If you’ve driven past a Cracker Barrel lately and thought things looked a little... off, you aren’t alone. Honestly, the porch rockers are still there, but behind the scenes, the "Old Country Store" is fighting for its life.
It’s been a rough ride.
Ever since Julie Felss Masino took over as CEO—coming from places like Taco Bell and Starbucks—the brand has been trying to figure out how to stay relevant without ticking off the people who have eaten there every Sunday for thirty years. It hasn't gone well. In fact, by late 2025, the company found itself in the middle of a full-blown identity crisis that cost them millions in market value and a massive chunk of their foot traffic.
The Logo Disaster and the $700 Million Headache
So, what’s going on with Cracker Barrel right now? Basically, they tried to "modernize," and the internet collectively lost its mind.
In August 2025, the company unveiled a new, simplified logo. Gone was the iconic "Uncle Herschel" character—the old man leaning on a barrel—replaced by a minimalist yellow circle and basic text. The backlash was instant.
Longtime fans called it "soulless." Some even claimed the brand was "going woke" or trying to erase its Southern heritage. It wasn't just mean comments on Facebook, either. After the announcement, restaurant traffic plummeted by 8% almost overnight.
They panicked.
Within weeks, the company scrapped the new logo entirely. They brought Uncle Herschel back. But the damage was done. By the time they hit their first quarter of fiscal 2026, the company reported a massive $24.6 million net loss.
Why Your Local Store Might Look Different (Or Not)
The logo wasn't the only thing they tried to change. They also started remodeling stores to make them "brighter" and "less cluttered."
Think white paint instead of dark wood.
Shadow boxes for antiques instead of stuff hanging everywhere.
For many, it felt like a doctor’s office with a gift shop attached. After testing this "modern farmhouse" look in a handful of locations, the company officially pulled the plug on the program in September 2025. They even promised to transition some of the already-remodeled stores back to their original, darker decor.
If your local spot looks a bit brighter, it might stay that way for a bit, but don't expect the "white-walled" look to spread any further. They've shifted their budget from "modernizing" to "maintenance." This means they're spending money on boring stuff like fixing parking lots, painting (presumably in the old colors), and fixing leaky roofs rather than trying to look like a Pinterest board.
The Maple Street Shutdown
One of the biggest "quiet" pieces of news is what's happening to their sister brand.
Cracker Barrel owns Maple Street Biscuit Company. They bought it back in 2019 for $36 million, hoping it would be their ticket to winning over younger, urban brunch crowds.
It’s become a drag.
In late 2025, the company announced it was shuttering 14 Maple Street locations. They realized they were spreading themselves too thin. CFO Craig Pommells basically admitted that these stores weren't meeting financial expectations, so they’re cutting the dead weight to focus on the core Cracker Barrel brand.
✨ Don't miss: The Real Story Behind Select Roofing Owner and What Homeowners Miss
The Menu: Out with the New, In with the Old
The kitchen has been a battlefield.
For a while, they were pushing "lighter" options and "elevated" dinner items like New York strip steaks. They even tried to "simplify" how the kitchen worked to save money on labor.
It backfired.
Customers complained the food didn't taste the same. Quality dipped. In a desperate move to win back trust, the company recently announced the return of "The Old" to the "Old Country Store."
- Hamburger Steak is back.
- Eggs in the Basket are back.
- Uncle Herschel's Favorite breakfast is front and center.
They've literally retrained thousands of kitchen staff on the "core recipes" because they realized that if the biscuits aren't perfect, nothing else matters.
Is Cracker Barrel Actually Going Out of Business?
Probably not, but they are definitely shrinking.
They expect sales to be lower in 2026 than they were in 2025. That’s not a great sign for a public company. They’re also dealing with $25 million in expected hits from new tariffs and rising wage costs.
To save money, they've laid off staff at their corporate headquarters in Lebanon, Tennessee, and slashed their advertising budget. They’re basically going into "hunker down" mode.
The good news? Their loyalty program is actually working. They’ve got over 10 million members now. These are the "superfans" who are keeping the lights on. If you're one of them, you've probably noticed more "Front Porch Feedback" requests. They are finally—finally—listening to what people actually want instead of what a consultant in a suit thinks they should want.
What You Should Do Next
If you're a fan or an investor, here’s the reality: Cracker Barrel is currently a "fixer-upper" brand.
- Check the menu before you go. They are rotating classics back in, so your old favorite might finally be available again after a long hiatus.
- Use the app. Since they are desperate for traffic, the "Cracker Barrel Rewards" program is currently handing out more perks and "Peg Games" points than usual to keep people coming through the doors.
- Expect a "Back to Basics" vibe. If you visit in 2026, expect fewer experimental dishes and more focus on the stuff that made them famous in 1969.
The era of trying to be "cool" is over for Cracker Barrel. Now, they just want to be themselves again.