Hard court tennis has a funny way of making experts look like amateurs. Going into New York this past August, the chatter was almost entirely focused on Jannik Sinner. Honestly, it made sense. He was the defending champ, he had a massive win streak on hard courts, and he’d spent 65 weeks at the top of the rankings. But if you followed the US Open picks 2025 early on, you saw a shift that most of the "safe" money missed until it was too late.
Carlos Alcaraz didn't just win; he dismantled the narrative.
The vibe at Flushing Meadows this year was electric, partly because the stakes felt higher than a standard Grand Slam. We were watching the first time in 23 years that a major final didn't feature a single member of the Big Three (Federer, Nadal, or Djokovic). It was the official passing of the torch, even if Novak Djokovic was still lurking in the semifinals.
The Reality of the Alcaraz "Shave and Win" Strategy
You probably saw the hair. Before the tournament even started, Alcaraz showed up with a buzzcut that had social media in a frenzy. He joked that his brother messed up a haircut with the machine, so he just shaved it all off. Frances Tiafoe called him "aerodynamic." Whatever you call it, it worked.
When it comes to us open picks 2025, Alcaraz was the second favorite behind Sinner (+175 vs +110), but his path to the trophy was actually more dominant than the odds suggested. He only lost one set the entire tournament. One. That happened in the final against Sinner, a 6-2, 3-6, 6-1, 6-4 masterclass.
Why Sinner Couldn't Hold On
Sinner was a machine for most of the year, but New York in 2025 was punishing. By the time he hit the final, the Italian looked a bit predictable. He admitted it himself afterward. He’s a world-class ball-striker, but Alcaraz brought a level of "spectacular chaos" that Sinner couldn't calculate.
- The Stats That Matter: Alcaraz won 20 out of 27 net points in that final.
- The Ranking Shift: With this win, Alcaraz didn't just take the trophy; he snatched the World No. 1 spot back.
- The Rivalry: This was their 15th meeting and their third consecutive Grand Slam final against each other. That’s a record, by the way. No two men in the Open Era had ever played three straight major finals in a single season.
The Women’s Side: Sabalenka and the Anisimova Surprise
If the men’s draw was about the "New Big Two," the women’s draw was a lesson in resilience. Aryna Sabalenka did something that hasn't been done since Serena Williams in 2014—she defended her US Open title.
But let’s be real: the story everyone was talking about wasn't just Sabalenka. It was Amanda Anisimova.
Most us open picks 2025 had Anisimova as a long shot, maybe +2500 if you were feeling lucky. She had been through the wringer, including a brutal 6-0, 6-0 loss at Wimbledon earlier in the year. Yet, she found some New York magic, taking down the No. 2 seed Iga Swiatek in the quarterfinals. It was one of those "phoenix rising" moments that makes the Open so special.
📖 Related: Davante Adams Rookie Card: Why Modern Collectors Are Finally Getting It Right
Sabalenka’s Mental Fortress
Sabalenka is just different now. She used to crumble under the pressure of being the favorite. In 2025, she was the No. 1 seed and played like it. She only dropped one set the whole way through. In the final against Anisimova, she won 6-3, 7-6, showing a level of composure in that second-set tiebreak that would have been impossible for her three years ago.
Honestly, she’s basically the queen of the hard courts at this point. With four majors now, she’s tied with Naomi Osaka for the third-most active titles on the WTA tour.
What Most People Got Wrong About Djokovic
Everyone wanted to see if Novak could get to 25. He made it to the semifinals, which is insane for a 38-year-old, making him the oldest player in the Open Era to reach the semis of all four majors in a single year.
But the "safe" picks for Djokovic to win it all ignored a glaring trend: he didn't win a single set in any of his major semifinal matches this year. In New York, Alcaraz beat him 6-4, 7-6, 6-2. Novak is still a legend, but the physical gap between him and the 22-year-old Alcaraz has finally become a canyon.
Breaking Down the Dark Horses
While the stars took the trophies, the 2025 tournament was a gold mine for anyone watching the "next gen" stars.
- Victoria Mboko: The 18-year-old Canadian was the breakout star of the summer. She beat four Grand Slam champions in Montreal and made a serious run in New York. If you aren't watching her for 2026, you're missing out.
- Jack Draper: He was the British hope and actually had the fourth-best odds to win. He didn't get the trophy, but he proved he belongs in the top 10 conversation.
- Ben Shelton: The home favorite reached the quarterfinals and continues to be the most exciting American man on tour. He's got the serve, but he still needs that one "big win" against the Sinner/Alcaraz wall.
The Business of the 2025 Open
It’s worth noting that this wasn't just a win for the players; it was a massive payday. The USTA handed out $90 million in total compensation. That’s a 20% jump from 2024. Alcaraz and Sabalenka each walked away with $5 million.
Even the doubles players saw a boost, with the winning teams in men’s, women’s, and mixed doubles each banking $1 million. The reimagined Mixed Doubles Championship actually sold out Arthur Ashe Stadium for two days—something almost unheard of for that format.
Final Actionable Takeaways for Tennis Fans
If you're looking at these results to figure out what happens next in the tennis world, keep these points in your back pocket:
- The Surface Matters: Sabalenka and Sinner are currently the undisputed rulers of hard courts, but Alcaraz has the "higher ceiling" when he's focused.
- Watch the Youth Movement: Players like Victoria Mboko and Joao Fonseca aren't just prospects anymore; they are actively disrupting the draws of established veterans.
- The Big Three Era is Over: For the first time, we can say it without a "maybe." Novak is still elite, but the tournament wins are now flowing through the Alcaraz-Sinner rivalry.
- Resilience is a Skill: Amanda Anisimova’s run proves that form is temporary, but class and mental toughness are everything in a two-week grind like the US Open.
Keep an eye on the Australian Open 2026 odds early. If Alcaraz stays healthy and keeps the "aerodynamic" buzzcut, he’s going to be very hard to bet against.
The 2025 season ended with a clear message: the new generation isn't coming—it's already here, and it's making a lot of money doing it.