The casting for Johnny Storm is always a lightning rod for controversy. Or maybe a solar flare. When Marvel Studios finally announced that Joseph Quinn is the one who plays Human Torch in the upcoming The Fantastic Four: First Steps, the internet basically went into a meltdown. Some fans cheered because they loved him as Eddie Munson in Stranger Things. Others scratched their heads, wondering if the soft-spoken British actor could channel the arrogant, "look-at-me" energy of New York's favorite hothead.
It’s a tough gig. You aren't just playing a superhero; you're playing a celebrity. Johnny Storm is the guy who signs autographs while fighting giant monsters. He's the guy who thinks he’s the main character of the universe.
Finding the right person who plays Human Torch means finding someone who can be incredibly annoying but somehow still lovable. We've seen a few versions of this over the decades. Some were campy. Some were gritty. One was even Chris Evans before he became the moral compass of the MCU. Let’s get into why Joseph Quinn is the current man in the hot seat and how he compares to the legends who came before him.
Joseph Quinn and the New Era of Johnny Storm
Joseph Quinn is currently the official answer to who plays Human Torch in the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU). If you've been living under a rock, Quinn became a global sensation for his role in Stranger Things Season 4. He played a metalhead with a heart of gold who went out in a blaze of glory. Now, he’s trading the guitar for literal fire.
Director Matt Shakman seems to be going for a very specific vibe for this 2025/2026 era. The new movie is set in a retro-futuristic 1960s. This isn't our 1960s—it's a stylized, Kirby-esque version of the past. Quinn has to fit into that aesthetic. He’s been seen in leaked set photos wearing a sleek, blue-and-white suit that looks ripped straight from the 1963 comics.
✨ Don't miss: Who Was Really in the Whistle Down the Wind Cast Through the Years
People were worried about his accent. Quinn is British. Johnny Storm is the quintessential American teenager from Long Island. But if we’ve learned anything from Tom Holland or Benedict Cumberbatch, it’s that Marvel knows how to coach a dialect. Honestly, the bigger challenge isn't the voice; it’s the ego. Johnny Storm is a thrill-seeker. He’s the guy who takes the Ferrari out without asking. Quinn has shown he can do "charismatic outcast" perfectly. Can he do "arrogant superstar"? We'll find out when the movie hits theaters on July 25, 2025.
Why Quinn’s Casting Matters for the MCU
Marvel is in a weird spot. They need a hit. The Fantastic Four is often called "Marvel’s First Family," but their movie history is, frankly, a bit of a mess. By casting Quinn, Marvel is betting on "Internet Boyfriends." They want actors who have a deep, dedicated fanbase that will show up no matter what.
Quinn isn't alone, though. He’s joined by Pedro Pascal as Reed Richards, Vanessa Kirby as Sue Storm, and Ebon Moss-Bachrach as The Thing. That is a heavy-hitting lineup. Quinn has to hold his own against an Emmy winner and an Oscar nominee. He’s the "little brother" of the group, both in the script and likely on set.
The Chris Evans Legacy: Before He Was Captain America
Long before he was picking up Mjolnir, Chris Evans was the definitive answer to who plays Human Torch for a whole generation. He played the role in Fantastic Four (2005) and Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer (2007).
If you go back and watch those movies today, they're... okay. They're a bit cheesy. But Evans? Evans was perfect. He captured that smirk. He had the physique, the comedic timing, and the "Flame On!" catchphrase down to a science. It’s funny looking back because his Johnny Storm is the polar opposite of Steve Rogers. Johnny is selfish. Steve is selfless. Johnny wants the spotlight. Steve wants to hide in the back of the line.
Evans actually returned to the role briefly in Deadpool & Wolverine (2024). It was one of the biggest "gotcha" moments in recent cinema history. Everyone expected him to show up as Captain America. Instead, he dropped a bunch of F-bombs and got flayed alive by Cassandra Nova. It reminded everyone that, deep down, Evans still has that bratty Johnny Storm energy in his range.
Michael B. Jordan and the 2015 Experiment
In 2015, Josh Trank directed a reboot that most people try to forget. Michael B. Jordan was the one who plays Human Torch in that version. At the time, the casting caused a lot of unnecessary "discourse" online because Jordan is Black and the character had traditionally been portrayed as white.
The irony? Jordan was the best part of that movie.
The film itself was a tonal disaster. It tried to be a body-horror movie, then a generic superhero flick, and it failed at both. But Jordan brought a grounded, mechanical interest to the character. He wasn't just a jock; he was a gearhead who built his own engines. It was a cool take that got buried under a bad script.
Jordan, like Evans, went on to do much bigger things in the Marvel world. He became Erik Killmonger in Black Panther, widely considered one of the best villains in movie history. It goes to show that being the guy who plays Human Torch is often a stepping stone to superstardom.
The Forgotten Torch: Jay Underwood
We have to talk about the 1994 movie. It was produced by Roger Corman and was never actually intended to be released. It was made solely so the studio could keep the film rights. It’s a legendary piece of "lost" media that you can now find on YouTube in grainy 480p.
In this version, Jay Underwood is the one who plays Human Torch. The special effects are... well, they’re 1994 low-budget practical effects. When Johnny "flames on," he basically becomes a poorly superimposed cartoon. Underwood played it very "golly-gee-whiz," which was accurate to the very early 1960s comics but felt dated even in the 90s. Still, he was the first to do it in a feature-length format, even if the movie was technically a legal loophole.
🔗 Read more: Not With My Wife: The Norman Panama Comedy That Time Almost Forgot
What it Takes to "Flame On"
Playing this character isn't just about looking good in spandex. There’s a psychological layer to Johnny Storm that most people miss. He’s a guy who literally burns himself up.
Think about the physics—which the comics occasionally touch on. He has to stay hydrated. He has to worry about the oxygen in the room. In the more recent comics, like the "Life Story" run or the North/Coello run, we see a Johnny who is terrified of being alone. He surrounds himself with fans and fire because he’s scared of the quiet.
Joseph Quinn has hinted in interviews that he’s looking at the source material deeply. He’s not just watching the old movies. He’s looking at the way Jack Kirby drew the character—the kinetic energy, the way Johnny always seems to be in motion.
Training and Special Effects
In the 2005 movie, Chris Evans had to spend hours in the gym, but he also had to deal with early CGI tracking markers. For Joseph Quinn, the tech has evolved. We're talking about "The Volume" (the massive LED screens used in The Mandalorian) and high-end motion capture.
But there’s a physical toll too. You have to move like fire. Fire isn't stiff. It’s fluid. It’s unpredictable. If you watch the way Evans moved, he was very athletic and bouncy. Quinn has a different physicality—he’s a bit more lanky. It will be interesting to see if his Human Torch moves differently than the ones we've seen before.
Comparing the Portrayals
If you’re trying to keep track of the lineage, it looks something like this:
- Jay Underwood (1994): The "lost" performance. Earnest, low-budget, and very campy.
- Chris Evans (2005-2007): The gold standard for charisma. He defined the "superhero as a celebrity" trope before the MCU even existed.
- Michael B. Jordan (2015): The wasted potential. A great actor trapped in a movie that didn't know what it wanted to be.
- Joseph Quinn (2025): The newcomer. He’s bringing a 1960s retro vibe and a massive built-in fanbase.
The Misconceptions About the Character
One thing people get wrong about who plays Human Torch is thinking the actor has to be a "jerk." Johnny isn't a jerk. He’s impulsive. There’s a difference.
The best Johnny Storm actors understand that he loves his family more than anything. He fights with Ben Grimm (The Thing) constantly, but he’d die for him. That brotherly chemistry is the secret sauce. If Joseph Quinn and Ebon Moss-Bachrach don't have that "I hate you but I love you" energy, the movie won't work. It doesn't matter how good the fire effects are.
Looking Ahead: What’s Next for the Torch?
Once The Fantastic Four: First Steps drops, we aren't just seeing a one-off. Joseph Quinn is likely signed for a multi-picture deal. This means he will be the Human Torch for the next decade. He’ll be in the next Avengers movies. He might cross paths with Spider-Man—and in the comics, Johnny Storm and Peter Parker are best friends.
Fans are already dying to see the "Spidey and Torch" dynamic on screen. Tom Holland and Joseph Quinn together? That’s a box office goldmine.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Collectors
If you're following the journey of who plays Human Torch, there are a few things you can do to stay ahead of the curve:
- Read the "Fantastic Four: Life Story" comic. It gives you a great sense of how Johnny ages and changes over time, which might influence Quinn's long-term portrayal.
- Watch Joseph Quinn’s older work. Check out A Quiet Place: Day One or Dickensian. It shows his range beyond the "Eddie Munson" archetype.
- Keep an eye on the official Marvel socials. They've been dropping "concept art" that looks like 1960s postcards. This gives us the biggest hint about the tone Quinn will be playing.
- Don't ignore the 2005 movies. Even if they're dated, Chris Evans' performance is a masterclass in how to play a "lovable ego."
The mantle of the Human Torch is a heavy one. It requires a mix of physical comedy, high-octane action, and genuine emotional vulnerability. Joseph Quinn has some big, flaming shoes to fill, but he has the talent to make the character his own. Whether he’s cracking jokes at Ben Grimm’s expense or flying through the New York skyline, he’s about to become the face of a new generation of Marvel fans.
The wait until July 2025 feels long, but for a character that’s been waiting decades for a truly "perfect" MCU debut, it’s just a blink of an eye. Get ready. Things are about to get hot.