It was almost midnight on Chappaquiddick Island, a tiny, quiet slice of land off the coast of Martha’s Vineyard. Most of the country was glued to their televisions, waiting for the Apollo 11 moon landing. But on a dirt road leading toward Poucha Pond, things were going sideways for the Kennedy dynasty.
Senator Edward "Ted" Kennedy was behind the wheel of a 1967 Oldsmobile Delmont 88. His passenger was 28-year-old Mary Jo Kopechne, a brilliant political strategist who had worked for his brother Bobby. They had just left a party at a rented cottage. Then, the car went over the side of Dike Bridge.
The car flipped. It landed upside down in the dark, tidal water. Kennedy got out. Mary Jo did not.
The Timeline of the Ted Kennedy Traffic Accident
If you look at the official record, the timeline is where everything starts to feel "off." Kennedy claimed he made a wrong turn. He said he intended to take Mary Jo to the ferry landing so she could get back to her hotel in Edgartown. Instead of staying on the paved Main Road, he turned right onto Dyke Road—a rough, unpaved path that led straight to a bridge with no guardrails.
The math doesn't quite add up for a lot of people.
- 11:15 PM: Kennedy and Kopechne leave the party.
- 11:30 PM - 12:40 AM: The crash occurs. An off-duty deputy later testified he saw a car matching Kennedy’s license plate at 12:40 AM, long after Kennedy said the accident happened.
- The Rescue Attempt: Kennedy said he dove into the water repeatedly to save her but couldn't reach her because of the strong current.
- The Walk Back: He walked back to the cottage, passing several houses with lights on. He didn't knock on any doors.
- The Delay: This is the part that haunts the legacy. Kennedy didn't call the police. He didn't call the fire department. He went back to the party, got his cousin Joe Gargan and friend Paul Markham, and they went back to the bridge to try again. Still, no one called for professional help.
- The Swim: Kennedy eventually swam across the channel back to Edgartown. He went to his hotel, changed his clothes, and even spoke to a hotel guest about a noise complaint around 2:00 AM.
He didn't report the accident until 10:00 AM the next morning. By then, two fishermen had already found the car.
The Question of the Air Pocket
There is a chilling theory about what actually happened inside that Oldsmobile. John Farrar, the diver who recovered Mary Jo’s body, didn't believe she drowned instantly.
When he found her, her head was pressed into the footwell of the backseat. This is exactly where an air pocket would have formed as the car settled. Her hands were gripping the seat. Farrar was convinced she lived for maybe two or three hours, breathing that trapped air until it finally turned into carbon dioxide.
"If I had been called when the accident happened," Farrar later said, "she would be alive today."
The legal fallout was surprisingly light, at least on paper. Kennedy pleaded guilty to leaving the scene of an accident. He got a two-month suspended sentence and a temporary driving ban. That was it. No manslaughter charges. No jail time.
Why Chappaquiddick Still Matters
Honestly, the Ted Kennedy traffic accident didn't just end a life; it changed the trajectory of the U.S. Presidency. Before 1969, Ted was the heir apparent. He was the next Kennedy king.
But the image of the neck-brace-wearing Senator at Mary Jo's funeral felt staged to many. When he gave a televised speech a week later, blaming a "jumble of emotions" like "grief, fear, and panic" for his failure to report the crash, the public's trust took a massive hit. He basically admitted his conduct was "indefensible," yet he remained in the Senate for decades.
You’ve gotta wonder what happens in a world where that bridge had a guardrail. Or a world where he knocks on a door at 12:00 AM.
Misconceptions and Complexities
One big misconception is that the party was a "wild orgy." Most accounts from the "Boiler Room Girls"—the women who worked on RFK's campaign—suggest it was a standard, albeit boozy, cookout. It wasn't a scandal until the car hit the water.
Another point of contention is the autopsy. Or rather, the lack of one. Mary Jo’s parents opposed it, and a judge later denied the request to exhume her body. We will never know for 100% certainty if she drowned or suffocated.
🔗 Read more: Jessica Alba Daughter Honor: What Most People Get Wrong About Raising a Hollywood Mini-Me
Actionable Insights for History Buffs
If you’re looking to dig deeper into the nuances of this case, don't just stick to the headlines.
- Read the Inquest Transcript: The 763-page transcript from the 1970 judicial inquest reveals a lot of contradictions in the testimonies of the party-goers.
- Examine the Bridge Specs: Looking at the old photos of Dike Bridge shows just how dangerous that turn was. It was a 90-degree angle with zero protection.
- Study the 1980 Campaign: Watch Ted Kennedy’s interview with Roger Mudd. It’s a masterclass in how a decade-old scandal can still sink a political career with just one poorly answered question.
The legacy of the accident is a mixture of tragedy and privilege. While Ted Kennedy went on to become the "Lion of the Senate," Mary Jo Kopechne remained a footnote in most history books for years. Today, researchers are finally focusing more on her life as a talented professional rather than just a victim in a Senator's "incident."