If you’ve spent any time looking at the real estate market in the South Coast lately, you know things are getting tight. Rental prices are up, inventory is low, and neighbors are getting a little more vocal about who exactly is staying next door. For a while there, it felt like Fall River was the Wild West for short-term rentals. You could basically throw a mattress in a spare room, snap a few photos, and start collecting checks.
But then the city stepped in. Hard.
The drama surrounding the Fall River Airbnb lawsuit isn't just a legal spat between a few frustrated property owners and City Hall. It’s a microcosm of the fight happening all over Massachusetts—from the Cape to the Berkshires—about who gets to decide what a "residential neighborhood" actually looks like. Honestly, if you're an investor or just someone trying to pay your mortgage by renting out a floor of your multi-family, the current landscape is kinda confusing.
The Crackdown That Sparked the Fire
Basically, the city decided they’d had enough of "ghost hotels." In early 2024, Fall River started enforcing some of the strictest short-term rental (STR) rules in the region. They weren't just asking for a small registration fee. They started telling people that unless they had a specific zoning variance, they couldn't operate in most residential areas.
Predictably, people got mad.
The core of the Fall River Airbnb lawsuit involves property owners who argue that the city's sudden shift in enforcement is unconstitutional—or at the very least, a violation of their "grandfathered" rights. Imagine you bought a triple-decker in 2021 specifically to run it as an Airbnb. You’ve got the $1,000,000 liability insurance the city wants. You’ve got the floor plans. You’ve been paying your taxes. Then, out of nowhere, you get a cease-and-desist letter saying your "business" isn't allowed in a residential zone.
That’s exactly where the legal friction started.
Why the City Thinks They're Right
The city's legal team isn't just being mean for the sake of it. They’re looking at a housing crisis. They argue that every apartment turned into a permanent Airbnb is one less unit for a local family. From their perspective, a short-term rental is a commercial business.
And businesses belong in commercial zones.
They point to cases like Styller v. Lynnfield and more recent rulings in Nantucket where Massachusetts courts have sided with towns. The logic? If your zoning code doesn't explicitly say "short-term rentals are allowed," then they aren't allowed. It’s a "permissive" zoning philosophy. If it’s not on the list of okay things, it’s a no-go.
The "Grandfather" Myth and Other Misconceptions
One of the biggest points of contention in the Fall River Airbnb lawsuit is the idea of "pre-existing non-conforming use." You’ll hear hosts say, "I was doing this before the new ordinance, so they can't stop me."
👉 See also: Cómo está el dólar el día de hoy y por qué tu bolsillo siente el cambio
Well, the courts are increasingly saying: Actually, yes they can.
In Massachusetts, for a use to be grandfathered, it usually has to have been legal when it started. If the city argues that STRs were never legal under the old zoning code because they weren't listed, the "grandfather" argument falls apart. It’s a brutal technicality that has left many local investors holding the bag on properties that no longer cash flow.
What the Lawsuit is Actually Asking For
The plaintiffs in these types of cases are usually looking for a few specific things:
- Injunctive Relief: They want the court to tell Fall River to stop issuing fines while the case is sorted out.
- Clarification on "Accessory Use": They argue that renting out a room or a unit is "incidental" to living there. It’s just a modern version of having a boarder.
- Due Process: Claims that the city didn't give enough notice before changing how they interpret the law.
The Real-World Impact on Fall River Hosts
If you’re currently running an Airbnb in the city, you’re probably looking over your shoulder. The Building and Zoning Department has been active. They aren't just waiting for complaints anymore; they’re cross-referencing active listings with city records.
It’s a mess.
Some owners have tried to pivot to "mid-term rentals"—stays of 31 days or more. Since the Massachusetts state law (Chapter 337 of the Acts of 2018) defines a short-term rental as 31 days or less, staying for 32 days technically moves you into a different legal category. But even that is a grey area if the city decides you’re still running a "lodging house" without a license.
Lessons From Nearby Towns
We’ve seen this movie before. In Nantucket, a recent 2025 ruling by a Land Court judge basically shut down STRs in the historic district unless the owner is living in the house. The Fall River Airbnb lawsuit is watching these precedents closely. If the courts continue to trend toward "local control," the dream of the passive-income Airbnb empire in residential Fall River might be over.
The city wants you to have:
- Annual licensing: Renewed every year, no exceptions.
- Parking plans: You can't just park three cars on the sidewalk.
- Safety inspections: Smoke detectors and exits have to be up to par.
What You Should Do Now
If you're caught in the middle of this or thinking about buying property in Fall River for the purpose of short-term renting, you need to move carefully. This isn't 2018 anymore.
- Check the Zoning Map: Don't take a Realtor's word for it. Go to the city's building department and ask specifically if "transient lodging" is allowed at that address.
- Get a Lawyer Who Knows Land Use: This isn't a standard "slip and fall" case. You need someone who understands Massachusetts Chapter 40A.
- Consider Long-Term Tenants: With the way the Fall River Airbnb lawsuit is trending, having a reliable 12-month lease might be less of a headache than fighting the Zoning Board of Appeals.
The reality is that Fall River is trying to protect its housing stock. Whether they are doing it in a way that is legally sound is what the court will eventually decide. For now, the "gold rush" of unregulated Airbnbs in the city is effectively on ice. Keep your records organized, pay your room occupancy taxes, and maybe wait to see how the next hearing goes before you buy that next property.
Next Steps for Property Owners
First, verify your property’s specific zoning sub-district. You can do this through the Fall River GIS mapping system online. Second, if you receive a violation notice, do not ignore it. The fines can stack up daily, and the city has shown a willingness to take these all the way to Bristol Superior Court. Finally, join a local host advocacy group; there is strength in numbers when it comes to lobbying for a more "middle-ground" ordinance that allows for responsible hosting while addressing the city's valid concerns about housing density and neighborhood character.