If you’ve ever stood on the first tee at Victoria National Golf Club, you know that feeling. It’s not just the standard "don't-chunk-it" nerves. It’s the realization that you are about to play a course built on top of a literal abandoned strip mine. Most people think Indiana is just flat cornfields and basketball hoops, but Newburgh is different. This place is rugged. It’s jagged. Honestly, it’s one of the most intimidating visual experiences in American golf.
Tom Fazio gets a lot of flak for being a "resort" designer, someone who makes things pretty and playable for the average guy. Victoria National is the exception to that rule. He took 418 acres of scarred earth—land left behind by the Victoria Coal Mine—and turned it into a gauntlet of finger-lakes and massive elevation shifts. It opened in 1999 and immediately felt like it had been there for a century, mostly because the vegetation had already reclaimed the mine spoils.
You aren't just playing golf here. You’re navigating a labyrinth where water is basically everywhere.
The Brutality of the Back Nine
When the Korn Ferry Tour comes to town for the Championship, you see the best golfers in the world looking genuinely stressed. There’s a stretch at the end that locals call "The Gauntlet." It starts at the 14th and doesn't let go until you're back in the locker room.
The 14th is a long par four that requires a pinpoint drive just to see the green. Then comes 15, a par three where the green looks like a tiny island surrounded by deep, dark water. If the wind is kicking off the lakes, good luck. You see guys hitting two or three clubs more than they think they need just to stay dry. It's brutal. It's beautiful. Most of all, it's exhausting.
I’ve seen plenty of scratch golfers go into the 16th hole with a decent scorecard only to leave the 18th with a double-digit addition to their total. The 18th itself is a monster. It’s a par four that wraps around the water, daring you to bite off more than you can chew on the approach. If you miss right, you're dead. If you miss left, you’re in the drink.
Why the Land Matters
The history of the site is what gives Victoria National Golf Club its soul. This wasn't a pristine forest that someone decided to bulldoze. It was an industrial wasteland. The mining stopped in 1977, and for twenty years, nature just did its thing. Trees grew on the edges of the pits. The pits filled with rainwater and became deep, crystal-clear lakes.
📖 Related: Belmont Park Race Track Schedule: What Really Happened With the 2026 Reopening
Fazio didn't have to move as much dirt as you’d think because the miners had already done the heavy lifting. The "fingers" of land that jut out into the water are actually the old spoil piles. That’s why the fairways feel so isolated. You’re often playing in a corridor of land with water on both sides, separated from the rest of the world. It creates this eerie, quiet atmosphere. You don't hear traffic. You just hear the wind and the occasional splash of a Pro V1 hitting the water.
Membership and the Dormie Network
For a long time, Victoria National was a bit of a hidden gem, a private club that people talked about in hushed tones. Then the Dormie Network bought it in 2018. That changed everything.
They poured money into the infrastructure. We’re talking about high-end cottages, a massive renovation of the clubhouse, and a level of service that rivals the big-name destination spots like Bandon or Pinehurst. But unlike those places, it remains a private experience. You aren't fighting for tee times with 300 other tourists.
The cottages are the real deal. They’re designed for "stay and play" groups, which is basically how the club operates now. You fly into Evansville, get picked up, and you don't leave the property for three days. You eat like a king, drink good bourbon, and lose a dozen balls a day. It’s a specific kind of masochism that golfers seem to love.
The Course Record and Professional Struggles
Think about this: the course record is held by Sebastian Cappelen, who shot a 62 during the 2014 United Leasings Championship. That sounds low until you realize the average score for the field that week was significantly over par. Even the pros struggle with the greens. They are bentgrass, kept at tournament speeds almost year-round, and they have these subtle breaks that are nearly impossible to read if you haven't played there a dozen times.
I talked to a caddie there once who told me the secret isn't hitting it long. It’s knowing where to miss. If you miss in the wrong spot at Victoria National, you don't just have a hard chip; you have an impossible one. Or you're re-teeing.
Natural Beauty vs. Difficulty
The visual contrast is what sticks with you. The water isn't that murky brown color you see in most Midwest ponds. Because the lakes are so deep—some are over 60 feet deep—the water is a striking blue-green. It looks like something you’d see in the mountains, not ten miles from the Ohio River.
The wildlife is everywhere, too. Deer, hawks, and even the occasional bobcat have been spotted roaming the high fescue. It feels wild. Most modern courses feel "over-manicured," like a suburban lawn on steroids. Victoria National feels like it’s barely holding back the wilderness. If the mowers stopped for a week, the course would probably vanish back into the woods.
Agronomy and Maintenance
The superintendent at a place like this has a nightmare job. Keeping bentgrass healthy in the humid Indiana summers is a feat of engineering. They use huge fans around the greens to keep the air moving, otherwise, the grass would literally cook in the heat. It’s a high-maintenance lady, but when she’s dialed in, there isn't a better playing surface in the country.
💡 You might also like: Coach of Winnipeg Jets: Why Scott Arniel is Facing His Toughest Test Yet
The fairways are Zoysia, which is a godsend for the average player. It sits the ball up like it’s on a tee. You can’t really blame a bad lie for a fat shot here. If you chunk a wedge off Zoysia, that’s entirely on you.
Practical Advice for Your Visit
If you get the chance to play Victoria National Golf Club, don't be a hero. Leave the ego at the gate.
- Check the wind. If it’s blowing over 15 mph, the course becomes two shots harder. Adjust your expectations accordingly.
- Bring more balls than you think. Seriously. Even if you're a 5-handicap, you’re going to lose a few. The water is magnetic.
- Pace yourself on the front nine. The front is slightly more open and "easier," but if you use up all your mental energy there, the back nine will chew you up and spit you out.
- Take a caddie. You need someone to tell you where the "dead zones" are. There are bunkers and water hazards you can't see from the tee.
- Enjoy the food. The culinary program under the Dormie Network is top-tier. The steaks are world-class, and the atmosphere in the clubhouse at sunset is the best way to forget about the 95 you just shot.
The reality of Victoria National is that it's a "bucket list" course that actually lives up to the hype. It’s ranked in the Top 50 of Golf Digest’s Greatest Courses in America for a reason. It isn't just about the golf; it’s about the transformation of the land. It’s a testament to how something broken—a scarred strip mine—can be turned into something breathtakingly beautiful.
Just make sure you've practiced your mid-iron play before you show up. You're going to need it.
Actionable Next Steps
- Assess your membership options: Since it is a private club under the Dormie Network, look into their national membership model if you travel for golf. It grants access to all their properties across the US.
- Prep your game: Focus your practice sessions on long-iron accuracy and lag putting. The greens are huge and fast, and three-putts are the primary score-killer at Victoria National.
- Logistics: If you are visiting from out of state, fly into Evansville Regional Airport (EVV). It’s a quick 15-minute drive to the club. Arrange for on-site cottage lodging well in advance, as they fill up during the peak spring and fall seasons.