It felt like the air physically left Salt Lake City. Honestly, if you were there, you know that specific silence. One second, the Rice-Eccles Stadium crowd—a record-breaking 54,383 people—is screaming because their defense just ended the game. The next, a yellow flag is lying on the turf, and everything changes.
The Utah vs BYU 2024 matchup wasn't just another chapter of the Holy War. It was a 22-21 heartbreaker that basically broke the internet and the Big 12’s disciplinary bank account.
The Call That Stole the Show
Let's get straight to the thing everyone is still arguing about in the grocery store aisles: the holding penalty.
Utah had it won.
The Utes were up 21-19. BYU faced a 4th-and-10 from their own nine-yard line. Jake Retzlaff, the BYU quarterback who’d been struggling to find his rhythm all night, dropped back. He got absolutely buried. A sack. The game should have been over right there. Fans were already preparing to storm the field.
Then came the flag.
Zemaiah Vaughn was whistled for defensive holding. The replay showed Vaughn grabbing BYU receiver Hinckley Ropati. Was it enough to warrant a flag at that moment? That depends on which side of Point of the Mountain you live on.
Utah Athletic Director Mark Harlan didn't wait for the post-game press conference to vent. He basically stormed the post-game podium and told the world the game was "stolen" from them. It cost him $40,000 in Big 12 fines, but he said what every Ute fan was thinking.
Brandon Rose and the Second Quarter Surge
Kinda weird to think about now, but Utah was actually in control for a huge chunk of this game. With Cam Rising out (again) and Isaac Wilson struggling, Kyle Whittingham rolled the dice on Brandon Rose. It was his first career start.
Rose looked like a hero for about thirty minutes.
In the second quarter, Utah went on a tear:
- Brant Kuithe caught a 20-yard TD pass from Rose.
- Kuithe punched in a 1-yard run after a wildcat snap.
- Micah Bernard caught a 7-yard TD pass.
By halftime, Utah was up 21-10. The stadium was vibrating. BYU’s undefeated season looked like it was heading for the dumpster. But the thing about this 2024 BYU team was their weird, almost annoying ability to hang around. They didn't panic. They just... waited.
✨ Don't miss: Shin Guard for Football: What Most Players Get Wrong About Protection
How BYU Flipped the Script
Jake Retzlaff finished 15-of-33 for 219 yards. Not exactly Heisman numbers, but he made the plays that mattered when the lights were the brightest.
The third quarter was a defensive slog. BYU chipped away with field goals. Will Ferrin, the kicker who ended up being the MVP of the night, was steady while everything else was chaotic.
The turning point wasn't even an offensive play. Keelan Marion took a kickoff 96 yards to the house earlier in the game, which kept BYU within striking distance when the offense was stagnant. It reminded everyone that in a rivalry game, special teams are usually where the weirdness starts.
The Final Drive Breakdown
After the controversial holding call gave BYU a fresh set of downs, Retzlaff suddenly looked like a different player.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Lakers Zip Up Hoodie Is Still the Only NBA Gear That Actually Matters
- He found Chase Roberts for 30 yards.
- He hit Darius Lassiter for another 12.
- Hinckley Ropati (the guy involved in the holding call) ripped off a 14-yard run.
They marched 65 yards in less than two minutes. Will Ferrin stepped up for a 44-yard field goal with three seconds left. It was straight down the middle. 22-21.
The Fallout: Big 12 Chaos
The Utah vs BYU 2024 game didn't just affect the win-loss column. It shifted the entire power dynamic of the Big 12 in its first year with the "Four Corner" schools.
BYU moved to 9-0. They stayed the lone undefeated team in the conference and kept their playoff hopes alive. Utah, on the other hand, fell to 4-5. It was their fifth loss in a row. For a team that was picked to win the conference in the preseason, it was a total collapse.
Honestly, the most human part of the whole night was seeing Kyle Whittingham after the game. Usually, he's a stone wall. This time? He looked exhausted. He called the officiating "ridiculous" and basically left it at that.
📖 Related: Team USA Basketball Carmelo Anthony: Why He Is the Real International GOAT
Actionable Insights for the Rivalry's Future
If you're looking at how this changes the Holy War moving forward, there are a few things to keep an eye on:
- Quarterback Stability: BYU found their guy in Retzlaff, but Utah is entering a massive transition period. The Brandon Rose experiment showed flashes, but the search for the next "face of the program" after Cam Rising is officially on.
- Officiating Transparency: Expect the Big 12 to face massive pressure regarding how they communicate late-game calls. The "accidentally" leaked document confirming the holding call didn't exactly soothe the anger in Salt Lake City.
- Recruiting Momentum: Wins like this are massive for recruiting. BYU being the "team to beat" in the state for the 2024 season gives Kalani Sitake a huge hammer to swing on the trail.
The best thing you can do now is re-watch the fourth quarter without the sound on. You’ll see the tactical adjustments BYU made—spreading the field and testing Utah's secondary when they were gassed. It wasn't just a "lucky" flag; it was a team that knew how to capitalize on a single mistake.
Check the Big 12 tiebreaker rules if you’re still tracking BYU’s path to the championship, because that one-point win in Salt Lake was the thin margin that kept their season from unraveling.