Let’s be real for a second. If you walk into any tack room, you’re going to see a wall of metal that looks more like a medieval torture collection than a set of communication tools. It’s intimidating. You see a "Ported Kimberwicke" or a "Twisted Wire Snaffle" and honestly, if you aren't a bit confused, you probably aren't paying attention. Most riders just grab what their trainer tells them to use, but understanding a horse bit severity chart is about way more than just picking a piece of equipment. It is about the physics of the horse's mouth and, frankly, the skill in your own hands.
Bits aren't inherently "mean." People are. But some bits definitely have a higher potential for "ouch" than others.
The biggest lie in the equestrian world is that a snaffle is always gentle and a curb is always harsh. That's just wrong. A thin, wire snaffle in the hands of a frustrated beginner can do significantly more damage than a high-end spade bit in the hands of a master vaquero. We need to look at the mechanics—leverage, surface area, and pressure points—to actually rank these things.
👉 See also: Mars in the 6th House Synastry: Why This Placement Feels Like a Full-Time Job
The Physics of "Ouch": How Severity is Actually Measured
When we talk about a horse bit severity chart, we are looking at where the pressure goes. Your horse has a few "hot spots" in their mouth: the bars (the sensitive, toothless gums), the tongue, the roof of the mouth (the palate), and the corners of the lips.
Some bits spread pressure out. Others concentrate it like a laser.
Think about a snowshoe versus a stiletto heel. A wide, thick bit is the snowshoe; it distributes the weight of your pull over a larger area. A thin, twisted wire bit is the stiletto. Same amount of force, but because the surface area is tiny, it bites. This is the first rule of bit severity. The thinner the mouthpiece, the more severe the bit. Then there’s the "nutcracker effect." This happens with single-jointed bits. When you pull, the bit folds in a V-shape. That joint can poke the sensitive roof of the horse's mouth while the sides squeeze the bars. It’s a double whammy. Many horses find this incredibly distressing, which is why you see them tossing their heads or gaping their mouths.
Mouthpiece Textures and Materials
If you see a bit with "slow twists" or "corkscrews," you're looking at something designed to create friction. It’s meant to get a horse’s attention by being uncomfortable. Is it necessary? Most modern trainers like Warwick Schiller or dressage experts would argue that if you need a "cheese grater" in your horse’s mouth to stop, you actually have a training problem, not a bit problem.
Materials matter too. Sweet iron and copper encourage salivation, which keeps the mouth "soft" and responsive. Cold stainless steel is fine, but it doesn't offer that "tasty" incentive. Rubber or plastic bits are often seen as the gentlest, but be careful—if they are too thick, they can be bulky and uncomfortable for horses with small mouths or low palates.
Breaking Down the Horse Bit Severity Chart by Category
You can't just list bits 1 through 10. It’s not a linear scale because the type of pressure changes. Let’s look at the groups.
The "Gentle" Tier (Low Severity)
This is usually where beginners and young horses start.
- Soft Rubber Mullens: These are straight bars. No joint, no nutcracker. Just simple pressure on the tongue and bars.
- Double-Jointed Snaffles (French Link or Lozenge): These are the gold standard for many. Because there are two joints, the bit lays flat across the tongue. It doesn't poke the roof of the mouth.
- Thick Eggbutt Snaffles: The "eggbutt" refers to the hinge. It’s fixed, so it doesn't pinch the corners of the lips like a loose ring might.
The "Moderate" Tier (The Transition)
This is where things get a bit more technical.
- Single-Jointed D-Rings: Standard, but that V-shape we talked about makes them slightly more assertive than a French link.
- Pelhams: Here comes leverage. A Pelham has two sets of reins. One acts like a snaffle; the other acts like a curb. It’s a "best of both worlds" bit, but it requires a rider who can handle two sets of reins without getting tangled.
- Low Port Curbs: A curb bit uses shanks. The longer the shank, the more leverage you have. A low port gives the tongue a little room, which some horses prefer.
The "High Severity" Tier (Expert Only)
If you see these in a catalog, they usually come with a "use with caution" vibe.
- Long-Shanked Cathedral Bits: These have a high arch (the port) that can hit the roof of the mouth. They are designed for incredibly subtle cues in highly trained western horses. In the wrong hands? Disaster.
- Twisted Wire Snaffles: Just say no. Unless you are a professional correcting a very specific, dangerous habit in a controlled environment, these are generally considered archaic and unnecessary.
- Waterford Bits: These look like a chain of metal balls. They are designed to prevent a horse from "grabbing" the bit and leaning on it. It's very flexible, but it can be quite "bumpy" and sharp if used aggressively.
The Secret Ingredient: Your Hands
You’ve probably heard the saying, "A bit is only as harsh as the hands that hold it." It’s a cliché because it’s true. A "mild" snaffle used by someone who balances by pulling on the reins is a tool of agony. Meanwhile, a high-leverage curb in the hands of a master might never even engage; the horse feels the weight of the shanks move and reacts before the pressure even hits.
Dr. Hilary Clayton, a renowned expert in equine biomechanics, has done extensive studies on bit pressure using sensors. Her research shows that even "gentle" bits can exert significant force on the thin skin of the bars. The bars of the mouth are literally just bone covered by a thin layer of sensitive tissue. There’s no padding there.
When you look at a horse bit severity chart, you have to factor in your own "Hands Severity Rating."
- Do you have a steady, independent seat?
- Do you use your legs and core to stop, or just your arms?
- Can you give "the release" the millisecond the horse obeys?
If the answer to those is "no," then any bit you use is going to be high-severity.
Common Misconceptions About "Harsh" Bits
One of the weirdest things I see is people putting a "stronger" bit on a horse that bolts.
If a horse is running away, it’s usually because they are in pain, terrified, or simply haven't been taught to stop off the seat. Adding a sharper bit might stop them once or twice through sheer shock, but eventually, they’ll just learn to "brace" against that pain too. Now you have a horse that’s bolting and has a mouth made of stone.
Another one: "He likes this bit because he chews on it."
Actually, frantic chewing or "champing" can be a sign of stress. You want a quiet, moist mouth. If the horse is clacking the metal like a typewriter, they are likely trying to find a way to escape the pressure.
📖 Related: Power XL Grill Air Fryer Combo: What Most People Get Wrong About This Kitchen Workhorse
Finding the Right Fit for Your Horse
Every horse’s mouth is shaped differently. Some have "fleshy" tongues that take up all the room, meaning they hate thick bits. Others have low palates, meaning any jointed bit is going to poke them.
You should actually stick your fingers in your horse's mouth (carefully!). Feel the height of the palate. Look at the thickness of the tongue. If you see scarring on the bars or the corners of the lips, that's a huge red flag that the previous bit—regardless of where it sits on a chart—was too severe for that horse or that rider.
Actionable Steps for Choosing a Bit
Don't just buy what’s on sale. Follow these steps to ensure you’re being as humane as possible.
- Start with a Bit Assessment: Have an equine dentist check for wolf teeth or hooks. Sometimes "bit resistance" is actually just a tooth stabbing them in the cheek.
- The "Less is More" Trial: Try the mildest bit possible (like a double-jointed lozenge snaffle) and see if the horse can perform the task. If they can’t, ask yourself if it’s a training gap.
- Check the Width: A bit that is too narrow will pinch the lips; too wide and it will slide back and forth, causing friction burns. You want about a quarter-inch of space on either side of the mouth.
- Consult a Bit Fitter: Yes, this is a real job. Professional bit fitters carry hundreds of options and can watch you ride to see how the horse reacts to different metal alloys and shapes.
- Check Your Ego: Don't use a certain bit just because it's "traditional" for your discipline. If your dressage horse is happier in a Baucher bit than a loose ring, use the Baucher.
Choosing a bit is a conversation between you and your horse. A horse bit severity chart is a great map, but you're the one driving the car. The goal is always to use the lightest touch possible. If you find yourself pulling harder and harder, it’s time to put the bits away for a day, get in the round pen, and work on the fundamentals. Your horse’s mouth—and their trust in you—will thank you for it.