Music moves people. But it’s rare when a movie soundtrack stops being a "soundtrack" and starts being a cultural fixture that refuses to leave the radio. When Bradley Cooper and Lady Gaga teamed up for the 2018 remake, people expected a few decent pop tunes. They didn't expect a gritty, raw, and technically complex exploration of addiction and fame told through a collection of tracks that felt lived-in. A Star Is Born songs didn't just support the plot; they were the plot.
Jackson Maine’s gravelly voice and Ally’s meteoric rise wouldn't have worked if the music sounded like studio-polished fluff. It had to be live. It had to be loud. It had to feel like it was recorded in front of thousands of screaming fans at Glastonbury or Coachella—because, honestly, most of it was.
👉 See also: Tom Holland New Spider-Man Suit: What Most People Get Wrong
The Raw Power Behind "Shallow" and the Big Hits
You know "Shallow." Everyone knows "Shallow." That "Haaa-ah-ah-ah" belt from Gaga is burned into the collective memory of the late 2010s. But looking back, the track’s success wasn’t just about the meme-worthy bridge. It was about the bridge between two genres. You have the folk-rock, Americana grit of Jackson Maine clashing with the burgeoning pop sensibility of Ally. Lukas Nelson, son of the legendary Willie Nelson, was the secret weapon here. He helped Cooper find a sound that felt authentic to a road-worn rocker rather than a movie star playing dress-up.
Nelson and his band, Promise of the Real, provided the backbone for the more rock-heavy A Star Is Born songs. This wasn't some guy in a booth with Auto-Tune. Cooper insisted on recording live on set. He hated the look of actors lip-syncing to pre-recorded tracks because it always looks a bit "off" around the mouth. By singing live, they captured the actual breathing patterns and the physical strain of the performances.
"Maybe It's Time" serves as the thematic anchor for Jackson. Written by Jason Isbell, a titan in the Americana scene, the song is a brutal reflection on aging and the difficulty of change. It’s a simple acoustic melody, but the lyrics—"Maybe it's time to let the old ways die"—basically tell you exactly how the movie is going to end within the first twenty minutes. Isbell’s involvement gave the film a massive amount of "street cred" with country and folk purists who usually roll their eyes at Hollywood’s take on their world.
👉 See also: Why No Strings Attached 2011 Still Defines the Modern Rom-Com Debate
Why "Always Remember Us This Way" is the Better Song
I’ll say it. "Shallow" won the Oscar, but "Always Remember Us This Way" is the emotional peak of the record. It feels like a classic Carole King or Elton John ballad. It’s timeless. Gaga’s performance here is more restrained than her usual theatrical output, focusing on a soulful, piano-driven melody that captures the exact moment a relationship starts to slip away.
Writing this track involved a "who's who" of Nashville songwriters, including Natalie Hemby, Hillary Lindsey, and Lori McKenna. These women are the architects of modern country storytelling. They brought a specific kind of heartache to the table that felt grounded. Most movie songs feel like they were written by a committee trying to win an award. This one felt like a diary entry.
And then there's the shift. As Ally becomes a star, the music changes. It gets glossier. It gets "poppier." Tracks like "Hair Body Face" and "Why Did You Do That?" are often dismissed by fans of the earlier, rockier stuff. But that’s the point. The music is supposed to feel a bit more disposable because it represents the machinery of the industry swallowing Ally’s original voice. It’s a clever bit of meta-commentary that many people missed while they were busy arguing about whether the lyrics "Why do you look so good in those jeans?" were actually good or not.
Behind the Scenes: The Technical Grit
Mark Ronson, who worked heavily on the soundtrack, has talked about how they wanted to avoid the "theatrical" sound. They wanted dirt. They wanted feedback. During the filming of the concert scenes, the production actually hijacked real festival stages. They had about ten to fifteen minutes between real sets at Stagecoach and Glastonbury to run out, set up, and film Cooper performing "Black Eyes."
📖 Related: Why Dance with the Stars Season 31 Was the Biggest Gamble in Show History
The crowd’s reaction in those scenes is real because there were actually 80,000 people there. That energy translates into the audio. When you listen to the opening track, "Black Eyes," you hear the rumble of the amps. It’s a heavy, bluesy stomp that establishes Jackson Maine as a credible threat in the rock world.
Key Contributors to the Sound
- Lukas Nelson: Lead consultant and songwriter who gave the film its rock-and-roll heartbeat.
- Jason Isbell: Wrote the pivotal "Maybe It's Time."
- Mark Ronson: The pop mastermind who helped bridge the gap between the styles.
- Diane Warren: Contributed to the heartbreaking "Why Did You Do That?" and other sessions.
Interestingly, Cooper spent eighteen months in vocal training to drop his natural speaking voice by an entire octave. He wanted to sound like a man who had smoked too many cigarettes and played too many loud shows. That dedication is why the duets work. If he hadn't put in that work, Gaga would have blown him off the screen. Instead, their voices blend in a way that feels like two people who actually spend their nights together on a tour bus.
The Legacy of "I'll Never Love Again"
The finale is a gut punch. "I'll Never Love Again" is a powerhouse ballad that harkens back to Whitney Houston’s "I Will Always Love You." It’s the moment Ally fully embraces her stardom while grieving her loss.
There’s a piece of trivia that makes this song even heavier: Lady Gaga found out her close friend Sonja Durham had passed away from cancer right before she was supposed to film the final performance. Bradley Cooper told her she didn't have to do it, but she insisted on performing the song for her friend. That’s not "acting" in the final cut. That’s a woman actually mourning. You can hear it in the way her voice cracks slightly at the end of the song before the film cuts back to the quiet version Jackson sang to her at home.
Actionable Takeaways for Music Lovers
If you're revisiting the soundtrack or discovering it for the first time, don't just stick to the radio edits. The full soundtrack includes "dialogue" tracks that provide context, making it feel like a chronological story.
- Listen for the "Live" elements: Use a good pair of headphones to catch the stage noise in "Black Eyes" and "Alibi." It’s a masterclass in sound production.
- Check out the writers: If you liked "Maybe It's Time," go listen to Jason Isbell's album Southeastern. If you loved the ballads, look up the "Highwomen"—a group featuring several of the film's songwriters.
- Watch the performances: The visual cues in the "Shallow" sequence—how Ally hides her face until the big note—change how you perceive the vocal dynamics.
The enduring power of these songs isn't just about the celebrity names attached to them. It's about the fact that they were built on a foundation of real musicianship, live recordings, and a refusal to take the easy "studio" way out. They captured lightning in a bottle by being unapologetically loud and devastatingly quiet, all at the same time.