The phone hasn't stopped ringing at the MLSE offices this week. Honestly, if you're Brad Treliving, you probably want to chuck your mobile into Lake Ontario right about now. The pressure in this city is a different beast. One minute, fans are planning a parade because the team won eight of eleven; the next, they're terrified the season is over because Chris Tanev is likely done for the year.
That’s the reality of a Toronto Maple Leafs trade in January 2026. It’s never just a transaction. It’s a referendum on the future of the franchise.
Right now, the name on everyone’s lips is Dougie Hamilton. Yes, that Dougie Hamilton. The 6-foot-6 giant who has basically been living in the doghouse in New Jersey lately. It sounds like a video game trade on paper, but the actual mechanics of getting him to Toronto are enough to give a capologist a migraine.
💡 You might also like: Fort Payne AL Football: Why the Wildcats are North Alabama’s Most Underrated Powerhouse
The Chris Tanev Hole and the Hamilton Rumors
Let’s be real. Losing Chris Tanev is a disaster. He was the "adult in the room" for a defensive corps that sometimes looks like it’s playing fire-drill hockey. With him out, the right side of the blueline is a literal construction zone.
Enter the New Jersey Devils' drama.
Dougie Hamilton was a healthy scratch recently. In the NHL, when a $9 million defenseman sits in the press box, his bags are usually already packed. Pierre LeBrun and Frank Seravalli are both pointing at Toronto as a "potential fit," and it’s easy to see why. Treliving knows Hamilton from their Calgary days. He knows exactly what Dougie brings—a booming shot and elite puck-moving abilities—and exactly what he doesn't (a physical, "heavy" playoff style).
But here is the catch. A huge, $9 million catch.
📖 Related: Ohio High School Playoff Scores: What Most People Get Wrong About the 2025 Season
The Devils are reportedly done with the Hamilton experiment, but they aren't exactly looking to do Toronto any favors. For a Toronto Maple Leafs trade involving Hamilton to work, New Jersey would have to eat a significant chunk of that salary. Treliving is already working with couch change and a couple of Tim Hortons gift cards in terms of cap space.
Why Not Rasmus Andersson?
If the Hamilton deal feels too "blockbuster-y," Rasmus Andersson is the name that makes way more sense for a team trying to stay sane.
Andersson is in the final year of a deal paying him $4.55 million. He’s 29. He’s a right-shot. He’s basically the "diet" version of what the Leafs need, but without the baggage of a long-term $9 million commitment.
The Flames are leaning into a rebuild, and Craig Conroy is looking for assets. The problem? Toronto's cupboard is kinda bare. They don’t have a first-round pick in 2026 or 2027. If they want Andersson, they have to convince Calgary that a package centered around someone like Matias Maccelli or a mid-tier prospect is enough.
The Easton Cowan Dilemma
You can't talk about a Toronto Maple Leafs trade without mentioning Easton Cowan. He’s the crown jewel.
Last year, Treliving almost sent him to St. Louis in a package for Brayden Schenn. Thank God he didn't. Cowan has been a spark plug this season, showing a "Mitch Marner-lite" ceiling that the team desperately needs, especially after the Marner-to-Vegas blockbuster reshaped the roster.
The fan base would riot if Cowan is moved for a rental. But if you’re trying to land a Dougie Hamilton or a high-end top-pair defenseman? He’s the only chip that moves the needle. It’s a brutal balancing act. Do you mortgage the next five years for a chance to win four rounds in May?
Players Who Might Be Packing Their Bags
If a trade happens before the Olympic break, someone on the current roster has to go. It’s math.
- Matias Maccelli: He’s been okay, but the "fit" feels off. He’s a half-point-per-game guy who sometimes struggles to earn the coach's trust. Seattle and Boston are already sniffing around.
- Max Domi: We love the heart, but at $3.75 million, he’s a movable piece if you need to bring in a big-ticket defenseman.
- Morgan Rielly: This is the "nuclear option." There have been whispers—mostly from the wilder corners of the internet—that Rielly could be moved to facilitate a total blueline makeover. It feels unlikely, but in Toronto, "unlikely" happens once a week.
What Most People Get Wrong About These Rumors
Everyone looks at the "Top 10 Trade Targets" lists and thinks it’s like a grocery store. It’s not.
Hamilton has a 10-team trade list. We don't know if Toronto is on it. Even if he wants to come home (he’s a GTA kid), the Devils have to be willing to take back "bad" money. If Toronto sends over $6 million in contracts to make the room, New Jersey is just inheriting a different problem.
The most realistic path forward? A smaller, more surgical strike.
Instead of the $9 million mega-star, keep an eye on names like Jordan Eberle or even Steven Stamkos (imagine that homecoming). If Treliving can find a way to patch the defense with a mid-tier veteran and add a gritty winger who can actually score in the playoffs, that’s a win.
Actionable Insights for the Trade Deadline
If you're following the Toronto Maple Leafs trade tracker this month, here is what you actually need to watch:
- The LTIR Paperwork: Watch what happens with Chris Tanev. If he goes on long-term injured reserve for the rest of the season, that $4.5 million in cap space is the "key" that unlocks every deal.
- The Retention Game: Any trade for a big name requires a third team to retain salary. It costs draft picks to buy that cap space. Since the Leafs are low on picks, they might have to overpay with prospects like Ben Danford.
- The "Olympic Freeze": The roster freeze starts February 4th. If Treliving is going to make a move for Hamilton or Andersson, he’s basically got three weeks to pull the trigger or wait until late February.
The Leafs are in a "win now" window that feels like it’s closing and opening at the same time. They’ve got the stars, but the support system is currently held together by tape and prayers. Whether it’s Hamilton, Andersson, or a surprise name from the Western Conference, the next move will define this era of Toronto hockey.
💡 You might also like: Women's NCAA Tournament Bracket Explained: Why Most People Get It Wrong
Keep an eye on the waiver wire and the scratch list tonight. In the NHL, a healthy scratch isn't just a night off—it's usually the first chapter of a goodbye.