If you walk into a Trader Joe’s during the first week of September, you’re basically entering a citrus-orange fever dream. It’s "Pumpkinpalooza." There are pumpkin-flavored waffles, pumpkin-infused body butters, and those little ginger-spiced cookies that disappear in one sitting. But sitting quietly amidst the chaos of seasonal snacks is the humble Trader Joe’s canned pumpkin.
Actually, it’s labeled as Organic Pumpkin.
📖 Related: Apple Spinach Walnut Salad: Why Most Recipes Taste Boring and How to Fix It
Most people grab a few cans, toss them in the pantry, and assume all canned pumpkin is created equal. I used to think that too. I figured a pureed squash is a pureed squash. Turns out, I was wrong. If you’ve ever baked a pie that came out a little too "soupy" or a loaf of bread that didn’t rise quite right, your choice of can might be the secret culprit.
The Watery Truth About This Puree
Here is the thing: Trader Joe’s organic pumpkin is fundamentally different from the heavy hitter in the industry, Libby’s.
Libby’s uses a proprietary strain of Dickinson pumpkin. It’s dense, dark, and holds its shape on a spoon. Trader Joe’s version? It’s notably thinner. If you open a can and tilt it, you’ll notice a higher moisture content almost immediately. It’s paler, too.
Does that mean it’s bad? Not at all. But it means you can’t always swap it 1:1 in a recipe that was specifically engineered for that thick, custard-like name-brand stuff.
I’ve found that if I’m making a traditional pumpkin pie, the TJ’s puree needs a little "editing." Some bakers actually recommend simmering the puree in a saucepan for ten minutes to cook off that extra water. It sounds like a hassle, but it concentrates the flavor. Honestly, without that step, your pie crust might end up a bit soggy.
✨ Don't miss: Finding the Best Cute Elephant Pictures to Color Without the Usual Fluff
It’s Actually 100% Pumpkin (Mostly)
There is a long-standing internet rumor that canned pumpkin is actually just butternut squash.
Technically, the FDA is pretty chill about this. They allow various types of firm-shelled, golden-fleshed sweet squash to be labeled as "pumpkin." However, Trader Joe’s markets theirs as organic pumpkin puree derived from Cucurbitaceae.
It’s just pumpkin. No salt. No ginger. No "pumpkin spice" (unless you buy the specific pie filling, which is a different beast entirely).
- Calories: 50 per half-cup.
- Fiber: About 4 grams.
- Vitamin A: A massive 380% of your daily value.
It’s basically a superfood in a tin. Because it’s organic and has no additives, it’s also the go-to choice for people who make their own dog treats. My neighbor swears by it for her golden retriever's digestion, and frankly, the dog seems to have better gut health than I do.
Why the Seasonal Scarcity is Real
Trader Joe's doesn’t do "year-round" very well.
They operate on a limited SKU model. This means they only carry about 4,000 products compared to the 30,000+ at a typical Kroger or Safeway. Because the organic canned pumpkin is a seasonal star, it often vanishes by January.
I’ve seen people on Reddit panic-buying 12 cans in November because they know the "Pumpkin Dry Spell" is coming. By the time you’re looking for pumpkin to make a random batch of muffins in April, you’ll likely be staring at an empty shelf where the cans used to be.
Best Ways to Use It (Beyond the Pie)
Since the texture is lighter and more liquid-y, it actually performs better in certain "non-baking" scenarios.
💡 You might also like: Kraft Shells and Cheese: Why the Original Blue Box Just Can't Compete
- The Savory Shift: I love whisking a few tablespoons into a marinara sauce. It doesn’t make the pasta taste like dessert; it just adds a velvety, earthy thickness.
- Smoothies: Because it’s thinner, it blends into a protein shake without turning it into a sludge.
- Pumpkin Chili: This is where the TJ’s version shines. It melts into the broth perfectly.
- Oatmeal Stir-in: A dollop of this with some cinnamon and a splash of maple syrup makes boring oats feel like a $15 brunch.
Comparison: Trader Joe's vs. The Others
In various blind taste tests, including some notable ones by Food & Wine, Trader Joe’s often lands in the middle or toward the bottom for baking.
Why? Because it’s "less squashy."
Some people find the flavor too mild. If you want that deep, hit-you-over-the-head pumpkin flavor, you might be disappointed. But if you want something that tastes fresh, bright, and slightly sweet without being heavy, this is your winner.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Haul
If you're planning to stock up this season, here is how to handle the Trader Joe's specific quirks:
- Check the Date: While canned goods last a long time, the organic stuff can sometimes have a shorter "best by" window than the preservative-laden cans.
- Strain It: If a recipe calls for "Libby’s" specifically, put the TJ’s puree in a fine-mesh strainer lined with a coffee filter for 20 minutes. You’ll be shocked at how much water drains out.
- Buy Early: Don't wait until the week of Thanksgiving. The supply chain for organic pumpkins can be finicky, and once a region sells out, that’s usually it for the year.
- Freeze the Leftovers: Most recipes use 1 cup, but the can holds nearly 2. Don’t let the rest mold in the fridge. Freeze it in an ice cube tray. Each cube is roughly 2 tablespoons—perfect for dropping into a morning smoothie or a bowl of dog kibble.
At the end of the day, it's a $2-ish can of organic veggies. It’s not going to change your life, but knowing that it’s a "wetter" puree will definitely save your next batch of muffins from being a damp disaster.