You’re sitting on your couch, scrolling through your phone, and you see it. A link promising to tell you which historical world leader matches your vibe. You click. Suddenly, you’re answering questions about whether you prefer a quiet night in or a massive gala, or how you’d handle a hypothetical invasion of a neighboring country. Most of us have taken a which president are you test at some point. It’s a bit of a digital rite of passage.
But honestly, have you ever stopped to wonder why we’re so obsessed with these things? Or why one quiz tells you you're basically Abraham Lincoln's twin, while another insists you’re more of a Richard Nixon?
👉 See also: Welsh Girls Names Like Jane: The Surprising Reason These Classics Are Making a Comeback
It’s not just about killing five minutes during a lunch break. These quizzes sit at this weird, fascinating intersection of history, psychology, and our own desire to see ourselves reflected in the people who shaped the world.
The Psychology Behind the Quiz
Why do we care? Basically, humans are wired for "social comparison." We want to know where we fit in the hierarchy of personality. When you take a which president are you test, you aren't just looking for a name. You're looking for validation of your own traits.
If a quiz says you’re Theodore Roosevelt, you feel bold, adventurous, and maybe a little rugged. If it says you’re James Madison, you’re the "ideas person," the quiet intellectual in the room. It’s a shorthand for explaining who we are to ourselves and others.
Psychologists often look at these through the lens of the "Big Five" personality traits:
- Openness (Are you curious or cautious?)
- Conscientiousness (Are you organized or easy-going?)
- Extraversion (Are you outgoing or reserved?)
- Agreeableness (Are you compassionate or competitive?)
- Neuroticism (Are you sensitive or confident?)
Researchers like Rubenzer and Faschingbauer actually applied these professional psychological scales to past presidents. They found that "great" presidents often scored high on Openness to Experience. So, when a quiz asks if you like trying new foods or traveling to weird places, it's actually trying to see if you have the "presidential" trait of intellectual curiosity.
Not All Tests Are Created Equal
Kinda funny how one test feels like a deep soul-searching journey and the next asks what your favorite color is. There are basically three types of these quizzes floating around the internet:
🔗 Read more: Why That Little Bird With a Yellow Rump Is Harder to Identify Than You Think
The "Buzzfeed" Style
These are purely for entertainment. They’ll ask you to "Pick a brunch menu" or "Choose a Netflix show" and then tell you you’re Harry S. Truman. There’s zero historical logic here. It’s just fun. You take it, you post the result on your story, and you move on.
The Policy Matcher
These are more serious. They ask about your stance on taxes, healthcare, or foreign intervention. These tests—like those often seen on Pew Research or specialized political sites—map your current beliefs against the actual platforms of past administrations. You might find out you’re a 19th-century Whig at heart.
The Personality Deep-Dive
These are the ones that actually try to match your temperament. They use historical records, diaries, and letters to build a "profile" of someone like George Washington. They ask about how you handle stress or conflict.
The "Greatness" Trap
Most people taking a which president are you test want to be the "good" ones. Everyone wants to be Lincoln. Nobody wants to be James Buchanan (the guy often blamed for not stopping the Civil War) or Andrew Johnson.
But history is messy. Honestly, even the "great" ones had traits that would make them difficult to live with.
- LBJ was known for "The Treatment"—getting in people's personal space and looming over them to get his way.
- John Adams could be incredibly prickly and sensitive to criticism.
- Calvin Coolidge was so quiet they called him "Silent Cal."
If a test is actually accurate, it should probably tell you about your flaws too. Are you stubborn? Are you a micromanager? Those are presidential traits, too.
💡 You might also like: Why Your Reverse Osmosis Filter Diagram Looks So Confusing (And How to Actually Read One)
What Most People Get Wrong
The biggest misconception is that these tests are "accurate" in a scientific sense. They aren't. They’re "proxies."
A test can't tell you how you'd handle the Cuban Missile Crisis because you aren't in 1962, and you don't have the weight of the world on your shoulders. What it can do is highlight your "default mode."
Do you lean toward diplomacy or action?
Do you trust your gut or do you need 50 pages of data before making a choice?
Why Accuracy is a Moving Target
Historians are constantly re-evaluating these men. Ulysses S. Grant used to be ranked near the bottom because of scandals in his administration. Now, he’s climbing the ranks because historians are looking more closely at his efforts toward civil rights.
This means a which president are you test written in 1990 would give you a very different "vibe" for Grant than one written in 2026. Our understanding of the past changes, and so does the way we "match" ourselves to it.
Making the Most of Your Result
So you took the test and got... Chester A. Arthur. You’re probably thinking, "Who?"
Don't just close the tab. Use it as a jumping-off point.
- Read a Wikipedia entry: Find out why the test matched you with them. Was it your style of dress? Your career path?
- Look for the "Shadow Side": Every presidential strength has a weakness. If you're "decisive" like Jackson, are you also "impulsive"?
- Cross-reference: Take three different tests. If you get three different presidents, look for the common thread. Are they all "War Presidents"? Are they all "Communicators"?
Actionable Next Steps
Instead of just clicking "retake," try these specific ways to dive deeper into your presidential persona:
- Audit Your Leadership Style: If your test result says you're a "Collaborator" like Eisenhower, look at your current project at work. Are you actually collaborating, or just telling people what to do?
- The "Diary" Exercise: Read a few pages of the diaries of the president you matched with. See if their internal monologue actually sounds like yours. (James K. Polk’s diary is famously detailed if you’re a workaholic).
- Compare Policy vs. Personality: Take a policy-based quiz and then a personality-based one. If you get FDR for personality but Herbert Hoover for policy, you’ve got some interesting internal contradictions to explore.
At the end of the day, a which president are you test is a mirror. It’s a way to see our own quirks and strengths through the lens of the most powerful office in the world. It’s less about who they were and more about who you are becoming.
Check out the most recent historians' rankings from the C-SPAN Presidential Historians Survey to see where your "match" currently stands in the eyes of the experts.