It started with a conference call. That sounds boring, right? Most corporate training sessions are. But in May 2018, a specific role-play exercise designed to prevent PR disasters actually created the biggest one in the history of the pizza industry. John Schnatter, the face of the brand he built from a broom closet, used the Papa Johns n word slur during a call with Laundry Service, a marketing agency. He didn't just say it in passing; he used it while trying to explain how he wasn't like Colonel Sanders.
The fallout was instant. Brutal.
Most people think it was just a random outburst, but the context is actually weirder and more complex than a simple soundbite. This wasn't just about a word; it was the final match in a room full of gasoline. The company’s stock plummeted, Schnatter was ousted from his own board, and the "Papa" was scrubbed from the logos. Even the University of Louisville took his name off their football stadium. It was a total corporate meltdown.
The Role-Play Gone Wrong
The setting was a media training session. Schnatter was already in hot water for comments he made about the NFL protests—he'd blamed the league's leadership for "pizza blues" and falling sales because players were kneeling during the national anthem. Laundry Service was supposed to help him avoid future gaffes.
According to reports from Forbes, which broke the story in July 2018, Schnatter was asked how he would distance himself from racist groups online. During his response, he complained that Colonel Sanders had called Black people the n-word and never faced a public backlash. He used the full slur. He also reportedly talked about his upbringing in Indiana, claiming people used to drag Black people behind trucks.
📖 Related: Why Every Hong Kong Electronics Fair Exhibitor Photo Looks the Same (And How to Fix It)
He thought he was being historical or illustrative. The people on the other end of the line? They were horrified.
It’s easy to see why. There is a massive difference between discussing a slur and using it, especially in a professional setting where you are literally being paid to prove you aren't a liability. The agency moved to terminate their contract with Papa John's almost immediately after.
A Legacy Built on a Broom Closet
To understand why this hit so hard, you have to look at what John Schnatter was to that company. He wasn't just a CEO. He was the brand. Since 1984, he had been the guy in the commercials. He sold his 1971 Camaro to buy pizza equipment. That kind of "founder's myth" is powerful.
But it makes the company vulnerable.
When your face is on every box and your name is on every storefront, your personal behavior isn't just a "private matter." It’s the brand's identity. When the Papa Johns n word news broke, the company didn't just lose a leader; they lost their mascot. The board of directors realized they couldn't have a man who used that language—regardless of his intent—as the symbol of a global franchise that employs thousands of diverse workers and serves an even more diverse customer base.
Schnatter resigned as chairman of the board within hours of the report going public.
The Aftermath and the Legal War
The years following 2018 were a mess of lawsuits and counter-claims. Schnatter didn't go quietly. He filed multiple lawsuits against the company and the marketing firm. He claimed he was "set up" and that the comments were taken out of context.
He even launched a website, "Save Papa Johns," to tell his side of the story. In his view, the board used the incident as a "coup" to push him out because of internal power struggles. He hired experts to analyze the tapes. He went on talk shows. He even did a famous interview where he claimed he’d eaten 40 pizzas in 30 days and that a "day of reckoning" was coming.
Honestly, it was surreal to watch.
While he was fighting his legal battles, the company was doing the hard work of "de-Papa-fying." They brought in Shaq—Shaquille O'Neal—to join the board and act as a new brand ambassador. They changed the marketing. They focused on "Better Ingredients. Better Pizza." instead of "Better John." It worked. Sales eventually rebounded, but the stain of the incident remained in the public consciousness.
The Reality of Corporate Culture
What many people miss about this story is that it wasn't an isolated event. Investigatory reports from Forbes suggested a much broader "toxic" culture at the headquarters in Louisville. There were allegations of a "frat-house" atmosphere, inappropriate behavior toward women, and a general lack of professional boundaries.
The use of the Papa Johns n word was the tipping point, but the culture was already leaning toward a cliff.
It serves as a massive case study for modern business. You can't have a culture that revolves entirely around the ego of one person, especially if that person doesn't have the self-awareness to navigate modern social norms. The "founder-led" model has high rewards but catastrophic risks.
👉 See also: Dynamic Aviation Thailand Contingent on Contract: What’s Actually Happening on the Ground
What We Can Learn From the Fallout
- Brand Identity is Fragile: If your brand is tied to a person, that person needs to be beyond reproach, or you need a "Plan B" for when they fail.
- Context Doesn't Always Save You: Schnatter’s defense was that he was quoting someone else or being descriptive. In a corporate environment, that distinction often doesn't matter. The impact outweighs the intent.
- Recovery Requires Radical Change: Papa John's didn't just apologize. They changed their board, their spokesperson, their internal training, and even their logo's font. You have to prove the "old way" is dead.
- The Internet Never Forgets: Every time you search for the brand now, the Papa Johns n word incident is one of the top results. It is a permanent part of their digital footprint.
If you're running a business or managing a brand, take a look at your own "single points of failure." Is there one person whose public image could destroy your bottom line? If so, it’s time to diversify your brand's voice. Don't wait for a crisis to start building a culture that can survive without its founder.
The "day of reckoning" Schnatter promised never really arrived in the way he thought it would. Instead, the world just moved on to a version of Papa Johns that didn't include him. It’s a harsh lesson in how quickly the "face" of a company can become the person they most want to forget.