It is finally here. The first round of the fantasy football playoffs. Honestly, if you've made it this far, you’ve already survived the brutal gauntlet of the bye-week blues and that soul-crushing mid-season injury wave. But now the pressure changes. It’s different. A single bad decision in your week 15 start sit lineup doesn't just annoy you on a Tuesday morning—it ends your season.
You’re probably staring at your roster right now, oscillating between overthinking a "revenge game" narrative and wondering if that waiver wire pickup from Wednesday is actually a league-winner. Stop. Take a breath. Fantasy success in the postseason isn't about being a genius; it’s about not being your own worst enemy. We see it every year. Managers bench their stars because of a "tough matchup" only to watch those stars drop 20 points on their bench while a "sleeper" puts up a zero.
The playoffs are about volume and talent. Period. Let’s get into the weeds of who actually deserves a spot in your starting eleven this week and who needs to stay far away from your active roster.
👉 See also: Brazil Football Team Schedule Explained: Why the 2026 Road Looks Different
The Quarterback Quagmire: Trusting the Process
Quarterback is usually the easiest position to solve, yet it’s where people get the weirdest during the playoffs. You've got guys like Patrick Mahomes or Josh Allen. You play them. It doesn't matter if they’re playing against the '85 Bears or a high school JV squad. You start them.
The real week 15 start sit headaches come from that middle tier. Think about Jordan Love or Jared Goff. Goff is a prime example of a "dome vs. road" split that can ruin a season. If the Lions are at home in the Ford Field fast track, he’s an elite start. If he’s outdoors in the freezing rain in Chicago or Green Bay, his floor drops through the basement. You have to look at the environment, not just the jersey.
Take a look at the streaming options. If you’re desperate, someone like Will Levis might catch your eye because of a "favorable" matchup against a secondary that gives up big plays. Don't do it. Not in the playoffs. In Week 15, you want the guy with the high floor. You aren't looking for a 40-point ceiling if it comes with a 5-point floor. You want the 18-point guarantee. This is why guys like Brock Purdy are so valuable; the system provides a safety net that volatile deep-ball passers simply don't have.
Running Back Volatility and the "Workhorse" Myth
The "workhorse" running back is a dying breed, which makes the few remaining ones worth their weight in gold. When you’re looking at your week 15 start sit options at RB, you need to count touches, not yards. Yards are fickle. Touches are earned.
Christian McCaffrey—assuming he's healthy and on the field—is the obvious 1.01 every single week. But what about the murky backfields? Look at the Philadelphia Eagles or the Miami Dolphins. In Miami, you might have De'Von Achane and Raheem Mostert splitting duties. Achane is the home run threat, but Mostert often gets the "dirty" work inside the five-yard line. If you’re the underdog in your matchup, you play Achane for the upside. If you’re the favorite, you might prefer the steadiness of a guy who gets the goal-line looks.
- Rachaad White: He’s been a polarizing figure, but his involvement in the passing game makes him almost "matchup-proof" in PPR formats. Even if the Bucs are losing, he’s racking up points.
- Bijan Robinson: The talent is undeniable. The coaching usage? Sometimes questionable. But in Week 15, you bet on the talent.
- Tony Pollard: Watch the usage rates. If the efficiency is dipping but the carries are still there, he remains a volume-based start.
Avoid the "hot hand" trap unless the lead back is actually injured. Coaches say a lot of things to the media about "giving the young guy more looks," but when the season is on the line in December, they almost always lean on the veterans they trust to pick up a blitz.
Wide Receiver: Chasing Air Yards and Red Zone Targets
Wide receiver is where games are won and lost in the playoffs. It’s also where the most "noise" exists in the data. You’ll hear people talk about "cornerback shadows," and while some corners like Sauce Gardner or Patrick Surtain II are elite, the "shadow" narrative is often overstated. Great offensive coordinators like Kyle Shanahan or Ben Johnson find ways to move their best receivers into the slot to avoid those matchups.
Justin Jefferson and CeeDee Lamb are locked in. No discussion needed.
The real week 15 start sit debate revolves around the WR3 or Flex spot. Do you go with a high-target, low-yardage guy like Jakobi Meyers, or do you swing for the fences with a deep threat like Rashid Shaheed?
Honestly, it depends on your opponent. If your opponent has a juggernaut team and you’re projected to lose by 15, you need the volatility. You need the guy who can score two 50-yard touchdowns on three catches. If you’re projected to win, give me the guy who is going to see 8 to 10 targets, even if they’re all five-yard curls.
Understanding the Slot Advantage
In the modern NFL, the slot is a goldmine. Defenders can’t be as physical in the middle of the field due to player safety rules. This is why someone like Amon-Ra St. Brown is a statistical machine. When evaluating your fringe starters, check where they line up. If a receiver spends 40% or more of his time in the slot, his floor is inherently higher than an "X" receiver who lives on the boundary and relies on perfect sideline timing.
Tight Ends: The Land of Despair
Let's be real. If you don't have Travis Kelce, Sam LaPorta, or George Kittle, you're basically throwing darts at a board while blindfolded. The tight end position in 2024 and 2025 has been a chaotic mess.
In your week 15 start sit decisions, don't chase last week's touchdowns. If a random tight end caught two touchdowns on two targets last Sunday, he is almost certainly going to disappoint you this week. That is "touchdown regression" waiting to happen. Instead, look at "Route Participation." Is the tight end actually running a route on 80% of the quarterback's dropbacks, or is he staying in to block? If he’s blocking, he’s a zero-point risk.
Trey McBride has emerged as a target monster because he’s essentially the second wide receiver for his team. Those are the tight ends you want. If they aren't a top-two target on their own team, they shouldn't be in your lineup unless you have no other choice.
Defensive Streaming: The December Weather Factor
Defense and Special Teams (DST) streaming is a legitimate strategy, especially in Week 15. The weather starts to turn. Wind is the enemy of the passing game, not snow. Snow is actually fun; receivers know where they’re going and DBs slip. Wind, however, ruins everything.
If you see a forecast with 20+ mph sustained winds, you start the defense playing in that game. Period.
Look for matchups against backup quarterbacks or rookie signal-callers who haven't played in the cold before. The New York Jets or the Cleveland Browns often have elite defenses, but if their offense is constantly going three-and-out, the defense gets tired. A tired defense gives up points in the fourth quarter. It’s better to start a "worse" defense that has a "better" offense, because they’ll spend more time on the sideline resting while their team leads.
Common Pitfalls: The "Revenge Game" and Over-Tinkering
The "revenge game" is one of the biggest myths in fantasy football. Players are professionals. They want to win every game. While a player might be slightly more motivated to beat an old team, the coaching staff isn't going to change their entire game plan just to help a guy get a "revenge" touchdown. Don't base your week 15 start sit decisions on narratives. Base them on targets, touches, and Vegas totals.
Speaking of Vegas, use the betting lines. The "Implied Team Total" is the most accurate predictor of success we have. If Vegas thinks a team is going to score 30 points, you want pieces of that offense. If the over/under is 37, stay away from that game entirely if you can. Those low-scoring slogs are fantasy poison.
Then there is the "Thursday Night Trap." We’ve all done it. We start a mediocre player on Thursday because we want someone to cheer for. Then he gets 4 points and we spend the rest of the weekend staring at that 4-point hole in our lineup. Unless the player is a clear-cut starter, avoid the Thursday game. The "mini-bye" usually favors the defense, and the short week often leads to sloppy, low-scoring football.
Actionable Strategy for Week 15
To actually win this week, you need to be cold-blooded. Here is exactly how to handle the next 48 hours:
Check the injury reports, but don't wait until Sunday morning to have a backup plan. If your star receiver is "Questionable" for a late afternoon game, you must have a pivot from the late games or the Monday night game ready to go. Don't get locked into a 0 because your guy was a late scratch and your bench played at 1:00 PM.
Trust the guys who got you here. Don't get cute. If you’ve started a player for 14 weeks and he’s produced, don't bench him for a waiver wire darling just because the matchup looks "green" on your app. Matchup colors are based on season-long averages, but teams change. A defense that was bad in Week 4 might be elite in Week 15 because they got their star pass rusher back from injury.
Focus on the "High-Value Touches." This means carries inside the 10-yard line and targets in the red zone. A 20-yard catch in the middle of the field is 3 points in PPR. A 2-yard touchdown catch is 7.2 points. Prioritize the players who get the ball when the team is close to the end zone.
Verify the weather one hour before kickoff. If the wind is howling, move your kickers and deep-threat receivers out of your lineup. Kickers are especially sensitive to wind; a 15-point performance can quickly become a 0 if the coach decides to go for it on 4th down because he doesn't trust the field goal unit in the gusts.
✨ Don't miss: The Next Game for Houston Texans: Can C.J. Stroud Handle the Divisional Round Pressure?
Stop looking at "Projected Points." Those numbers are just guesses made by an algorithm. They don't know that a player’s offensive line is missing two starters or that a coach is on the hot seat and might be playing more conservatively. Trust your eyes and the volume data. If you do that, you'll be in a much better position to move on to Week 16.
Keep your roster flexible and don't be afraid to drop your backup quarterback or a second tight end to stash a defense that has a great matchup next week. You’re playing for the trophy now, not for roster depth. Every move should be calculated to maximize your points for this specific week while blocking your opponent from making a move that could hurt you.
Analyze the snap counts from Week 14. If a player’s snaps plummeted, that’s a red flag. If they spiked, even without a huge stat line, that’s a "buy low" opportunity for your starting lineup. Volume eventually leads to production. In the playoffs, we bet on the volume and let the touchdowns fall where they may. Good luck. You're going to need it, but you're also going to be prepared.