You’re probably humming it right now. That soaring melody, the synth-heavy backdrop, or maybe that raw, bluesy acoustic guitar. But here’s the thing: when people ask who sings all of my love, they usually aren’t looking for one specific person.
Music history is messy.
There are at least three massive, chart-topping songs with almost identical titles, and if you mix them up, you’re looking at entirely different genres, decades, and vibes. We’re talking about the heavy-hitting rock legends of the 70s, a 2024 pop sensation, and a classic R&B powerhouse. Honestly, it’s a bit of a sonic minefield.
Most people are looking for Led Zeppelin.
Specifically, the 1979 track "All My Love" from their final studio album, In Through the Out Door. It’s iconic. It’s haunting. But if you’re younger—or just into modern pop—you might actually be thinking of Sabrina Carpenter and her 2024 hit "All of My Love" (often stylized as "All of My Love" or confused with "Slim Pickings" and "Juno" vibes from the Short n' Sweet era). Then there’s The Gap Band.
Let's break down exactly who is behind these tracks and why the stories behind them matter way more than a simple credits list.
Led Zeppelin and the Heartbreak Behind the Lyrics
If you are looking for the classic rock version, the answer to who sings all of my love is Robert Plant. But to call it just a "Led Zeppelin song" feels like an understatement. It’s a eulogy.
Recorded at ABBA’s Polar Studios in Sweden, this track stands out because it’s one of the few Zeppelin songs where Jimmy Page didn’t have a writing credit. That’s huge. Usually, Page was the architect, but this time, it was Robert Plant and John Paul Jones.
The Tragic Inspiration
Robert Plant wrote the lyrics for his son, Karac, who died suddenly in 1977 while Zeppelin was on tour in the United States. He was only five years old. You can hear the grief. When Plant sings about a "feather in the wind," he’s talking about the fragility of life. It isn’t a love song for a girlfriend; it’s a father’s desperate reach toward a child he lost.
John Paul Jones dominated the sound here. That famous, slightly "cheesy" (depending on who you ask) synthesizer solo? That’s a Yamaha GX-1. It gave the song a symphonic, almost prog-rock feel that polarized fans at the time. Jimmy Page and drummer John Bonham reportedly weren't huge fans of the softer direction, but they played it with a restrained power that made it a radio staple.
If you’re listening to a version with a long, majestic synth outro and a very emotional vocal delivery, you’re definitely listening to Robert Plant.
The Modern Era: Sabrina Carpenter’s Take
Fast forward to 2024. If you’ve been on TikTok or Spotify recently, you’ve likely seen the name Sabrina Carpenter everywhere. While she has a song titled "All of My Love" on her massive album Short n' Sweet, she’s part of a new wave of artists reclaiming these classic titles.
Why It’s Trending
Sabrina’s version is a completely different beast. It’s bubbly, sarcastic, and deeply rooted in modern synth-pop. While Robert Plant was singing about loss, Sabrina is singing about the frustration of giving your all to someone who doesn't quite get it.
She sings it with that signature "wink-and-a-nod" vocal style. It’s breathy. It’s precise. It’s also incredibly catchy.
What’s interesting is how the search for who sings all of my love spiked the moment her album dropped. Gen Z listeners were searching for her lyrics, while Gen X and Boomers were busy arguing about whether anyone could ever top the Zeppelin version.
The R&B Groove: The Gap Band
We can't talk about this title without mentioning the 1989 hit by The Gap Band.
Charlie Wilson. That’s the voice.
If the song you’re thinking of makes you want to get up and two-step, it’s Charlie Wilson. "All of My Love" by The Gap Band reached number one on the R&B charts and stayed there. It’s a masterclass in New Jack Swing and late-80s soul.
💡 You might also like: The Optimus Prime Truck: What Most People Get Wrong About the Movie Rigs
The Gap Band brought a funk pedigree to the title that the other versions lack. While Zeppelin is grand and Sabrina is poppy, Charlie Wilson is smooth. He’s soulful. He’s singing about a very different kind of devotion.
Why People Confuse Them
People often forget the "of" in the title.
- Led Zeppelin: "All My Love"
- The Gap Band: "All of My Love"
- Sabrina Carpenter: "All of My Love"
That one little preposition is usually the only thing separating a classic rock masterpiece from a dance-floor filler or a modern pop anthem.
Other Notable Versions You Might Be Hearing
Sometimes, the person singing isn't the original artist. Covers are everywhere.
Dread Zeppelin, the Elvis-fronted reggae Led Zeppelin tribute band (yes, they are real and they are amazing), did a version. It’s weird. It’s heavy on the reggae beat. If the singer sounds like a funky Elvis Presley, you’ve found the Dread Zeppelin version.
Then there’s the London Philharmonic Orchestra. They did an instrumental version that strips away the lyrics entirely, focusing on the melody John Paul Jones wrote. It highlights just how complex the composition actually was.
The Ariana Grande Connection
In 2014, Major Lazer released a track called "All My Love" featuring Ariana Grande for The Hunger Games: Mockingjay, Part 1 soundtrack. This is a massive EDM-pop hybrid. If there’s a heavy beat drop and a whistle-tone-capable soprano, it’s Ariana.
The 90s Factor
En Vogue also had a track titled "Give It Up, Turn It Loose" that often gets mislabeled in early digital music libraries as "All My Love" because of the repeating chorus.
Deciding Which One Is Yours
How do you know which one you're looking for? Look at the "vibe check."
- Does it sound like a church organ mixed with a rock band? It’s Robert Plant (Led Zeppelin).
- Does it sound like a 2024 summer party with clever, fast-paced lyrics? It’s Sabrina Carpenter.
- Does it sound like 1989, complete with a funky bassline and silky smooth male vocals? It’s Charlie Wilson (The Gap Band).
- Is it an EDM track from a movie soundtrack? It’s Ariana Grande and Major Lazer.
The Misconception of the "Lost" Recording
There’s a common rumor that there’s a "lost" version of the Led Zeppelin song featuring a different lead singer because Plant’s voice was struggling during that era. That’s mostly myth. While Plant’s voice had changed significantly from the "immigrant Song" days of 1970 to the In Through the Out Door sessions in 1978, he is the only one who ever laid down lead vocals for that track.
Any "alternate" version you find on YouTube is likely a demo or a fan-made "AI vocal" recreation, which have become strangely popular in 2025 and 2026. Stay away from those if you want the real emotional weight of the original.
How to Properly Credit and Find These Songs
To find the exact version you want, you have to be specific with your streaming search.
- For the rock classic: Search "All My Love Led Zeppelin".
- For the R&B hit: Search "All of My Love Gap Band".
- For the modern pop star: Search "All of My Love Sabrina Carpenter".
If you're using a smart speaker, specifically ask for the artist name. Simply asking "play All of My Love" is a roll of the dice. You might get a 1970s synth solo when you were actually in the mood for a 2024 pop breakdown.
Actionable Steps for Music Fans
- Check the Year: Look at the release date in your streaming app. 1979 is Zeppelin, 1989 is Gap Band, 2014 is Ariana, and 2024 is Sabrina.
- Listen to the Lyrics: If you hear "Yours is the cloth, mine is the hand that sews time," you're listening to a masterpiece of rock poetry. If the lyrics are about modern dating and "sending a text," you're in the 21st century.
- Explore the Covers: If you like the Zeppelin version, check out the live versions from the Celebration Day era. Even though they didn't play it often live, the rehearsals are legendary.
- Verify the Credits: Use sites like Discogs or Genius to see the actual songwriters. It's the best way to avoid the "fake" or "AI" covers that are cluttering up search results lately.
The answer to who sings all of my love depends entirely on your own musical history. Whether it’s Robert Plant’s tribute to his son or Sabrina Carpenter’s modern pop anthem, each version holds a specific place in the cultural zeitgeist. Knowing the difference doesn't just make you a better trivia player—it helps you appreciate the evolution of songwriting over the last fifty years.