Look, we've all been there. You stare at your roster on a Tuesday night, convinced you’ve finally cracked the code, only to realize by Sunday afternoon that your "lock of the week" just put up a literal zero. Week 4 is usually when the wheels start to wobble. We’re officially out of the "small sample size" excuse phase. By now, we know who the target monsters are, which offensive lines are actually turnstiles, and which coaches were lying through their teeth during training camp.
Honestly, the biggest mistake people make with week 4 nfl fantasy rankings is chasing last week’s box score like a dog chasing a mail truck. It’s tempting. But if you're ranking players based on what they did in Week 3 without looking at the defensive shell they faced, you’re basically begging for a loss.
The Quarterback Tier: Josh Allen is the Sun
If you have Josh Allen, you start him. Period. The man is currently the QB1 for a reason. Heading into a matchup against the New Orleans Saints, the projections are screaming A+ across the board. The Saints' defense isn't a total pushover, but they just don't have the lateral speed to keep Allen from turning a broken play into a 20-yard scramble for a score.
Why Lamar Jackson is Tricky This Week
Then there's Lamar. Ranking Lamar Jackson at QB2 feels safe, but the matchup against Kansas City at Arrowhead is a different beast. We saw him struggle with a hamstring tweak late in the game, and while he’s expected to play, his mobility is the engine of his fantasy value. If he's even 10% slower, that massive ceiling starts to look a lot more like a floor.
On the flip side, keep an eye on Drake Maye. Yeah, you heard me. The kid in New England is actually putting up numbers. He’s currently the QB8 and gets a Carolina Panthers defense that—let’s be real—does not travel well. Experts like Sloan Piva are calling him a top-five play this week. If you're in a pinch because Jayden Daniels is out with that knee issue, Maye is your guy.
Running Back Chaos: The Injury Bug Bites Hard
If your backfield feels like a MASH unit, you aren't alone. We lost James Conner and Najee Harris for the year. That's brutal. It shifts the entire landscape of week 4 nfl fantasy rankings because suddenly, guys like Omarion Hampton and Cam Skattebo are must-starts.
Hampton is particularly interesting against the Giants. With Harris down, the Chargers are going to lean on the rookie. The Giants' run defense is... well, it's the Giants. They give up chunk plays like they're handing out candy.
- James Cook (BUF): Top-tier volume against New Orleans.
- Kyren Williams (LAR): Facing an Indy defense that is bleeding points.
- Ollie Gordon (MIA): The rookie "spark" everyone is talking about for Monday Night against the Jets.
Gordon is a polarizing one. Some analysts have him down at RB38, but the Jets actually gave up a decent amount of yardage to Tampa's backs. With the Dolphins' offense in a bit of a funk, they need a home run hitter. Gordon has the "juice."
Wide Receivers: The CeeDee Lamb Vacuum
The biggest shocker hitting the wire is CeeDee Lamb being out for 2-4 weeks with that high ankle sprain. It’s a disaster for Dallas, but a goldmine for fantasy managers looking for volume.
Enter Jalen Tolbert and KaVontae Turpin.
Tolbert saw six targets last week and nearly hit the 100-yard mark. Against a Green Bay secondary that honestly looks a little lost at times, Tolbert is a legitimate WR3/Flex play. Don't overlook Dontayvion Wicks on the other side, either. He leads the Packers in target per route run rate. In a projected shootout at AT&T Stadium, Wicks is a sneaky way to get exposure to that game without paying the premium for Malik Nabers (who, tragically, is feared to have a torn ACL).
🔗 Read more: When Did Argentina Win the World Cup 2022: What Really Happened at Lusail Stadium
The "Must-Starts" That Might Scare You
- Quentin Johnston (LAC): He's moved past "sleeper" status. He's a WR2. Stop doubting it.
- Jaxon Smith-Njigba (SEA): Leading the league in receiving yards isn't a fluke.
- Puka Nacua (LAR): The matchup against the Colts is a dream. He's the WR1 overall this week in many models.
Tight Ends: Finding Water in a Desert
Tight end has been a wasteland this year. If you didn't draft one of the top three, you’re basically throwing darts at a board while blindfolded.
However, Jake Ferguson is the "X-factor" this week. With Lamb out, Dak Prescott is going to look for his security blanket. Last week, Ferguson had a 25% target share. Against a Packers defense that allows the sixth-most points to the position, he has a legitimate shot at being the TE1 overall for Week 4.
On the sleeper side, keep an eye on Hunter Henry. He’s developed a real rapport with Drake Maye. The Panthers can't cover the middle of the field to save their lives. If you're tired of getting 3 points from your TE, Henry is a safe bet for a decent floor.
💡 You might also like: Why the Champions League Final 2013 Was the Purest Game of the Modern Era
The Truth About the "Experts"
Don't blindly follow every ranking list you see. Some models are still "fading" guys like Jerry Jeudy despite his volume, mostly because they don't trust Joe Flacco's age. But Flacco is still slinging it.
The reality of week 4 nfl fantasy rankings is that context matters more than raw stats. Are the Ravens' defensive injuries (like Roquan Smith's hamstring) going to let Patrick Mahomes carve them up? Probably. Is Matthew Stafford going to throw for 400 yards against Indy? He’s the passing leader for a reason, so it's a safe bet.
Actionable Next Steps for Your Roster
- Check the Saturday Wire: With so many "Questionable" tags (Davante Adams, Jauan Jennings, Chris Godwin), you need to have a backup plan ready for those late-afternoon starts.
- Target the Dallas/Green Bay Shootout: Both defenses are struggling. This game has the highest over/under for a reason. Start your pieces here.
- Monitor the Concussion Protocol: If Justin Fields clears for the Jets/Dolphins game, his rushing upside makes him a top-12 play. If not, pivot to a streamer like Geno Smith.
- Trust the Volume: In Week 4, don't get cute. Play the guys getting 8+ targets or 15+ carries, regardless of the "name value" of the guy on your bench.