Fantasy football is basically just a high-stakes game of guessing who is going to get hit with the "injury bug" next. Honestly, if you told me back in August that by October we’d be starting Quentin Johnston as a legitimate WR1, I’d have probably asked for a hit of whatever you were smoking. But here we are. Week 5 is officially "Chaos Week." Between the heavy-hitters like CeeDee Lamb and Tyreek Hill being sidelined or limited, and the first wave of bye weeks—Atlanta, Chicago, Green Bay, and Pittsburgh are all off—your roster likely looks like a medical ward.
Let’s get real. Rankings are only as good as the volume behind them. In PPR, we don't care about "toughness" or "blocking." We care about targets. If a guy is seeing a 35% target share, he’s a gold mine, even if he’s playing for a team that hasn't won a game since the Bush administration.
👉 See also: Why the Paris Opening Ceremony Olympics 2024 Still Sparks Such Heated Debate
The Elite Tier: Puka, Amon-Ra, and the "New" Normal
It’s Puka’s world. We’re just living in it. Puka Nacua isn't just a flash in the pan anymore; he’s the undisputed king of the Week 5 wide receiver rankings PPR. He’s averaging over 20 points per game, and with Davante Adams now in that Rams offense, the spacing is just... chef's kiss. People thought Adams would steal the show, but he’s actually just pulling the safeties away so Puka can feast on those intermediate routes.
Then there’s Amon-Ra St. Brown. The Sun God is heading into a shootout against Cincinnati. Honestly, he’s the safest floor in fantasy. You lock him in, you get 8 catches and 80 yards, and you sleep like a baby.
Top 10 Week 5 Rankings (PPR)
- Puka Nacua (vs. SF) - Target monster.
- Amon-Ra St. Brown (@ CIN) - Consistent as a Swiss watch.
- Justin Jefferson (@ CLE) - Even with Carson Wentz's shaky shoulder, you don't bench JJ.
- Jaxon Smith-Njigba (vs. TB) - Finally the alpha in Seattle.
- Garrett Wilson (vs. DAL) - No Davante means more Justin Fields-to-Wilson connections.
- Nico Collins (@ BAL) - The Ravens secondary is a pass funnel.
- Ja’Marr Chase (vs. DET) - High ceiling, but Detroit’s corners are playing out of their minds.
- Emeka Egbuka (@ SEA) - With Mike Evans out, the rookie is the focal point.
- George Pickens (@ NYJ) - Sauce Gardner is a problem, but Dak has no other choice.
- Quentin Johnston (vs. WAS) - I can't believe I'm writing this either.
Why Quentin Johnston Isn't a Fluke
Look, I get it. We spent all of last year making fun of QJ’s hands. But the Chargers' offense under Jim Harbaugh has somehow turned him into a volume-based WR1. He leads the team in target share and end zone looks. Against a Washington Commanders secondary that allows the ninth-most yards to receivers, he’s a must-start. Keenan Allen is still there, sure, but Johnston is the guy Nix—I mean, Herbert—is looking for when the play breaks down.
Actually, it's worth noting that the Chargers are playing the Commanders, and Washington has been getting torched on deep balls. If you have Johnston, you’re playing him. Period.
The Injury Landmines: Xavier Worthy and A.J. Brown
This is where things get dicey. Xavier Worthy is dealing with a shoulder and an ankle. He’s "expected" to play Monday night against Jacksonville, but "expected" is a scary word for fantasy managers. If he’s out, Marquise Brown becomes a sneaky play, but the floor is subterranean.
Then there’s A.J. Brown. He’s frustrated. We’re frustrated. He had a 38% target share last week but barely any production to show for it. He’s facing Patrick Surtain II this week. Surtain is a "shutdown" corner in the truest sense—he's held almost every WR1 he's faced to under 30 yards. Brown is still a WR2 because of the volume, but don't expect a 30-point explosion.
The Slot Funnel Strategy
If you’re struggling for a flex play, look at the Indianapolis Colts matchup. They are allowing a ridiculous +4.8 schedule-adjusted FPG to slot receivers. This makes Jakobi Meyers and even Tre Tucker incredibly attractive for the Raiders. The Colts' secondary is basically a rotating door at this point, especially with Xavien Howard retiring mid-season (wild, right?).
Deep Sleepers and "Oh No, I'm Desperate" Picks
If you’re staring at your lineup and seeing names like Wan’Dale Robinson or Darius Slayton, don't panic. Robinson is a PPR scammer’s dream. He’ll catch 7 balls for 42 yards, and in full PPR, that’s 11.2 points before he even gains a yard. That’s a usable floor.
Tetairoa McMillan is another one. The Panthers rookie is pacing for over 1,100 yards. The catch rate is ugly (around 51%), but 8 targets a game is 8 targets a game. Against Miami, he’s a high-upside WR3.
Players to Sit (If You Can)
- Calvin Ridley: He’s banged up (knee/elbow) and the Titans' offense is... well, it's a work in progress.
- DeVonta Smith: He’s dropped to WR40-ish territory in actual PPR production.
- Chris Olave: The Giants secondary is actually decent against the slot where Olave has been drifting lately.
What Most People Get Wrong About Matchups
Fantasy "experts" love to look at "Red vs. Green" matchup charts. Forget that. Look at the Shadow Alerts. When a guy like Quinyon Mitchell (reigning Defensive Player of the Week) is shadowing, it changes everything. He just shut down Davante Adams. If he shadows Courtland Sutton this week, Sutton’s floor falls out from under him.
The same goes for Sauce Gardner and George Pickens. Pickens runs over 90% of his routes from the perimeter. Sauce is going to be in his jersey all day. That makes Jake Ferguson (TE) or even Jalen Tolbert more likely to see the volume.
Practical Steps for Your Week 5 Lineup
First, check the Saturday injury reports. If Xavier Worthy is downgraded, you need a backup plan for Monday night. Grab JuJu Smith-Schuster if he's on your wire—it's gross, but he'll get the snaps.
Second, don't overthink the "name" value. If a guy is a perennial All-Pro but is averaging 4 targets a game in a run-heavy offense, he’s a bench candidate. Volume is king in October.
📖 Related: Coolest NFL Jerseys of All Time: What Most People Get Wrong
Finally, watch the weather in Buffalo. The Patriots and Bills game could be a windy one. If it is, Stefon Diggs might see fewer deep shots and more short-area targets, which actually helps his PPR value but kills his ceiling.
To stay ahead of the curve, I recommend checking the "active/inactive" lists exactly 90 minutes before the 1:00 PM EST kickoff. If you see a surprise inactive in a high-total game like Detroit vs. Cincinnati, pivot immediately to the "next man up" (looking at you, Jameson Williams).
Good luck. You're gonna need it.