couple of actual pizzas. Instead, we got a game that required four separate consoles and four copies of the game. In 2016, that was a hard sell. Today, with the servers being ghosts of their former selves, it's even harder to justify.
Why You Should Still Care
Is it a masterpiece? No. Is it "Platinum's worst game"? Some critics said so, but that's a bit harsh. It’s a 7/10 experience that looks 10/10.
If you’re a die-hard TMNT fan, the voice acting alone is worth the price of admission. They got legends like Nolan North and Steve Blum involved. The banter between the brothers feels authentic. It’s not just a cash grab; you can tell the developers loved the source material, even if they were rushed by a tight production schedule.
Actionable Next Steps for Turtle Fans
If you’re looking to scratch that TMNT itch in 2026, here is how you should actually spend your time and money:
- Hunt for a Physical Copy: If you still own a PS4, Xbox One, or the older 360/PS3 consoles, look for a used disc. It’s the only legal way to play TMNT Mutants in Manhattan today. Check local retro game stores before hitting the big auction sites.
- Check out Shredder’s Revenge: If you want that classic arcade feeling but with modern polish, Shredder's Revenge is the gold standard. It has the local co-op that Mutants in Manhattan missed.
- Read the IDW Comics: Since this game was heavily based on that run, go back to the source. The Mateus Santolouco art is stunning, and the story beats are some of the best in the franchise's history.
- Emulation (The Grey Area): PC players often turn to abandonment sites for delisted games. While we can't link them, the community has kept the game alive with mods that even let you play as different versions of the turtles.
TMNT Mutants in Manhattan isn't perfect, but it's a fascinating piece of history. It represents a specific era of licensed gaming where high-art developers tried to bridge the gap between "kiddy" IP and hardcore action mechanics. It's flawed, fast, and undeniably Turtle Power.