It was cold. Really cold. On December 12, 2012, New York City was still reeling from the literal and figurative wreckage of Hurricane Sandy. The subways were mostly back, but the vibe in the city was heavy, gray, and exhausted. People needed a win. They got 12 12 12 The Concert.
Honestly, calling it a "concert" feels like a massive understatement. It was a marathon. Six hours of pure, unadulterated rock and roll history packed into Madison Square Garden. If you weren't there, you were probably one of the two billion people—yes, billion with a B—who had access to the stream. It was everywhere. It was on the radio, it was on every TV channel, and it was the first time a benefit felt like it actually had the weight of the world behind it.
The lineup was absurd. Paul McCartney, The Rolling Stones, Bruce Springsteen, Roger Waters, The Who, Billy Joel, Eric Clapton. It was basically a living Hall of Fame museum that decided to get together for a jam session in Midtown Manhattan.
The Night Bruce Set the Tone
Bruce Springsteen and the E Street Band kicked things off, and they didn't ease into it. They went straight for "Land of Hope and Dreams." You could feel the room shift. Bruce has this way of making a massive arena feel like a tiny kitchen table conversation, and he knew exactly what the crowd needed to hear. He brought out Jon Bon Jovi for "Born to Run," and for a second, the Jersey-New York rivalry just vanished.
It wasn't just about the music. It was about the money, obviously. The Robin Hood Foundation was running the show, and they weren't messing around. They eventually raised over $50 million that night alone, with the total climbing north of $60 million later. But the energy? That's what people remember.
You’ve got to remember the context here. Lower Manhattan had been underwater. Staten Island was devastated. The Jersey Shore was unrecognizable. When Adam Sandler got up and did a parody of "Hallelujah" called "Sandy-lujah," it sounds cheesy on paper, but it was the first time a lot of people in that room had laughed in weeks. He was making jokes about the Knicks and the local news anchors, and it grounded the whole spectacle in something real.
When Sir Paul Became a Grunge Frontman
Probably the most talked-about moment of 12 12 12 The Concert was the Nirvana "reunion." Sort of. Dave Grohl, Krist Novoselic, and Pat Smear took the stage, but instead of trying to replace Kurt Cobain, they brought out Paul McCartney.
They played "Cut Me Some Slack."
It was loud. It was abrasive. It was definitely not "Yesterday." Watching a 70-year-old Beatle screaming over Grohl’s thunderous drumming was peak 2012 surrealism. Some people hated it. Most people thought it was the coolest thing they’d ever seen. It showed that the night wasn't just a nostalgia trip; it was about the raw power of live performance. McCartney stayed on for a massive set afterward, eventually closing the night with "Live and Let Die" and "I've Got a Feeling" with Alicia Keys. By the time he finished, it was nearly 2:00 AM.
The British Invasion (Again)
The Rolling Stones showed up, played two songs, and left. It was brief. Mick Jagger made a joke about how this was the biggest collection of old British musicians ever seen in Madison Square Garden. He wasn't wrong.
The Who, on the other hand, played like they were trying to tear the roof off. Pete Townshend was windmills and fury. Roger Daltrey, even with his voice showing the years, hit the scream in "Won't Get Fooled Again" with enough force to rattle the rafters. It’s funny how these guys, most of whom were in their 60s and 70s at the time, out-energized almost every modern act on the bill.
Why 12 12 12 The Concert Actually Worked
We’ve all seen benefit concerts that feel corporate or forced. This didn't. Maybe it’s because it was in New York. The MSG crowd is notoriously difficult, but that night, they were all-in.
- No Egos: You had Billy Joel playing "Miami 2017 (Seen the Lights Go Out on Broadway)" which, let's be honest, is the unofficial anthem for any New York disaster. He followed it up with "Moving Out" and "New York State of Mind." He knew his role. He was the local hero.
- The Tech: This was a massive technical feat. It was broadcast to every continent.
- The First Responders: The floor wasn't just filled with celebrities and high-rollers. A huge chunk of the audience were the people who had been digging out houses and pumping out basements.
Roger Waters’ set was a visual masterpiece, as you’d expect. He did "Another Brick in the Wall" with a youth choir from the impacted areas. When they took off their hoodies to reveal "Fear Builds Walls" shirts, it was a heavy moment. Then he brought out Eddie Vedder for "Comfortably Numb." Vedder’s baritone mixed with Waters’ grit? Perfection.
The Logistics of a $60 Million Night
People often wonder where the money goes after these things. The Robin Hood Foundation is pretty transparent about it. They didn't just dump cash into a general fund. They targeted 400 different non-profits in the tri-state area.
👉 See also: Heather Hell's Kitchen Season 2: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
They focused on:
- Housing and mold remediation (a huge issue after the flooding).
- Food banks that were depleted.
- Legal services for people fighting insurance companies.
- Small business grants to get storefronts open again.
It’s easy to be cynical about "rich rockstars" helping out, but 12 12 12 The Concert was a logistics miracle. It was put together in less than six weeks. Think about that. Getting that many legends in one room with that much equipment and a global broadcast signal in 40 days is basically impossible.
The Moments Nobody Talks About
While everyone remembers Paul and Nirvana, Eric Clapton’s set was quietly incredible. He did "Got to Get Better in a Little While" and "Crossroads." It was pure blues. No bells and whistles. Just a guy and a Stratocaster reminding everyone why he’s called Slowhand.
And then there was Chris Martin. He did a stripped-back set, just him and a guitar or piano, and then he brought out Michael Stipe. Stipe had been mostly retired since R.E.M. broke up a year earlier. Seeing him come out to sing "Losing My Religion" was a "pinch me" moment for the Gen Xers in the crowd. It was understated and beautiful.
Actionable Takeaways for Music History Buffs
If you want to relive this or understand the impact, don't just watch the clips.
Check out the documentary "The Love We Make," which covers Paul McCartney’s similar efforts after 9/11. It provides a lot of context for why he was the one to anchor the 12 12 12 show.
Look up the Robin Hood Relief Fund reports. If you’re ever curious about how to vet a charity, their breakdown of the Sandy relief is a gold standard in "how to do it right."
Listen to the live album. It was released shortly after and it’s one of the few benefit albums where the sound quality actually holds up. The mixing on The Who’s set is particularly crisp.
The reality is we probably won't see a show like this again. The "Old Guard" of rock is thinning out, and the industry is too fragmented now. 12 12 12 The Concert was the last great gathering of the titans, all for a city that desperately needed a light at the end of a very dark tunnel. It wasn't just a concert; it was a 2:00 AM New York City victory lap.
To dive deeper into the specific impact of the night, you can find the full setlists on sites like Setlist.fm or track down the original broadcast footage, which is still archived in various places online. Understanding the sheer scale of the production—from the revolving stages to the satellite uplinks—gives you a whole new appreciation for what the organizers pulled off while half the city was still without power.
Go listen to that Billy Joel set. It still hits just as hard.