Darkness is heavy. Most people don't realize that when they first dive into the world of indie survival horror, but when you watch What Lies Below, the weight of the ocean is the first thing that hits you. It isn't just a game about holding your breath. It’s a claustrophobic masterclass in tension developed by a solo creator who clearly understands that what we don't see is way scarier than what we do.
Honestly, the indie scene is flooded with sub-nautical clones. You've seen them. They usually try to mimic Subnautica or Iron Lung, but What Lies Below carves out a niche that feels grittier. It’s a low-poly nightmare. You play as a diver stranded in the crushing depths of the ocean, specifically within an abyss that seems to defy geological logic.
The Setup That Hooks You
The premise is deceptively simple. You’re down there. Your sub is trashed. You have a harpoon, a flashlight that feels like it’s powered by a dying AA battery, and a ticking clock of oxygen. But the genius of the game lies in its sound design. You’ll hear a metallic groan. Was that the hull of your ship or something with teeth?
Gamers often overlook how much work goes into atmospheric pressure in digital spaces. In What Lies Below, the developer, Gidreit, uses a specific aesthetic—the PS1-style "crunchy" pixels—to mask the horrors. This is a deliberate choice. When you can’t quite tell if that shape in the distance is a rock or a leviathan, your brain fills in the gaps with the worst possible scenario.
Why the Survival Mechanics Actually Matter
Most survival games treat hunger and thirst like chores. You’re basically a digital babysitter for a stomach meter. Here, the mechanics are tied directly to your panic levels.
If you start sprinting or flailing because you think you saw eyes in the dark, your oxygen consumption spikes. It’s a vicious cycle. You need to stay calm to survive, but the game is designed to make staying calm nearly impossible. This creates a psychological "squeeze."
- Oxygen Management: It isn't just a timer; it's your leash.
- The Harpoon: You only have one shot before a slow reload. Don't miss.
- The Map: Forget GPS. You’re navigating by landmarks and a compass that feels terrifyingly unreliable.
I’ve seen streamers lose their minds over the "sonar" mechanic. You ping the area, and for a split second, the wireframe of the seafloor lights up. Then, darkness. It’s basically the "clap" scene from The Conjuring but under three miles of saltwater.
Watch What Lies Below and See the Horror for Yourself
If you’re planning to watch What Lies Below on a platform like Twitch or YouTube before buying it, pay attention to the lighting. The way light refracts in the water in this game is strangely beautiful despite the lo-fi graphics. But it’s the shadows that do the heavy lifting.
👉 See also: Uma Musume Pink Horse: Why Haru Urara Is The Internet's Favorite Underdog
There’s a specific moment—no spoilers—where the scale of the environment shifts. You realize you aren't just in a cave. You’re in a graveyard. The environmental storytelling is told through discarded equipment and logs that don't over-explain the lore. It respects your intelligence. It doesn't give you a 20-minute cutscene explaining why the monsters exist. They just do. And they want you dead.
The "Iron Lung" Comparison
People always bring up Iron Lung when talking about this game. It makes sense. Both involve small spaces and the crushing deep. However, while Iron Lung is a static experience where you’re looking through a camera, What Lies Below gives you agency. You’re out there. Your flippers are moving. You are vulnerable in a 360-degree space.
That vulnerability is the "secret sauce." Being stuck in a metal box is scary, sure. But being a fleshy human in a thin wetsuit while a creature the size of a skyscraper drifts past? That’s a different kind of existential dread.
Technical Performance and Accessibility
One of the best things about this title is that it runs on a toaster. Because it uses that retro-styled rendering, you don't need a $3,000 rig to experience the terror.
- Download the game (it’s usually found on Itch.io or Steam).
- Use headphones. This is non-negotiable.
- Turn off your room lights.
- Try not to hold your breath in real life (you will anyway).
The developer has been active in patching bugs, which is rare for these hyper-indie projects. They’ve tweaked the creature AI to make it less "predictable." Early versions had monsters that moved on set paths, but now they seem to hunt based on the noise you make. If you’re clanking around, expect company.
The Philosophy of Deep Sea Horror
Why are we so obsessed with the ocean? Scientists say we know more about the surface of Mars than the bottom of our own seas. That "Great Unknown" is the perfect canvas for horror. What Lies Below taps into thalassophobia—the fear of deep, vast bodies of water.
It’s not just about the monsters. It’s about the emptiness. The realization that if you died down there, nobody would ever find you. You’d just be another piece of debris on the ocean floor. The game leans into this isolation perfectly. There’s no radio contact. No "voice in your ear" guiding you. It’s just you and the bubbles.
Practical Tips for New Players
If you’re diving in for the first time, don't try to be a hero. This isn't an action game. It’s a "stay alive" game.
- Conserve your light. Shadows are scary, but being blind is worse.
- Listen more than you look. The audio cues tell you where the threats are long before your flashlight catches them.
- Don't spam the sonar. It’s like a dinner bell for some of the things living in the trenches.
- Check your corners. Yes, even in the water. Things like to hide in the crevices of the rocks.
Basically, treat every dive like it's your last. Because it probably will be.
Final Take on the Experience
What Lies Below isn't a long game. You can probably beat it in a few hours if you know what you’re doing. But those hours are dense. There’s no "filler" content. Every meter you descend feels earned.
✨ Don't miss: Why GTA San Andreas Still Rules the Open World Genre Decades Later
The ending—which I won't ruin—leaves you with a lingering sense of unease. It doesn't tie everything up in a neat little bow. Instead, it lets the mystery sit in your gut. It’s the kind of game that makes you look at the ocean differently the next time you’re at the beach. You’ll look at the horizon and think about what’s actually happening a few miles down.
How to Get Started with What Lies Below
To get the most out of your time with the game, follow these specific steps to ensure the atmosphere hits correctly:
1. Optimize Your Environment
This is a game of shadows. Calibrate your monitor brightness so the blacks are actually black, not dark gray. If you can see everything clearly, the game loses its primary weapon: the unknown.
2. Watch the Community Speedruns
After your first blind playthrough, check out the community on Discord or Reddit. There are some insane sequence breaks and "no-oxygen" challenges that show just how robust the game's physics actually are.
3. Support the Creator
Since this is an indie project, following Gidreit on social media or leaving a review on Steam actually helps the "What Lies Below" keyword gain traction, ensuring we get a sequel or more content updates in the future.
4. Explore the Lore Documents
Don't just rush to the end. Read the scattered notes. They provide context for the expedition that went wrong before you arrived, adding a layer of tragedy to the horror.