James Butler Hickok was basically a walking ghost by the time he rolled into Deadwood in 1876. Most people know him as "Wild Bill," the gunslinger with the long hair and the ivory-handled Colts, but the man who sat down at a poker table on August 2nd wasn't the invincible lawman of legend. He was thirty-nine, his eyes were failing from glaucoma, and honestly, he was looking for a way to strike it rich in the Black Hills gold rush so he could support his new bride.
He didn't find gold. He found a bullet.
The Day the Music Stopped at Saloon No. 10
The specific details of how did wild bill hickok die are actually pretty gritty when you strip away the Hollywood polish. It happened at Nuttal & Mann’s Saloon No. 10. It wasn't a grand showdown in the middle of the street. There was no "draw on three." It was a cowardly move by a man named Jack McCall, a guy who had lost his shirt to Hickok in a game the day before.
Hickok had a rule. He always sat with his back to the wall. He was a man who had made a lot of enemies in places like Abilene and Hays City, and he wasn't stupid. But on that Wednesday afternoon, the only seat available at the poker table forced him to face away from the door. He asked another player, Charles Rich, to switch seats with him. Twice.
Rich said no.
That refusal changed history.
About 4:15 PM, McCall—who had been nursing a grudge and probably too much rotgut whiskey—walked through the door. He didn't say a word at first. He just moved behind Hickok, pulled a .45-caliber Colt revolver, and shouted, "Damn you! Take that!"
The bullet hit Bill in the back of the head, killed him instantly, and actually passed through his cheek before hitting another player, Captain Massie, in the wrist. Hickok didn't even have time to reach for his guns. He just slumped forward onto the table.
💡 You might also like: Buy Despicable Me 4: What Most People Get Wrong About the Best Deals
Breaking Down the Dead Man’s Hand
You can’t talk about how did wild bill hickok die without mentioning those cards. It’s the most famous hand in poker history, but there’s actually some debate among historians about what was really in his grip.
The legend says he was holding two pair: black aces and black eights (the Ace of Spades, Ace of Clubs, Eight of Spades, and Eight of Clubs). This is what every tourist in Deadwood hears today. But here is the thing: nobody actually recorded the cards at the scene. The first time the "Aces and Eights" story really gained traction was in a biography written by Frank Wilstach in 1926—nearly fifty years after the shooting.
And that fifth card?
- Some say it was the Queen of Hearts (with a drop of Bill's blood on it).
- Others swear it was the Jack of Diamonds.
- A few historians think he hadn't even drawn his fifth card yet.
Basically, the "Dead Man's Hand" is part history and part marketing, but it’s a story that stuck. If you're playing poker today and you pull those cards, you’re going to feel a little chill. That’s the power of the Hickok legend.
Why Did Jack McCall Do It?
McCall’s motives were sorta all over the place. At his first trial—which was a "miner's court" held in a local theater—he claimed Hickok had killed his brother back in Kansas. The jury, made up of miners who didn't much care for lawmen anyway, actually found him not guilty.
It was a farce.
The "brother" story turned out to be a lie. McCall eventually left town and started bragging about the kill in Wyoming. You’ve gotta be pretty bold (or pretty dumb) to brag about murdering a legend in a territory that actually has a real court system. He was arrested again, and since the first trial wasn't "legal" (Deadwood was on Indian land at the time and lacked formal jurisdiction), double jeopardy didn't apply.
They hauled him to Yankton, found him guilty in a real courtroom, and hanged him on March 1, 1877. Interestingly, when they moved his body later, they found he was buried with the noose still around his neck.
Living With the Legacy
If you visit Deadwood today, you can see exactly where this happened, though the original saloon burned down long ago. You can walk up to Mount Moriah Cemetery and see Hickok's grave. He’s buried right next to Calamity Jane—a woman who claimed they were a couple, though most historians think she was just a superfan who followed him around.
Understanding how did wild bill hickok die isn't just about a murder; it’s about the end of an era. The Wild West was becoming "civilized." The days of the lone gunfighter were fading. When McCall pulled that trigger, he didn't just kill a man; he turned a tired, aging gambler into an immortal icon.
What to do if you're a history buff:
If this story fascinates you, the best way to get the "real" feel of it is to visit the Adams Museum in Deadwood. They have artifacts that bring the 1870s to life in a way a textbook never can. Also, if you’re a poker player, maybe just... keep your back to the wall. It’s good practice.
You should check out the archives of the South Dakota State Historical Society for the actual trial transcripts of Jack McCall if you want to see how the legal system finally caught up with him. It’s a fascinating read that proves the truth is often stranger than the movies.