The air in the Yellowstone universe is usually thick with gunsmoke and the smell of cedar, but right now, it’s mostly filled with a lot of nervous waiting. Fans are constantly scouring the web to find out who dies in 1923 season 2, and honestly, the anxiety is justified. Taylor Sheridan has never been one to shy away from killing off a protagonist just when you start to like them. Look at what happened to John Dutton Sr. in the first few episodes of the first season. One minute he's scouting cattle, the next he's a memory. It set a grim tone that hasn't let up.
Predicting the body count for the upcoming season isn't just about guesswork; it’s about looking at the cold, hard logic of the Dutton lineage. We know who has to survive for Kevin Costner’s John Dutton III to eventually exist, but that leaves a massive, target-shaped hole over everyone else.
The Looming Shadow Over Jacob and Cara Dutton
Harrison Ford and Helen Mirren brought a level of gravitas to the franchise that we hadn't seen since the flagship show started. But let's be real. Jacob Dutton is hanging on by a thread. After the ambush that took out his nephew, Jacob spent half of the first season essentially rotting in a bed while Cara tried to hold the ranch together with nothing but grit and a shotgun.
When people ask who dies in 1923 season 2, Jacob is usually the first name on the list. Why? Because the "passing of the torch" is a classic Western trope that Sheridan loves. Jacob represents the old guard. He’s the bridge between the 1883 generation and the modern era. If he dies, it forces Spencer Dutton to stop running from his responsibilities and actually lead. It’s the kind of narrative catalyst that makes too much sense to ignore.
However, killing off Harrison Ford too early feels like a waste of a massive paycheck. There’s a world where Jacob survives just long enough to see the ranch secured, only to succumb to his lingering injuries or the sheer exhaustion of the era. Cara, on the other hand, feels safer. Not because she’s protected by plot armor, but because she’s the emotional glue. If you kill Cara, the ranch doesn't just lose a leader; it loses its soul.
Spencer and Alex: A Tragic Romance or a Survival Story?
If you've watched the season 1 finale, you know the situation is dire. Spencer and Alexandra are separated. She’s screaming from the deck of a ship while he’s being hauled away. It’s peak melodrama.
But here is the thing. Spencer is basically the only one left who can actually fight. If Spencer dies, the Dutton ranch is gone. Period. Jack is too young and impulsive. Jacob is too old and broken. Spencer is the soldier. So, when considering who dies in 1923 season 2, Spencer is likely the safest person on the cast list. He has to get back to Montana. He has to save the family.
Alexandra is a different story.
✨ Don't miss: Master of Dark Shadows: Why Dan Curtis and Barnabas Collins Still Haunt Our Screens
The "death of the lover" is a powerful motivator. If Alex doesn't make it to Montana, it turns Spencer from a reluctant hero into a vengeful god. Fans are terrified that she will meet her end before she even touches American soil. There’s also the murky history of the Dutton family tree. We know Jack has a kid. We don't know for sure if Spencer does. If Spencer is the actual ancestor of the modern-day Duttons—a popular fan theory—then he needs a wife. Whether that’s Alex or someone he meets after a tragic loss remains the biggest question mark of the series.
Banner Creighton and Donald Whitfield: The Villains' Debt
Villains in the Yellowstone world have a varied shelf life. Some, like the Beck Brothers, get wiped out in a single season. Others linger. Banner Creighton, played with a snarling, desperate energy by Jerome Flynn, feels like a man on borrowed time. He’s caused too much grief. He killed John Sr. He nearly killed Jacob.
In any traditional Western, the villain has to pay. It’s almost a guarantee that when we finally see who dies in 1923 season 2, Banner will be at the top of the list, likely at the business end of a Dutton lever-action rifle.
Then there’s Donald Whitfield. Timothy Dalton plays him with such oily, sophisticated menace that you almost want him to stick around just to hear him talk. But Whitfield represents the "encroaching modern world." He’s the personification of the corporate greed that the Duttons have been fighting for over a century. His death might not be as violent as Banner’s, but his downfall is inevitable. You can't have a show about the Duttons keeping their land if the guy trying to take it is still standing at the end of the story.
The Teonna Rainwater Factor
Teonna’s storyline is the most brutal part of the show. It’s hard to watch. It’s supposed to be. Her journey isn't just about survival; it’s about the systemic erasure of her people.
The stakes for Teonna are different. If she dies, it feels like a victory for the horrific institutions she fled. If she lives, she becomes the foundation for the Rainwater legacy we see in the modern era with Thomas Rainwater. Most experts and theorists agree that Teonna is a survivor. She’s the warrior of her storyline. However, the people around her? Her father, Hank (who already perished), and those trying to help her? They are in constant danger.
Jack and Elizabeth: The Future of the Bloodline
Jack Dutton is a firebrand. He’s impulsive, angry, and honestly, a bit of a liability. Elizabeth has already suffered a miscarriage, which was a devastating blow to the family’s hopes for the future.
The question of who dies in 1923 season 2 often circles back to Jack because he’s so reckless. But we have to look at the lineage. If Jack is the father of the next generation, he’s safe. If he’s not... well, his chances of surviving a shootout with Banner Creighton’s men drop significantly. There is a very real possibility that Jack dies and Spencer is forced to step in and father the heir to the ranch, perhaps even with Elizabeth, though that would be a dark twist even for this show.
Why the Body Count Matters More This Season
In the first season, the deaths were about shock. They were about showing the audience that no one is safe. In season 2, the deaths will be about resolution.
💡 You might also like: Over Your Dead Body Movie: Why Takashi Miike’s Meta-Horror Is Still Breaking Brains
1923 was originally conceived as a limited run. While it was expanded, the narrative still feels like it’s sprinting toward a conclusion. Every character we lose now has to serve the purpose of moving the Duttons closer to the version of the family we see in the 1940s and beyond.
The Great Depression is looming. The range wars are heating up. The world is getting smaller, and the Duttons are being backed into a corner. When people are backed into a corner, they get violent.
Real-World Context and Production Delays
It’s worth noting that the long gap between seasons—caused by the strikes and various production hurdles—has changed how we talk about these characters. We’ve had years to dissect every frame.
Sources close to the production haven't leaked a "kill list," mostly because Taylor Sheridan runs one of the tightest ships in Hollywood. Scripts are often handed out in pieces. Actors sometimes don't know their fate until they get the pages for that specific episode. This keeps the performances raw, but it keeps us in the dark.
What we do know is that the cast has been spotted filming in various locations that suggest a widening of the world. More locations mean more opportunities for things to go wrong.
Practical Takeaways for Fans
If you're trying to figure out who dies in 1923 season 2, keep these three things in mind:
- The Ancestry Rule: If a character is a confirmed direct ancestor of John Dutton III (Kevin Costner), they cannot die until they’ve produced the next link in the chain. This is why the Jack vs. Spencer debate is so heated.
- The Star Power Pivot: Massive stars like Harrison Ford are rarely killed off-screen or in the middle of a season without a massive, narrative-shifting event. If Jacob goes, it’ll be the season finale.
- The Villain Cycle: Westerns require catharsis. Banner Creighton has lived far longer than most "henchman" style villains in this universe. His clock is ticking.
Ultimately, 1923 is a story about the cost of survival. It’s not a question of if people will die, but how their deaths will shape the land for the next hundred years.
To stay ahead of the curve, keep a close eye on the official Paramount+ trailers. Usually, the "death flags" are hidden in the dialogue. Look for characters talking about the "future" or "legacy"—in the Sheridan-verse, that’s usually a sign they won't be around to see it. Also, check the casting calls for "young" versions of characters; if we see a flashback to a character’s childhood, it’s often a setup for their exit.
Wait for the premiere and watch the background. The cinematography often tells you who is being "phased out" before the script does. Characters who start appearing more in shadows or separated from the main group by the framing of the shot are often the ones marked for a departure.