It feels like just yesterday we were all watching that Taylor Swift cover blow up the internet. You know the one. Brian Burkheiser and the rest of I Prevail basically hacked the music industry overnight with "Blank Space," turning a pop anthem into a metalcore staple. But fast forward a decade, and the news finally hit in May 2025: Brian and the band have officially called it quits.
It was a shock, but then again, maybe it wasn't.
If you’ve been following the subreddits or catching the live clips from the last year, you probably noticed the stage looked a little emptier. Brian had been sitting out shows for a while. The official word was "mutual," the kind of diplomatic language bands use when things get complicated. But when you dig into the timeline, the story of Brian Burkheiser and I Prevail is way more than just a typical lineup change. It’s a mix of a rare medical nightmare, communication breakdowns, and the high-pressure cooker of the touring life.
The Eagle Syndrome Battle
Let’s talk about the health stuff first because it’s honestly terrifying. For years, Brian was dealing with something called Eagle Syndrome. Most people have never heard of it. Basically, it’s this rare condition where a bone or ligament in your neck gets elongated or calcified and starts poking things it shouldn’t. Imagine a literal bone shard pressing against your throat and nerves every time you swallow or sing.
Brian eventually found out he had it on both sides.
👉 See also: Cast of Black November: Why This Massive Nollywood-Hollywood Mashup Still Feels Surreal
He went under the knife with Dr. Ryan Osborne in Los Angeles, a specialist who has worked with a lot of high-profile singers. It wasn't just about "fixing his voice." The pain was so intense it was breaking him mentally. He’s been super open about the "mental taxation" of performing while feeling like your neck is on fire. By the summer of 2024, he was back on the road, and by all accounts, the surgery was a success. His health was actually looking up right before the split happened.
Why the Split Felt Different
Usually, when a founding member leaves, there’s a long goodbye tour or a massive tribute post. With Brian Burkheiser, it felt a bit more abrupt. After the May 2025 announcement, the band’s socials went through a bit of a rebrand. Eric Vanlerberghe, the guy who usually handles the brutal screams, stepped up to cover the clean vocals too. He’s doing a killer job, honestly, but it changes the DNA of the band.
Brian didn't stay silent for long.
In June 2025, he posted a series of Instagram Stories that painted a much rawer picture than the "mutual" press release. He talked about "communication issues" and a "falling out." He wasn't throwing shade at the guys as people—he actually went out of his way to say they are good people—but he admitted he didn't deserve how things went down. It sounds like a classic case of a decade-long relationship just fraying at the edges until it snaps.
The Current State of Play
- I Prevail is currently pushing forward with their "Violent Nature" era.
- Eric Vanlerberghe is now the primary powerhouse upfront, with guitarist Dylan Bowman helping out on cleans.
- The band has a massive 2026 schedule, including the "Alienation Tour" with Three Days Grace and a huge European run.
- Brian Burkheiser is working on solo material, though it hasn't been a smooth transition.
There’s been some legal drama, too. Brian mentioned on social media that he was being "blocked" from releasing new music, specifically a track called "Phases." It’s the kind of messy business stuff that happens when contracts and songwriting rights get tangled up after a breakup. Fans are still waiting to see if he can clear those hurdles and drop his new project.
What Most People Get Wrong
A lot of fans assumed Brian left because he couldn't sing anymore. That’s just not true. Reports from people close to his recovery confirmed he was 100% physically capable of performing. The split was about the dynamic, not the diaphragm.
Ten years is a long time to spend on a bus with the same people. Brian has talked before about being an introvert in an extroverted industry. When you combine that personality type with chronic pain and the stress of a massive global brand, it’s a miracle the original lineup lasted as long as it did.
Honestly, it’s kinda sad to see the "Hurricane" era end like this. That song was such a massive moment for them, capturing the struggle they went through earlier in their career. Now, they’re navigating a different kind of storm. I Prevail is proving they can still draw massive crowds without their founding clean vocalist, but the fans who grew up on Lifelines and Trauma are definitely feeling the void.
What Happens Now?
If you're a fan of Brian Burkheiser and I Prevail, you've basically got two camps to follow now. I Prevail isn't slowing down; they’ve already released new tracks like "Into Hell" and "Rain" that lean into this heavier, singular-frontman vibe. They’re still a juggernaut in the metalcore scene.
As for Brian, he’s in a rebuilding phase. He’s teased a project that’s more "vulnerable" and "truthful" to where he is now. Whether he stays in the rock world or pivots to something else remains to be seen. One thing is certain: he’s not done with music. He’s just doing it on his own terms for the first time in ten years.
Actionable Insights for Fans:
- Follow Brian's Socials: His Instagram is where the real updates happen regarding his solo music and the "Phases" release.
- Check the 2026 Tour: If you want to see how the new vocal dynamic works, I Prevail is hitting major arenas in early 2026.
- Listen to the Lyrics: The "Violent Nature" tracks from I Prevail and Brian's upcoming solo work will likely give more insight into the split than any interview ever could.