If you’ve ever walked into a wild bird boutique or scrolled through the endless pages of online garden centers, you’ve seen them. They look like little wooden dinner tables or simple mesh rectangles. They don't have the high-tech gravity-fed tubes of a squirrel-proof feeder or the bright red plastic of a hummingbird reservoir. They’re tray feeders for birds, and honestly, they are probably the most underrated tool in your backyard birding kit.
Most people skip the tray. They think it’s messy. They think squirrels will have a field day. While they aren't exactly wrong about the squirrels, they’re missing out on the incredible diversity of species that simply refuse to use a tube feeder.
Have you ever seen a Northern Cardinal try to squeeze its chunky body onto a tiny metal perch? It’s awkward. It looks uncomfortable. Cardinals are ground-feeders by nature; they want a flat surface where they can see their surroundings while they crack open a sunflower seed. This is where the tray—or platform feeder—changes the game for your backyard ecosystem.
The Raw Reality of Choosing a Tray Feeder
Basically, if you want to see the "cool" birds, you need a tray. We’re talking about Rose-breasted Grosbeaks, Blue Jays, Juncos, and even the occasional Evening Grosbeak if you're lucky enough to live in their range. These birds have specific morphological needs. A tray feeder for birds mimics the natural flat ground where many of these species evolved to forage, but it keeps the food off the actual dirt where mold and pathogens like Salmonella or Mycoplasma gallisepticum (house finch eye disease) thrive.
But here’s the thing: not all trays are equal.
If you buy a solid-bottom wooden tray, you’ve just bought a bird-sized bathtub for bacteria. Rain falls, the seed gets soggy, the wood stays damp, and suddenly you have a fermented mess that can actually kill the birds you’re trying to help. Real experts look for metal mesh. Fine-gauge stainless steel or powder-coated aluminum mesh allows water to drain instantly and air to circulate around the seed. This keeps the "groats" and kernels dry.
It’s about airflow. Always.
Ground Trays vs. Hanging Platforms
You've got choices. A ground tray is basically a low-profile platform with short legs, maybe two or three inches off the grass. This is the VIP lounge for Mourning Doves and Sparrows. If you’ve got a lot of Towhees in your area, this is your best bet.
Hanging trays, on the other hand, give you a bit more flexibility. You can tuck them under an eave or hang them from a shepherd’s hook. The height offers a bit of protection from neighborhood cats, though a determined feline can still jump surprisingly high. If you’re worried about the local tabby, keep your ground feeders at least ten feet away from thick brush where a predator could hide. Open sightlines are a bird's best friend.
What to Put on the Menu
Don't just dump a "wild bird mix" from the grocery store onto your tray. Most of those bags are 80% "filler" seeds like red milo or wheat that most songbirds won't even touch. They’ll just kick it onto the ground, creating a pile of waste that attracts rodents.
Instead, try these:
🔗 Read more: The Reese's Peanut Butter Chocolate Cake Cheesecake is Better Than the Original
- Black Oil Sunflower Seeds: The gold standard. High fat, thin shells.
- Shelled Peanuts: Blue Jays will lose their minds for these. Seriously.
- Mealworms: If you want Bluebirds, this is the secret.
- Suet Nuggets: Great for winter energy.
- Fruit Chunks: Oranges or apples can attract Orioles or Tanagers in the spring.
The beauty of a tray is that you can offer "clumsy" food. You can't put a whole peanut in the shell inside a tube feeder, but on a tray? It’s a feast.
The Squirrel Problem (And How to Fix It)
Let’s be real. A tray feeder for birds is an open invitation to every squirrel in a three-block radius. It’s a buffet. There are no baffles on the tray itself to stop them.
If you hang your tray, use a disk-shaped baffle above it. If it’s on a pole, put a stovepipe baffle on the pole. But honestly? Some people just lean into it. They set up a dedicated "squirrel tray" far away from the bird station and fill it with cheap corn and peanuts. It’s called "diversion feeding." It works about 70% of the time, which, in the world of squirrel combat, is basically a victory.
Another pro tip: Safflower seed. Most squirrels hate the bitter taste of safflower, but Cardinals and Chickadees love it. If your tray is being overrun by furry acrobats, switch your entire tray to 100% safflower for two weeks. The squirrels will eventually get frustrated and move on to your neighbor's yard.
Maintenance Isn't Optional
You have to clean these things. I know, it’s a chore. But because tray feeders are so open, they get dirty fast. Bird droppings land right where the food is.
Every couple of weeks, or more often if it’s been rainy, you need to dump the old seed and scrub the tray with a 10% bleach solution (one part bleach to nine parts water). Rinse it until you can’t smell the bleach anymore. Let it dry completely in the sun. UV rays are a natural disinfectant, too.
A Lesson from the Cornell Lab of Ornithology
Project FeederWatch, run by the Cornell Lab, has decades of data showing that feeder height and type directly correlate to which species show up. Their research suggests that platform feeders have the highest "species richness" of any feeder type. This means you’ll see a wider variety of birds on one tray than you will on three different tubes.
It’s about the landing zone. Large birds need space to stabilize. Small birds like the safety of a group. A large tray allows four or five birds to feed simultaneously without the "pecking order" fights that happen at narrow perches. It’s more social. It’s more natural.
Thinking Beyond the Wooden Box
Some of the best tray feeders for birds today are made from recycled plastic (poly-lumber). This stuff is indestructible. It doesn’t rot, it doesn't peel, and you can power-wash it without worrying about splinters. Brands like Juncos or Birds Choice have mastered this.
Then there are the "fly-through" feeders. These are trays with a roof. The roof keeps the snow and rain off the seed, which is great, but it can sometimes spook larger birds like Hawks-fearing Doves who want a 360-degree view of the sky. If you go for a fly-through, make sure the gap between the tray and the roof is at least 8 to 10 inches.
The Seasonal Shift
Your tray should change with the calendar.
In the spring, I usually put out crushed eggshells. Nesting females need the calcium to produce their own eggs. It’s a simple thing, but you’ll see them flock to a tray specifically for those shells.
In the winter, I switch to high-energy suet blends and sunflower hearts (no shells). Why no shells? Because in the freezing cold, birds need to conserve every calorie. If they don't have to spend energy cracking a shell, they have a better chance of surviving a sub-zero night. Plus, you won't have a mountain of shells rotting under the snow come April.
Actionable Steps for Your Backyard
If you're ready to upgrade your birding game, don't just go buy the cheapest plastic tray you find. Follow this checklist to get it right the first time:
💡 You might also like: Balloon Ideas for Valentines: Why Most People Settle for Boring Decor (and How to Fix It)
- Prioritize Drainage: Only buy a tray with a perforated metal bottom. If it's solid wood or plastic, walk away.
- Location, Location, Location: Place your tray about 10-12 feet from a bush or tree. This gives birds a "staging area" to look for predators before landing, and a quick escape route if a Cooper's Hawk zooms by.
- The "No-Waste" Strategy: If you're worried about the mess, use "hulless" or "no-mess" seed mixes. They cost more per pound, but 100% of it gets eaten, and nothing grows in your lawn underneath.
- Height Matters: If you want Juncos and Sparrows, keep it low (ground level). If you want Grosbeaks and Jays, hang it at eye level.
- Be Consistent: Once birds find a reliable tray, they’ll check it every single morning. If you fill it at the same time, you’ll actually start to see them waiting for you on nearby branches. It’s a pretty cool feeling.
The tray feeder is the ultimate equalizer in the bird world. It’s not fancy, it’s not particularly "smart," but it works. It invites the shy ground-dwellers and the heavy-bodied beauties that the tube feeders ignore. Start with one, use good seed, and keep it clean. Your backyard bird count will thank you.