Sean Connery wasn't even Ian Fleming’s first choice. Think about that. The man who literally defined the silhouette of the modern action hero—the tailored suit, the cold eyes, the effortless cruelty—was initially dismissed by the author as an "overgrown stuntman." Fleming wanted someone like Cary Grant or even David Niven. He wanted refinement. What he got was a former bodybuilder from Edinburgh who walked like a panther. It changed everything.
Finding the right actors who have played Bond isn't just a casting director’s job; it’s a weirdly high-stakes cultural ritual that happens every decade or so. Since 1962, only six men have officially held the "License to Kill" under the Eon Productions banner. Seven, if you’re the kind of person who counts the unofficial Never Say Never Again. Every time a new face shows up, the internet loses its collective mind. People argue about height, hair color, and whether a guy is "too emotional" or "too wooden." But the reality of playing 007 is way more grueling than just looking good in a tuxedo. It's a massive physical and mental commitment that has actually broken a few of the men who took the role.
Sean Connery: The Original Blueprint
Connery is the Big Bang of the franchise. Before Dr. No, the idea of a British secret agent was much more "hush-hush" and much less "explosive volcano base." Connery brought a certain grit. He was dangerous. You actually believed he could kill someone with his bare hands before finishing a martini.
He did five movies straight: Dr. No, From Russia with Love, Goldfinger, Thunderball, and You Only Live Twice. By the time he hit that fifth one, he was done. Burned out. He hated the circus. He hated the loss of privacy. He famously walked away, leaving the producers in a total panic. They tried to replace him with a literal amateur, but we'll get to George in a second. Connery eventually came back for Diamonds Are Forever in 1971, mostly because they offered him a record-breaking salary that he used to set up the Scottish International Education Trust. He looked older. He wore a toupee. But that voice? Still iconic.
Honestly, the "Connery vs. everyone else" debate is a bit unfair because he got all the best "firsts." He got the first Aston Martin DB5. He got the first meeting with Blofeld. He set the rules. Everyone else has just been trying to figure out how to break them or follow them ever since.
The One-Hit Wonder: George Lazenby
Imagine being a car salesman and model with zero acting experience and deciding you should be the next James Bond. That is exactly what George Lazenby did. He bluffed his way into the office of producer Cubby Broccoli, lied about his credits, and somehow landed the lead in On Her Majesty's Secret Service (1969).
It’s actually a great movie. Some fans argue it's the best one. It’s the only time Bond gets married—and the only time we see him truly devastated when Tracy Bond is murdered in the final frames. Lazenby was actually pretty good at the physical stuff. He did many of his own stunts. But he was difficult on set. He didn't get along with director Peter Hunt or co-star Diana Rigg. Then, his agent told him that Bond was a "dying format" and that the 1970s would be all about hippies and peace, not secret agents. So, Lazenby quit before the movie even premiered. Talk about a bad career move.
🔗 Read more: Rita Moreno and West Side Story: What Most People Get Wrong
Roger Moore and the Era of Eyebrow Acting
If Connery was the panther, Roger Moore was the tuxedo-clad comedian. He took over in 1973 with Live and Let Die and stayed in the role longer than anyone else: seven official films over twelve years.
Moore knew he couldn't do what Connery did. He didn't try to be a tough guy. He leaned into the absurdity. In the Moore era, Bond escaped from crocodiles by running across their heads. He went to space. He fought a giant with metal teeth. Moore’s Bond was the guy who never got a hair out of place, even while jumping a car over a bridge in a 360-degree corkscrew.
- Live and Let Die (1973)
- The Man with the Golden Gun (1974)
- The Spy Who Loved Me (1977)
- Moonraker (1979)
- For Your Eyes Only (1981)
- Octopussy (1983)
- A View to a Kill (1985)
By the time A View to a Kill came out, Moore was 57. He was older than the mother of his leading lady. He later admitted he stayed too long. But for a whole generation of kids who grew up in the 70s and 80s, Roger Moore was James Bond. He was charming, lighthearted, and didn't take the world-ending stakes too seriously.
Timothy Dalton: The Bond Who Was Ahead of His Time
People hated Timothy Dalton in the late 80s. Well, maybe "hate" is too strong, but they were confused. After the campy fun of Roger Moore, Dalton arrived with The Living Daylights (1987) and Licence to Kill (1989) looking like he wanted to murder everyone in the room.
Dalton was a Shakespearean actor. He went back to Fleming’s books and realized that Bond was actually a miserable, burnt-out assassin who hated his job. He played him with a brooding, violent intensity. In Licence to Kill, Bond goes rogue for a personal vendetta—it’s dark, it’s bloody, and it’s basically a proto-Daniel Craig performance. But audiences in 1989 weren't ready for a "gritty reboot." They wanted gadgets and jokes. Legal battles between Eon and MGM delayed the next film for years, and Dalton eventually stepped down. It’s a shame, really. If he’d stayed, the 90s might have looked very different for 007.
Pierce Brosnan: The Hybrid Hero
After a six-year hiatus, James Bond returned in 1995 with GoldenEye. Pierce Brosnan was the perfect choice. He looked like the drawings in the books. He had the charm of Moore and the coolness of Connery.
Brosnan’s run is a weird mix of high-quality filmmaking and absolute nonsense. GoldenEye is a masterpiece of action cinema. It introduced Judi Dench as M and proved Bond could still exist after the Cold War. But by the time we got to Die Another Day (2002), the series had gone off the rails again. Invisible cars? Windsurfing on a tsunami? It was too much. Brosnan wanted to do deeper, darker stuff—he’s great in The Tailor of Panama—but the scripts he was given for Bond eventually let him down. He was essentially fired over the phone, which is a pretty cold way to treat the man who saved the franchise from irrelevance.
Daniel Craig: The Human Bond
When Daniel Craig was announced as the next 007 in 2005, the British tabloids were brutal. "Bond is Blond," they screamed. They said he was too short. They said he looked like a villain, not a hero. Then Casino Royale came out in 2006.
Craig changed the game. He bled. He fell in love. He made mistakes. For the first time, we had a continuous story arc across five films: Casino Royale, Quantum of Solace, Skyfall, Spectre, and No Time to Die. We saw Bond’s origin, his peak, and his definitive end. Craig brought a physical brutality back to the role that hadn't been seen since the early Connery days. He also became the first actor to officially "die" in the role, closing out a 15-year tenure that redefined what a block-buster lead looks like in the 21st century.
The Forgotten Bonds and Technicalities
You’ll often see lists of actors who have played Bond that stop at six. But there are a few "extra-canonical" entries that make for great trivia.
- Barry Nelson: He was the first person to play James Bond on screen. He played "Jimmy Bond" in a 1954 TV adaptation of Casino Royale. He was American. It was... weird.
- David Niven: He played Bond in the 1967 satirical version of Casino Royale. It’s a psychedelic mess of a movie, but Niven was actually Ian Fleming’s original choice for the character.
- The Voice Actors: Don't forget the video games. Actors like Toby Stephens (who played the villain in Die Another Day) have voiced Bond in radio plays and games, keeping the character alive between movie releases.
The Impossible Search for Bond 7
Right now, we are in the "Great Silence." There is no James Bond. Barbara Broccoli and Michael G. Wilson, the keepers of the flame at Eon Productions, are notoriously picky. They aren't just looking for an actor; they’re looking for a partner who will give up the next 10 to 12 years of their life.
The rumors fly constantly. Aaron Taylor-Johnson? Henry Cavill? Rege-Jean Page? The reality is that the next Bond will likely be someone we don't expect. They usually pick someone on the cusp of stardom, not someone who is already the most famous person in the room. They need someone who can handle the physical toll and the relentless press.
What to look for in the next era:
- Age Matters: They usually want someone in their early 30s so they can do at least three or four movies.
- The Tone Shift: After the heavy, emotional Craig era, expect something a bit more adventurous and perhaps slightly lighter—not Moore-level camp, but maybe a bit more fun.
- The Contract: It's a "golden handcuffs" deal. Many big-name stars turn it down because they don't want to be locked into one character for a decade.
If you’re looking to dive deeper into the history of the role, start by watching From Russia with Love, On Her Majesty's Secret Service, and Casino Royale. These three movies show the widest range of what the character can be. They represent the three pillars of Bond: the cold assassin, the tragic romantic, and the vulnerable human being.
The hunt for the next 007 continues, but the legacy of the previous six men ensures that whoever takes the mantle will be stepping into the most scrutinized shoes in cinema history. It's a role that offers immortality, but as many of these actors found out, it comes with a heavy price.
Next Steps for Bond Fans
- Read the Original Material: If you’ve only seen the movies, pick up Fleming’s Moonraker. It is nothing like the movie and offers a much deeper look at Bond’s internal life.
- Explore the Soundtracks: The music of John Barry and David Arnold is half the character. Listen to the evolution of the Bond theme to see how the tone shifted with each actor.
- Watch the Documentaries: Everything or Nothing: The Untold Story of 007 is a fantastic look at how the producers kept the franchise alive through bankruptcies and changing tastes.