Fear is a weird thing. It starts as a whisper in a group chat or a red flickering digit on a CNBC ticker, and then, suddenly, it's a goddamn avalanche. Most people think they know what happens in a stock market crash, but the reality is much more chaotic than just "prices go down." It is a systemic seizure.
It's 9:30 AM. The opening bell rings at the New York Stock Exchange. But instead of the usual hum of commerce, there is a vacuum. Buyers have simply vanished. This is where the panic truly starts—not when people sell, but when they can't find anyone to buy.
The Liquidity Black Hole
When we talk about a crash, we’re usually looking at a drop of 20% or more from recent highs, often happening in a terrifyingly short window. Think of the 1987 "Black Monday" where the Dow shed over 22% in a single day. Or the 2020 COVID-19 crash.
Basically, the "bid-ask spread" blows out. Under normal conditions, you can sell a share of Apple or Microsoft almost instantly because there’s a narrow gap between what sellers want and what buyers offer. During a crash, that gap becomes a canyon. You might want to sell at $150, but the highest bidder is sitting at $120. If you’re a forced seller—maybe you’re on margin—you take the $120.
That’s how prices lurch downward in violent, jagged steps.
Market makers, the folks who are supposed to keep things orderly, often step back. They don't want to catch a falling knife. Who would? When the professionals stop providing liquidity, the retail investor gets absolutely hammered. It feels like the floor has dropped out of the world.
The Margin Call Cascade
Here is the secret engine of a crash: debt.
Many big players use "margin," which is essentially gambling with borrowed money. If the value of their stocks drops too far, the broker demands more cash to cover the loan. If the investor doesn't have the cash? The broker sells their stocks automatically. They don't care about the price. They don't care about the long-term "fundamentals" of the company. They just hit the 'sell' button to get their money back.
This creates a feedback loop.
- Prices drop.
- Margin calls are triggered.
- Forced selling happens.
- Prices drop further because of the forced selling.
- More margin calls happen.
It’s a circular firing squad. This is exactly what we saw during the 2008 Great Financial Crisis with firms like Lehman Brothers. It wasn't just that the assets were bad; it was that they had to sell them at any price to stay alive, which pushed prices down for everyone else.
💡 You might also like: I'm Stuck Where the Trade Left Me: Dealing with the Brutal Reality of Bad Market Timing
Circuit Breakers: The Forced Timeout
The NYSE and Nasdaq have "circuit breakers." They are essentially the "chill out" buttons of the financial world.
If the S&P 500 drops 7%, trading stops for 15 minutes. It’s supposed to give people time to breathe, check their math, and maybe realize the world isn't actually ending. If it hits 13%, it stops again. If it hits 20%? Pack it up. The market closes for the day.
Honestly, these are a mixed bag. Some experts, like those at the Wharton School, argue that these pauses actually accelerate fear because traders scramble to sell everything they can before the halt hits. It’s like a stampede toward a closing door.
The Psychological Toll and the "Wealth Effect"
It’s easy to look at a chart and see lines. It’s harder to see the person sitting at their kitchen table watching their 401(k) lose ten years of growth in ten days.
This is where the "Wealth Effect" kicks in, but in reverse. When people see their brokerage accounts bleeding, they stop spending. They cancel the vacation. They don't buy the new car. Because consumer spending drives about 70% of the U.S. economy, the stock market crash eventually leaks into the "real" economy.
Businesses see sales slow down. They freeze hiring. Then come the layoffs.
This is why the Federal Reserve usually loses its mind during a crash. They start slashing interest rates and pumping "quantitative easing" (basically electronic money printing) into the system. They are trying to stop the financial heart attack from becoming a full-body organ failure. Ben Bernanke, who led the Fed during 2008, was a scholar of the Great Depression. He knew that if the banking system freezes during a crash, you aren't just looking at lower stock prices—you're looking at a decade of bread lines.
Why Some Things Don't Crash
Not everything dies.
In a true "dash for cash," almost everything gets sold—even gold, sometimes, because people need the liquidity to cover losses elsewhere. But usually, "defensive" sectors like utilities or consumer staples (think toilet paper and canned soup) hold up better. You might stop buying iPhones, but you aren't going to stop flushing the toilet or eating.
The 2000 Dot-com bubble was a great example of this. Pets.com went to zero, but boring companies that actually made things stayed relatively stable. The crash was a pruning of the weeds. A very, very painful pruning.
The "Dead Cat Bounce"
Be careful of the "Dead Cat Bounce." It’s a grim name for a grim phenomenon.
Even a falling market will have days where it shoots up 5% or 10%. People think, "Aha! The bottom is in!" They buy back in. Then, the selling resumes and the market hits new lows. It’s called a dead cat bounce because "even a dead cat will bounce if it falls from a great enough height."
🔗 Read more: SO Stock Price Today: Why Southern Company is Moving Right Now
Real bottoms usually aren't V-shaped. They are often "U-shaped" or even a "W," where the market tests the lows multiple times until everyone who wanted to sell is finally gone. This is known as "capitulation." It’s the moment when the last bull throws in the towel and says, "I don't care anymore, just get me out."
Paradoxically, that's usually the best time to buy.
Practical Steps for the Aftermath
If you find yourself in the middle of a crash, the worst thing you can do is make a decision based on the 2:00 PM news cycle.
First, check your cash reserves. A market crash is only a disaster if you are forced to sell. If you have enough cash to cover your rent or mortgage for six months, you can afford to wait for a recovery. The S&P 500 has a 100% success rate of recovering from crashes—eventually.
Second, stop looking at the daily P&L. High-frequency monitoring increases the urge to "do something." In a crash, "doing something" is usually just a way to lock in losses.
Third, rebalance—if you can stomach it. This sounds insane, but if your target was 60% stocks and 40% bonds, a crash will leave you with maybe 40% stocks and 60% bonds. To get back to your plan, you actually have to sell the "safe" bonds and buy the "scary" stocks. This is how legendary investors like Warren Buffett make their fortunes. They are "greedy when others are fearful."
💡 You might also like: Joe and Clara Tsai: What Most People Get Wrong About the Brooklyn Nets Billionaires
Finally, evaluate your risk tolerance. If the current drop is keeping you awake at night, you were over-leveraged or over-exposed to begin with. Use the next period of calm to adjust your portfolio so you aren't paralyzed the next time the sky falls.
The market isn't a retail store; it's the only place where the customers run out of the building when there’s a massive sale. Understanding what happens in a stock market crash won't make the red numbers hurt any less, but it might keep you from making the one mistake that turns a temporary setback into a permanent loss of wealth.