Shakespeare’s As You Like It is a weird play. It’s a pastoral comedy that spends half its time mocking pastoral comedies. To make that work, the As You Like It cast needs to be more than just a group of actors in doublets and hose; they have to navigate a script that is simultaneously a goofy romance and a biting philosophical debate. If your Rosalind is flat, the whole show collapses. If your Jacques is just a moody guy in a corner, you lose the soul of the production.
I’ve seen dozens of versions of this play. Some were high-budget cinematic feasts, and others were fringe theater productions where the "forest" was literally just three step-ladders and some green tinsel. What’s fascinating is how the casting choices define the era. Back in the day, it was all about the big-name stars. Now, directors are playing with gender, age, and classical expectations to find new layers in the Forest of Arden.
The Rosalind Problem: Why She Makes or Breaks the Show
Rosalind is the massive mountain every actress wants to climb. She has more lines than any other female character in Shakespeare. Honestly, she has more lines than most of the men. When you look at a famous As You Like It cast, the conversation always starts and ends with her.
Take the 1936 film version. It’s old, black and white, and definitely a product of its time. But it featured Elisabeth Bergner. She had this nervous, electric energy that made the "Ganymede" disguise feel almost plausible, even if the film itself felt a bit stiff. Then you jump ahead to 2006, where Kenneth Branagh cast Bryce Dallas Howard in his film adaptation set in 19th-century Japan. It was a bold swing. Howard brought a modern, wide-eyed sincerity to the role that grounded the floating, dreamlike quality of that specific production.
But for many purists, the gold standard remains Vanessa Redgrave in the 1961 Royal Shakespeare Company production. She was 24. She was luminous. Most importantly, she understood the humor. You can’t play Rosalind as a tragic figure; she’s a woman who is deeply, desperately in love but also smart enough to realize how ridiculous love makes people act.
Orlando and the Chemistry Test
Orlando is often played as a bit of a meathead. He’s the guy who writes terrible poetry and carves it into trees, after all. But if the actor playing Orlando doesn't have chemistry with Rosalind, the play feels like a long walk through the woods for no reason.
In that 1936 film I mentioned? A young Laurence Olivier played Orlando. Think about that. One of the greatest dramatic actors of all time, playing a lovestruck kid who wrestles for fun. He brought a physical intensity to it that most actors miss. More recently, in the 2022 @sohoplace production in London, Alfred Enoch (of Harry Potter and How to Get Away with Murder fame) took on the role. He brought a gentle, almost bewildered charm to Orlando that made you actually root for him instead of just laughing at his bad poems.
Jacques and the "Seven Ages of Man" Burden
Every As You Like It cast includes one person who has to deliver the most famous speech in the history of English literature: "All the world's a stage."
It’s a nightmare for an actor. How do you say lines that everyone in the audience can recite along with you without sounding like a Hallmark card? Jacques is the "melancholy" character, the guy who refuses to join the happy ending. He’s the cynical voice in a play full of optimists.
Kevin Kline played Jacques in the 2006 Branagh film and did something brilliant. He played him with a sort of weary, intellectual dry wit. He wasn't just sad; he was bored with how predictable everyone else was. It’s a subtle distinction, but it changes the whole vibe of the Forest of Arden. If Jacques is just a "downer," the play feels lopsided. If he’s a philosopher, he becomes the necessary shadow to Rosalind’s light.
The Modern Shift: Diversity and Gender Fluidity
We’re seeing a massive shift in how the As You Like It cast is assembled these days. Since the play is already about gender-swapping (Rosalind becomes Ganymede, who then pretends to be Rosalind), it’s the perfect playground for non-traditional casting.
The 2023 National Theatre production was a masterclass in this. They didn't just cast for the roles; they reimagined the community of the forest. We've seen productions where Jacques is played by a woman—Tamsin Greig did this at the Globe in 2024, bringing a sharp, sardonic edge to the role that felt entirely fresh.
When you look at the 2018 Globe production, directed by Elle While, they leaned heavily into the "carnival" aspect of the play. The casting was diverse, the music was loud, and the energy was chaotic. It reminded everyone that Shakespeare wrote this for a rowdy crowd in Southwark, not for people to sit silently in velvet chairs.
Supporting Players Who Steal the Spotlight
Don't overlook the "clown" roles. Touchstone is the professional fool, and Audrey is the goat-herd he falls for. If these two aren't funny, the second act drags.
- Patsy Ferran as Celia: In the 2018 Globe run, Ferran was a revelation. Usually, Celia is just the "best friend" who follows Rosalind around. Ferran made her a comedic powerhouse in her own right, reacting to Rosalind’s madness with a mix of loyalty and "are you serious?" expressions.
- Adrian Lester as Rosalind: Wait, a man? Yes. Back in 1991, Cheek by Jowl did an all-male production. Lester was Rosalind. It sounds like a gimmick, but critics at the time said it was one of the most moving versions of the play ever staged because it stripped away the "drag" tropes and focused on the raw emotion of the character.
Why We Keep Recasting Arden
The reason the As You Like It cast evolves is that the Forest of Arden isn't a real place. It’s a state of mind. It’s where you go when the "real world" (the Court) becomes too dangerous or too stifling.
In the Court, everything is rigid. Rules matter. In the Forest, rules disappear. You can be a man, a woman, a shepherd, or a philosopher. You can fall in love with a stranger in five minutes. Because the setting is so fluid, the casting has to be too. A cast that feels too "classical" or "stiff" fails the play. You need actors who are willing to be a little messy.
Assessing the 2025-2026 Season Trends
Right now, there's a move toward "environmental" casting. This involves using the physical space of the theater to dictate the cast's movement. In some recent regional productions, the As You Like It cast includes musicians who are part of the scene, blurring the line between the "actors" and the "atmosphere."
We’re also seeing more age-blind casting. Why should Rosalind and Orlando always be in their early 20s? The 2022 @sohoplace production featured Rose Ayling-Ellis, who used British Sign Language (BSL) throughout her performance. It wasn't just an accessibility feature; it was integrated into the storytelling, showing how communication—and the failure of it—is at the heart of the play.
Making Sense of the Versions
If you’re trying to decide which version to watch to see the best As You Like It cast, it depends on what you want:
If you want pure Hollywood prestige, the 2006 Kenneth Branagh version is the way to go. You get Bryce Dallas Howard, Kevin Kline, and David Oyelowo. It’s lush, it’s beautiful, and it’s very easy to follow.
If you want the raw, theatrical energy of Shakespeare’s home, look for the filmed stage performances from The Globe. The 2009 production featuring Naomi Frederick and Jack Laskey is particularly good. It captures the "wooden O" atmosphere where the actors interact with the "groundlings" (the audience members standing in the front).
For something historical and foundational, the 1961 RSC production with Vanessa Redgrave is a must. It basically set the blueprint for how modern actresses approach the role of Rosalind.
📖 Related: Long Bright River Season 2: Will Peacock Actually Order More Episodes?
Practical Takeaways for Your Next Viewing
When you’re looking at a new As You Like It cast list, keep these things in mind to see if the production is going to be any good:
- Check the Rosalind/Celia dynamic. If these two don't feel like real friends, the first act will be a chore. Their bond is the only thing that makes the escape to the forest believable.
- Look for the Jacques "vibe." Is he played as a moping teenager or a seasoned cynic? The latter is usually much more interesting.
- Note the Silvius and Phebe casting. These are the "parody" lovers. If they are played too straight, they’re boring. If they’re played too over-the-top, they’re annoying. The best casts find a middle ground where you feel bad for Silvius even while you're laughing at him.
- Pay attention to the music. Most casts now include actors who can play instruments. Shakespeare wrote several songs into this play ("Under the Greenwood Tree," "Blow, Blow, Thou Winter Wind"), and a cast that can actually sing and play adds a layer of magic that a backtrack just can't provide.
Basically, As You Like It survives because it’s flexible. It’s a mirror. Every time a new director assembles an As You Like It cast, they’re telling us something about how we view love and identity in that specific moment in time. Whether it’s a man in the 1600s, a woman in the 1960s, or a non-binary actor in 2026, the character of Rosalind remains one of the most vital, complex creations in the history of the stage.
The next time you see a production announced, don't just look at the headliner. Look at the ensemble. The Forest of Arden is only as good as the people inhabiting it.
To dive deeper into the world of Shakespearean performance, your next move should be to compare a traditional Globe production with a modern "concept" film. Start by watching the 2009 Globe performance and then jump into the 2006 Branagh film. Seeing how two different casts handle the same jokes—especially the "Seven Ages of Man" speech—will give you a better grasp of the play's range than any textbook ever could.