Unpasteurised Explained: Why This Raw Food Debate is Making a Massive Comeback

You've probably seen the word "unpasteurised" printed in small, slightly cautious-looking font on a block of fancy French Brie or a bottle of green juice at the farmer's market. Maybe you’ve even seen it on a bottle of "raw" milk tucked away in a health food store fridge. It sounds a bit rebellious. A bit rustic. But what does unpasteurised mean, really?

Honestly, it’s just a fancy way of saying "as it came out of the source."

Most of the liquids we consume—milk, cider, orange juice, even some honey—undergo a heat treatment called pasteurisation. Named after Louis Pasteur, the 19th-century French chemist who figured out that heating things up kills the microscopic nasties that make us sick. When something is unpasteurised, it has skipped that thermal bath. It’s raw. It’s alive. And depending on who you ask, it’s either a nutritional powerhouse or a ticking time bomb for your gut.

The Science of Going Raw

When a liquid is pasteurised, it’s usually heated to a specific temperature for a set amount of time. For milk, that’s often around 72°C (161°F) for 15 seconds. This kills pathogens like Salmonella, E. coli, and Listeria.

💡 You might also like: Why Effects of Not Having Enough Sleep Are Actually Wrecking Your Brain

Unpasteurised products keep everything intact.

The heat doesn't just kill the bad guys; it can also alter the good guys. Think of enzymes. These are proteins that help our bodies break down food. In raw milk, for instance, you have lipase and phosphatase. Many enthusiasts argue that when we heat milk, we denature these enzymes, making the milk harder to digest. If you’ve ever met someone who swears they are "lactose intolerant" but can drink raw milk without bloating, this is usually the reason they cite.

But it’s a gamble.

The microbes don't care about your digestive comfort. If a cow has an udder infection or if the milking equipment isn't surgically clean, those pathogens stay in the final product. Without that heat step, there’s no safety net. That’s why unpasteurised foods are such a polarizing topic in the world of public health.

Why Is Everyone Talking About Unpasteurised Milk Specifically?

Milk is the big one. It’s the battleground.

For decades, raw milk was basically the "Voldemort" of the dairy aisle. We didn't talk about it, and in many places, it was flat-out illegal to sell. But things are shifting. People are becoming increasingly skeptical of ultra-processed foods. They want "real" food. They want the stuff their great-grandparents drank.

What happens to milk when it isn't heated?

1. The flavor profile changes completely. It’s creamier, more complex, and tastes like the grass the cows actually ate.
2. The bacterial diversity stays high. We’re talking about probiotics that are naturally occurring, not just added back in by a lab.
3. The cream rises to the top. Literally. Most unpasteurised milk is also non-homogenized.

Dr. Catherine Donnelly, a food scientist at the University of Vermont and an expert on Listeria, has spent years researching the safety of traditional cheeses. She notes that while the risks are real, the context matters. Hard cheeses made from unpasteurised milk, like traditional Gruyère or Roquefort, have a long history of safety because the aging process and the acidity create a hostile environment for bad bacteria. Fresh unpasteurised milk, however, is a different beast entirely. It has no protective barrier.

The Real Risks Nobody Mentions

It’s not just a stomach ache.

📖 Related: Plank with dumbbell row: Why your core is still weak and how to fix it

We often think of food poisoning as a "bad night in the bathroom." But unpasteurised milk can carry Brucella or Campylobacter. In rare cases, these can lead to long-term issues like Guillain-Barré syndrome or kidney failure. This is why the FDA in the US and various health departments in the UK and Australia are so incredibly strict about it. They aren't just trying to kill your "farm-to-table" vibe; they are looking at the data from the early 1900s when milk-borne illnesses were a leading cause of death.

Beyond the Dairy Aisle: Juice and Honey

Milk gets all the press, but unpasteurised cider and juice are arguably more common. If you’ve ever bought "cold-pressed" juice that expires in three days, it might be unpasteurised. Or, it might have undergone High-Pressure Processing (HPP).

HPP is the modern workaround.

Instead of using heat, the juice is subjected to massive amounts of pressure—equivalent to the pressure at the bottom of the ocean. This kills pathogens while keeping the taste fresh. Technically, this isn't "pasteurised" in the traditional sense, but it's also not "raw" in its purest form.

Then there's honey.

Most supermarket honey is heated and filtered until it looks like clear liquid gold. Unpasteurised or "raw" honey is different. It’s cloudy. It contains bits of pollen, propolis, and wax. It’s full of antioxidants that disappear when you boil it. However, it also contains spores of Clostridium botulinum. For adults, this is fine. For babies under one year old, it can be fatal. This is the perfect example of how "unpasteurised" can be a health boon for one person and a deadly risk for another.

The Legal Maze of Raw Food

Depending on where you live, "unpasteurised" can be a legal headache.

• In the UK, you can buy raw milk directly from farmers, but not in supermarkets.
• In some US states, you have to buy a "herd share," meaning you technically own a piece of a cow to get its milk legally.
• In Canada, selling raw milk for human consumption is generally a no-go.

It’s a weird world where you can buy cigarettes and high-proof grain alcohol but might have to go to a dark parking lot to buy a gallon of raw cream. This "prohibition" vibe has only made the raw food movement stronger. It’s become a symbol of food sovereignty.

Does It Actually Taste Better?

Yes. Usually.

Pasteurisation is a blunt instrument. It kills the bad, but it also mutes the nuances. If you ever have the chance to try an unpasteurised Camembert from Normandy, take it. The texture is more "oozy." The smell is… assertive. It smells like a wet barn in the best possible way. When you heat that cheese during pasteurisation, you lose those volatile aromatic compounds. You get a product that is consistent and safe, sure, but also a bit boring.

Same goes for apple cider. Unpasteurised cider has a tang and a "funk" that the clear stuff in the plastic jugs can't touch. It’s the difference between a live concert and a studio recording. One is polished; the other has soul.

Making the Choice: How to Be Smart About It

If you’re curious about exploring unpasteurised foods, you don't have to just dive in blindly. There are ways to mitigate the risk without losing the benefits.

Check the Source

Don't buy raw milk from a guy with a bucket in an open field. Professional raw dairies (like those certified by the Raw Milk Institute) follow incredibly strict hygiene protocols. They test their milk daily for bacterial counts. A clean farm with healthy, grass-fed cows is exponentially safer than a factory farm trying to sell raw products.

Respect the Cold Chain

Unpasteurised products are alive. They spoil fast. If that raw juice sits in your warm car for an hour, the bacterial colonies are having a party. Keep it at or below 4°C (40°F) at all times.

Know Your Own Body

If you are pregnant, elderly, or have a compromised immune system, the "unpasteurised" label should probably be a "no-go" for you. The risk-to-reward ratio just doesn't add up. For a healthy adult with a robust microbiome, the risk is statistically low, though never zero.

Actionable Steps for the Curious Consumer

If you want to experience what unpasteurised really means without ending up in a hospital bed, start slow.

1. Start with Hard Cheese: Look for "Lait Cru" on French labels. Hard, aged cheeses like Parmigiano-Reggiano are technically unpasteurised but are considered very safe due to their low moisture and high salt content.
2. Try Raw Honey: It’s an easy entry point. Use it as a natural sweetener in lukewarm tea (boiling water will kill the enzymes you’re paying for) or on toast.
3. Vet Your Dairy: If you’re going for raw milk, visit the farm. Ask about their somatic cell counts. Ask how they clean their lines. A transparent farmer is a safe farmer.
4. Read the Fine Print: Look for the "Warning" labels required by law. They aren't there to scare you away, but to ensure you’re making an informed choice.
5. Listen to Your Gut: Literally. Some people find raw dairy revolutionary for their digestion. Others find it too heavy. Every microbiome is different.

Unpasteurised isn't just a food trend; it's a return to a specific type of relationship with what we eat. It requires more responsibility from the consumer and more transparency from the producer. It’s food with the training wheels taken off.

Whether you find that exhilarating or terrifying is entirely up to you.