Hollywood drama is usually just a lot of smoke and mirrors. A few cryptic Instagram unfollows, a "source close to the production" whispering to a tabloid, and then everyone moves on to the next red carpet. But the situation between Blake Lively and Justin Baldoni is different. It’s messy. It’s litigious. And frankly, it’s kinda sad considering the movie they made together, It Ends With Us, was supposed to be about breaking cycles of abuse.
Instead, the cycles just moved from the script to the courtroom.
If you’ve been following this since the summer of 2024, you know it started with a vibe check that failed miserably. Why was Justin Baldoni doing interviews alone? Why did the rest of the cast look like they were in a different zip code at the New York premiere? Honestly, it looked like a high school clique situation, but with millions of dollars and a #1 box office hit on the line.
The Breaking Point: From "Creative Differences" to Lawsuits
For months, everyone speculated. Was it because Ryan Reynolds (Blake’s husband) rewrote the rooftop scene without telling Justin? Was it because Blake brought in her own editor to cut a version of the film that Justin, the actual director, didn't want?
💡 You might also like: Margaret Kelly and Bill Murray: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
Those were the early theories. They were the "light" version of the story.
By late 2024 and heading into 2026, the gloves came off entirely. Blake Lively filed a massive lawsuit against Baldoni and his production company, Wayfarer Studios. This wasn't just about who got to pick the music for the trailer. She alleged a "hostile work environment" and accused him of sexual harassment. Specifically, the filings mention inappropriate comments on set and Baldoni allegedly showing unwanted pornographic images to staff.
The "Trap" and the Unsealed Texts
Just recently, in January 2026, we got a look at the other side. Newly unsealed text messages from December 2023 show Justin Baldoni texting his agent that he felt Blake was "setting me up for a trap."
He was stressed. Really stressed.
According to these texts, the friction peaked during the filming of intimate scenes. Baldoni claimed Blake "refused" to use a body double for sex scenes, but then insisted he use one. He told his agent it was a "gigantic clusterf---" and that he was giving in to 95% of her demands just to keep the peace.
It's a classic case of he-said, she-said, but with receipts. Baldoni’s legal team argues that the harassment claims are a "salacious" attempt by Lively to repair her reputation after the public turned on her during the press tour. You might remember that—people were pretty annoyed that she was promoting her hair care line, Blake Brown, and telling fans to "wear your florals" for a movie about domestic violence.
Why the Trial is the Only Way Out
The court of public opinion has been split for over a year. Some people see Justin as a director who was bullied off his own project by a powerful Hollywood couple. Others see Blake as a producer who was trying to protect herself and other women from a "problematic" boss.
Here is what we actually know:
- The $400 Million Countersuit: Baldoni didn't just sit back. He sued Blake, Ryan Reynolds, and their publicist for defamation and extortion. However, as of late 2025, a judge dismissed large parts of his countersuit, though the legal maneuvering is far from over.
- Colleen Hoover’s Position: The author of the book has been caught in the middle. She’s been deposed. She’s called the whole thing "sad" and "ugly." In private texts that leaked, she reportedly said she felt "forced to choose" between the two stars.
- The May 2026 Trial: Mark your calendars, because this isn't going away quietly. The trial was originally set for March 2026 but got pushed to May.
It’s rare to see A-list stars take it this far. Usually, there’s a quiet settlement and a joint statement about "mutual respect." Not here. They seem to genuinely dislike each other.
The Ryan Reynolds Factor
You can't talk about Blake Lively and Justin Baldoni without mentioning Ryan Reynolds. Justin’s team has leaned heavily into the idea that Ryan used his massive industry clout to "usurp" the film. There were even rumors that a character in Deadpool & Wolverine was a parody of Baldoni.
Whether that’s true or just Hollywood gossip, the involvement of "Deadpool" turned a movie set conflict into a full-scale industry war. It wasn't just a lead actress vs. a director; it was two production houses—Wayfarer vs. Ryan’s Maximum Effort—battling for the soul of the project.
What Most People Get Wrong
People love to pick a side. They’re either #TeamBlake or #TeamJustin. But the reality is probably more nuanced and, frankly, more boringly corporate. It sounds like a production that lacked clear boundaries from the start. When you have a lead actress who is also a producer and a husband who is a powerhouse filmmaker, the lines of authority get blurry fast.
If Justin felt his authority as director was being undermined, and Blake felt her safety or creative vision was being ignored, you have a recipe for the disaster we’re seeing now.
Moving Forward: Actionable Insights for the "It Ends With Us" Fallout
If you're following this and wondering what to make of it all, here are a few ways to keep the facts straight as we head toward the trial:
- Ignore the TikTok "Body Language" Experts: Most of the viral videos analyze three-second clips from the 2024 press tour. They’re fun, but they aren't evidence. Focus on the unsealed court documents—that's where the real story is.
- Watch the Subpoenas: The fact that people like Taylor Swift’s attorney and various PR executives have been pulled into the discovery process shows how wide this net is being cast.
- Wait for May 2026: Unless a massive settlement happens behind closed doors in the next few months, the testimony in May is going to be the first time we hear the "real" truth under oath.
Basically, the drama surrounding Blake Lively and Justin Baldoni has officially lasted longer than the actual production of the movie. It's a cautionary tale for Hollywood: sometimes a box office win isn't worth the legal bill.
Keep an eye on the Southern District of New York court filings. That’s where the next chapter of this mess will be written.