You remember the headband. If you watched Lifetime’s The Rap Game back in 2016, it was impossible to miss Tally. She was the skinny white girl from Nashville who walked into a room full of hungry artists and immediately became the focal point of a massive debate about authenticity, privilege, and whether she actually had the "it" factor Jermaine Dupri was looking for.
Most people just call her Tally from Rap Game, but her real name is Taylor McFerrin. She didn't just appear once. She became one of the few contestants to ever get a second chance, appearing in both Season 2 and Season 3. It was a rollercoaster. One week she was at the top of the Hit List, and the next, she was packing her bags because she couldn't remember her lyrics or lacked the "swag" needed to keep up with kids like Mani or Nova.
Honestly, the internet wasn't always kind to her. People either loved her flow or thought she was a "culture vulture" being pushed by the producers for ratings. But what actually happened when the cameras stopped rolling? The music industry is a graveyard of reality TV stars who thought a few episodes on a major network would guarantee a Platinum plaque. Tally’s story is a bit more complicated than that.
The Jermaine Dupri Factor and the Season 3 Drama
Jermaine Dupri is a legend. You don't produce Kris Kross, Usher, and Mariah Carey without knowing how to spot a star. When he first saw Tally, he saw potential. She had a rhythm that felt natural, but she lacked the grit. That’s why her exit in Season 2 felt so abrupt. She was talented, sure, but she wasn't "Atlanta" enough.
Then came the Season 3 return.
That was a huge deal. Usually, once you're cut, you're done. Bringing her back was a polarizing move. The other contestants—kids like Deetranada and King Roscoe—weren't exactly thrilled to see a "veteran" come back to take another shot at the So So Def chain. It created this weird dynamic where Tally was constantly defending her right to be there.
She eventually got cut again. It was brutal to watch. JD basically told her that while she could rap, she didn't have the stage presence to command an audience. That’s a tough pill to swallow when you’re a teenager in front of millions of viewers. But Tally didn't just disappear into a 9-to-5 life. She leaned into the controversy.
✨ Don't miss: Gary Peacock Park City: What Most People Get Wrong About the Jazz Legend’s Utah Ties
Life After Lifetime: The Music and the Rebrand
After the show, Tally from Rap Game had to figure out who Taylor was without the Lifetime editing. She started dropping singles on YouTube and SoundCloud. If you go back and listen to tracks like "Loose Cannon" or her "7 Rings" remix, you can hear a shift. She moved away from the "kid rapper" vibe and started leaning into a more mature, pop-trap sound.
It's a weird transition to make.
When you start on a show for kids and teens, the industry tends to box you in. Tally tried to break out of that box by showcasing a more "Instagram-ready" aesthetic. She grew up. She changed her look. She started focusing heavily on her social media presence, which is where most of the Rap Game alumni ended up finding their actual longevity.
- She amassed hundreds of thousands of followers on Instagram.
- Her YouTube channel became a mix of music videos and "Get Ready With Me" style vlogs.
- She moved to Los Angeles to try and make the "real" music industry happen.
But here is the reality check: the music industry is expensive. Without a major label like So So Def backing you, indie artists have to fund their own videos, studio time, and marketing. Tally was doing it, but the momentum from the show started to fade as newer seasons and newer stars took the spotlight.
The Controversy: Why Tally Was So Polarizing
Let's be real for a second. A lot of the heat Tally took was about race and hip-hop. In a genre built on Black culture, seeing a blonde girl from Nashville get a "second chance" from Jermaine Dupri rubbed people the wrong way. The term "culture vulture" was thrown around a lot in the YouTube comments and on Twitter (now X).
Was it fair?
Technically, Tally was a songwriter. She understood bars. She understood internal rhyme schemes. But she lacked the "struggle" narrative that often defines rap authenticity. She felt like a pop star trying to rap, rather than a rapper who happened to be pop. This distinction is why she struggled to win over the core hip-hop audience that watched the show.
Even her fellow contestants pointed this out. In the "Rap Game" house, the tension wasn't just about who had the best verse; it was about who deserved to be there. Tally often felt like the "producer's choice," which put a target on her back from day one.
💡 You might also like: I See a Dreamer Lyrics: Why CG5's Anthem Defined the Dream SMP Era
Where is Tally Now? (The 2024-2026 Reality)
If you look for her today, you’ll find a woman who has largely stepped away from the "rapper" persona that JD tried to build for her. She still creates, but the focus has shifted. Like many former child stars, the pivot to influencer marketing and lifestyle content was more sustainable than the grind of the rap circuit.
She’s still active on social media, but the "Tally" from 2016 is a ghost. She’s Taylor now. She’s someone who survived the reality TV meat grinder and came out the other side with her sanity, which is more than some of her peers can say.
The most interesting thing about her journey is how it highlights the "Reality TV Trap." Shows like The Rap Game provide a platform, but they don't provide a career. You get the followers, but you don't necessarily get the respect of the industry peers who didn't come up through a televised competition.
Actionable Takeaways for Aspiring Artists
Looking at the trajectory of Tally from Rap Game, there are some very real lessons for anyone trying to make it in the digital age. Success isn't just about getting on a show; it's about what you do when the camera turns off.
1. Control Your Own Narrative
Tally's biggest struggle was being "the girl JD brought back." It made her look dependent on his approval. If you're an artist, build your own brand before you seek out a mentor. That way, if the mentor leaves, the fans stay.
2. Versatility is a Double-Edged Sword
She could rap and sing, but she never quite mastered one. In the beginning, it’s better to be the best at one specific thing than "okay" at three things. Pick your lane and dominate it before you branch out.
3. Authenticity Can't Be Taught
JD kept telling her she lacked "swag." You can't buy that, and you can't rehearse it in a mirror. You have to live the life you're rapping about, or at least have a perspective that feels lived-in. Tally’s Nashville-to-Atlanta jump felt a little too manufactured for some fans.
4. Diversify Your Income Early
The reason Tally is still around is that she understood the power of her image. She transitioned into the influencer space because the music wasn't paying the bills yet. If you have a platform, use it to build a business, not just a discography.
✨ Don't miss: Wait, Is This Real? Everything We Just Saw in the New Real Housewives of Atlanta Preview
The story of Tally isn't a tragedy, and it isn't a "where are they now" cautionary tale. It’s just the reality of the modern entertainment industry. Sometimes, the "Rap Game" is just a stepping stone to finding out who you actually are.
To see what Tally is up to today, your best bet is following her verified Instagram or TikTok. She’s moved past the headband era, focusing more on high-fashion aesthetics and indie-pop leaning tracks. If you're looking for her old battle raps, those are mostly archived on Lifetime's YouTube channel—a time capsule of a girl trying to find her voice in a room full of giants.
Next Steps for Fans and Creators:
Check out the "where are they now" specials often released by former contestants on YouTube. Many of the Season 2 and 3 cast members have done long-form interviews explaining the behind-the-scenes contracts that often hindered their careers after the show ended. Studying these contracts is a must for any young artist considering a reality TV route.